Tango On A Thin Wire

Garett 2022-03-21 09:03:08

When I lit a cigarette outside Film Forum in a post-Beanpole daze, I felt like I just lost half of my life source. I have never experienced a film that translates immediate bodily sensations in such a visceral and disquieting way. Muffled ringing sounds, nose-bleeding attacks, frantic dancing turns into mania—the film's masterful use of involuntary physical condition traces the unimaginable pain of post-war trauma into a tangible form.

The film starts with Iya, a young nurse returning from World War II, standing still in front of a factory-like room. Frozen in motion save for some aberrant throaty noise, Iya is unaffected by people touching, pinching, or snapping her cheeks, not even blinking. After the deafening silence passed, Iya regained her consciousness and went on with her chores.

Later we learned the reoccurring ringing sound signals Iya's frozen fit, a post-concussion syndrome from the war that she has no control over, nor over the agency of her body. When the muffled ringing sound hits again while Iya is affectionately playing with Pashka, a three-year-old boy who the film initially misleads us to believe is Iya's child, I felt the audience tensing up their breath in the theatre. This time the fit lasts just long enough to suffocated Pashka, who turns out to be the son of her wartime fellow Masha.

When the disheartening death of Pashka is revealed to his mother, Masha's initial impulse is to "go dancing". Dancing is a metaphor for sex. Masha has bull-like eyes and energy. Her defense mechanism to incomprehensible pain is to have a human inside her body, be a penis or a child. When the wimpy boy uttered "Thank you" after their somewhat violent and un-erotic intercourse, the audience collectively chuckled while something deep inside of me brews into tears. I have received the same word from a stranger once in the same scenario. I felt infinitely, infinitely powerless.

View more about Beanpole reviews

Extended Reading
  • Arden 2022-04-19 09:02:44

    Want to love but why is love so passive and painful? This is the central question posed by the charismatic Slender Man. The young Balagov's answer in his restrained and poised historical melodrama is neither unique nor uncommon: because love is cold head to toe in such a twisted, complex, and hopeless scientism lie. War destroys people's bodies and souls, and seems to have taken away the rights and conditions that people have to breed happiness. Even if the ruler tells you that this is a disaster without miracles, irrational love still grows out of the gap between people. This kind of love that naturally emerges from the scar and the love that comes out of the painful childbirth in the womb finally forms a stark contrast. The irreconcilable contradiction is as striking and eye-catching as the red and green color matching. The difference between the two is that the identity, status and future of the latter are all tied to the child, while the former can live without a child, because that large dark red is the noble faith itself.

  • Melba 2022-03-16 09:01:07

    It's a bit uncontrollable, but the characterization is very successful. "It" was born in the war and died in the depression after the war; "it" brings phantom pain like childbirth, and lingering like a scar; Abandon the cover shoe. "It" is a baby, a trauma of war, and a twisted hope. The performance adds extra points, the green skirt spinning is too beautiful and too disillusioned.

Beanpole quotes

  • Nikolay Ivanovich: Where would he have seen a dog? They've all been eaten.