Can we keep warm by hugging?

Bill 2022-03-21 09:02:48

The end of "Underground" presents an impossible picture of the dead revelling together. There are two reasons for this "impossible". First, the characters died in different ways in the war, and the existence of heaven (the heaven in memory or in history) is like the land far away from the mainland, and it is difficult to find out. The second is the protagonists who have been dehumanized by war. For the past, they cannot forgive but forget, and whether forgetting is selective is questionable—unless they go to extremes, and extremes mean "nothing." So all this is just the director's obscenity, ironic and sad.

The ending of "Shouting and Whispering" is also a kind of obscenity, but Bergman is more lazy, and directly uses the diary of the dead to replay the flashing memory scenes of childhood. What a rare realm to be in love with each other, even siblings, flesh and blood, and partners are exposed to the test of illness, mediocrity, or other more obvious elements. Hypocrisy or rejection, there are all kinds of gestures. It is not that the contradiction does not exist, it is just that it has not yet reached the moment of eruption. The words in the diary are full of warmth, but the eyes of the young girl in the camera are so melancholy. Could it be that she really doesn't understand, she's just been deceiving herself. Otherwise, how could even the priest say that her faith is stronger.
Bergmante is not kind, and knows that it is useless to talk too much. Don't waste the audience's constant shock, so in the paragraphs that the two sisters have ambiguous and repaired, they simply pull out the dialogue track and play Bach's a cappella cello. I've been listening to these two CDs almost every day these days, and no matter what environment they're placed in, they're always a barrier.

In contrast, the death caused by emptiness in "Girlfriend", and the young man who dared not show his face after the train passed by, the rational and restrained cruelty is too kind, even cruel. Because separation is the norm in life, even if we hug each other tightly.

View more about Cries & Whispers reviews

Extended Reading

Cries & Whispers quotes

  • Agnes: There's someone out there. Anna. There's someone out there.

  • Maria: Your arguments have always bored me.