Is there a conscience today?

Candace 2022-03-21 09:03:03

"The Dreyfus incident is moving the world, but where is the poet in this vortex?" I first learned about the Dreyfus incident in Romain Rolland's "John Christopher", Two lines of note: French officer, accused of selling military intelligence to Germany, was rashly sentenced to life in exile. This matter caused a sensation in France, and wave after wave, caused the most serious political crisis in the Third Reich.

More than 100 years later, "I Complain" should be regarded as a response.

Much like the inverse of "Richard Jewell's Lamentations," told from the point of view of the investigator rather than the wronged, although the name "I accuse" sounds much more intense. After Zola's article, I thought it was the response of public opinion and the anger of the people -- they were indeed angry, they burned newspapers in the streets, and they wished they could burn Zola. After the powerful and powerful people read the sharp accusations in the newspapers, and they were shocked, guilty, and angry, I thought I could see the strength of the people. As a result, the next feature was the burned newspaper and Zola's other books. Then, the people surrounding the fire were really patriotic people, shouting "traitor, die!" At this moment, I suddenly felt that I was not just an audience, because this scene was too familiar. How can the honour of France be so slandered?

Senior officials protect each other, use the honor of authority to shut up our conscience, and we are forced to get used to the ugly reality. The honor shared by the group, if the conscience wants to destroy it, let the conscience die!

Until the end of the film, there are so many nearly lengthy court trials, but none of them are the villains who are tried and sent to prison, and their endings do not appear. It's difficult", which seems to be even more choking. I don't know much about this history, but the director's refusal to have a happy ending deprives the audience of the pleasure of punishing evil and promoting good. It is indeed very familiar. It is like "Chinatown" back then, and it is like life today.

There is no style that is too strong to be dazzling, but the cold brushstrokes and the somber tones are exactly the look of Polanski's films that I am familiar with, and it is still my favorite texture for writing history. The falling shredded paper was picked up on the desk, and the transition was amazing; the fencing duel scene was cold and meaningful.

I watched Elegy two months ago and was shocked that there are still such traditional movies today, but I don't like American classics; today's accusation may not be new enough, but I like this flavor, it's very classical and beautiful. From the perspective of female characters, the beautiful reporters in Elegy are young and pretty and can flirt well, but the symbolism makes me sick; Emmanuelle is old and has little connection with the case, but the image is very vivid, "It's nothing, I don't care about loyalty. Hope," and rejecting a lover's proposal after the dust settles, is far more charming, although it may also be a symbolic image of a French woman. Digression, last night, I dreamed that Emmanuel was still Mimi in "I Complain", which is amazing...

View more about An Officer and a Spy reviews

Extended Reading
  • Reginald 2022-04-24 07:01:22

    8/10. Polanski's skill is terrifyingly skilled, and the officers' rigid conversations and ritualized marches show great calmness, but the audience's indignation and the protagonist's sense of sacred responsibility are gradually driven. The focus is not on the ups and downs of the case (surveillance, secret meetings, warnings from superiors, forged letters, handwriting identification), nor on the victim's indictment (Dreyfus, at the beginning of the vast gray training ground, issued a faint The self-defense is still marginalized by the narrative after being removed from the military rank in public, and only briefly appeared in the experience of Alcatraz and the ending when the protagonist seeks debts), but focuses on depicting a pervasive anti-Semitic stench, from the protagonist to the The commander, who was dying from syphilis, accepted the order. The stench of rumors and prejudice was emanating from the old intelligence department building and the moldy stairs. Compared with the corrupt attempts of the state apparatus to kill those who bravely stood up and spoke out , Luncheons on the grass, nightclubs and opera houses and other gorgeous public spaces also spread malicious slander from the public, which eventually intensified into the newspaper burning activities against Zola and the Paris Crystal Night.

  • Lemuel 2022-03-26 09:01:12

    I am afraid that Polanski himself did not expect that a film that focuses on modern anti-Semitism in Europe and insinuates the rise of the far-right in Europe will actually dig a big hole for himself. Of course, you can't say that it has nothing to do with his experience at all, but that the emphasis is on his original sinful Jewish identity and nothing else. I still insist on this point: I have no right to talk and comment without seeing the film. The honesty and distortion, cowardice and tenacity, stubbornness and cunning, justice and corruption, hypocrisy and dignity, ruthlessness and humbleness of the people in "I Complain" all come from Polanski himself (personality or experience), you really can't tell if he's Dreyfus, Picard, or someone who insists he's right, maybe both, maybe not. To think that he is using this film to justify his innocence is a misreading and distortion of the multiple intentions of the film, not to mention blind bbw without seeing it. If he could explain it clearly with his mouth, he wouldn't make a movie, and if everyone could explain a movie with his mouth, then the movie wouldn't be attractive.

An Officer and a Spy quotes

  • Picquart: I want to see the Dreyfuss file.

  • Picquart: Dreyfuss is innocent.