The tragedy of Matteo

Weston 2022-03-21 09:02:52

Without any precautions, I was knocked down by this six-hour masterpiece, and my mood could not calm down for several days. The film depicts the lives, friends, lovers and families of the two brothers for more than 40 years. In addition to love, friendship and kinship, there are also political theories and life values ​​as social people... As long as you sink, you can always see the protagonist. own shadow.

"Newsweek" commentary, talking about the scene of Georgia being taken away by the police, causing the brothers to choose different life paths, the source of Matteo's tragedy may be here:
For Nicola, the more gregarious, easygoing brother, it leads him to a career as a quasi-Laingian psychiatrist. For the intense, angry Matteo, terrified by intimacy, freedom proves too threatening: he abandons his studies and joins the police, seeking refuge from his demons in a world of rules and regulations.

Here is a sentence Depicting matteo as "terrified by intimacy, freedom proves too threatening" might be easy to overlook. After the whole film is over, go back to the two brothers' trip to send Georgia back home, and you will have another insight.

How to enter Georgia's self-enclosed and helpless world, Matteo devoted himself sincerely, however, what did he gain? She worked so hard to bring georgia back to her dad, but was told to be nosy, so she got into a fight with her dad; and georgia made a big fight with him in the rain because the drawing book was peeked, making him aggrieved to death , Doubt about the relationship between people, too close to each other will hurt each other; and in the end Georgia was taken away by the police, the escape operation failed, his accumulated frustration after failing the exam has reached the extreme, and the two brothers officially A different path was chosen.

Since then, Matteo's heart has also been closed, resisting intimacy, whether it is love or family;

He was transferred from Sicily, passed by his home in Rome, and saw his mother supporting his debilitating father. Feeling guilty, he was speechless and drove past. In his brother's medical hospital, he met Georgia again, and a glimmer of hope rose in his heart. Then, the news of his father's death came at this time, which made him mentally burdened again, and his emotions were out of control. He drove fast, so the scene of arguing with his brother, embracing and crying, was heart-wrenching.

One of the episodes that puzzled me is: When Matteo first saw the wanted notice for his sister-in-law marked as "terrorist" at the police station, he asked, what should I do if I encounter such a wanted criminal? Colleagues told him bluntly that he could be killed directly. Similar scenes appeared again and again, and Matteo wiped the wanted avatar of "sister-in-law" again and again. It is conceivable that he imagined the encounter with the "sister-in-law" sister-in-law more than once in his mind. At that time, what should he do? He couldn't simply follow the orders, not only because she was his "sister-in-law", but also because he understood what her sister-in-law was like. Perhaps, it was this incentive that made Matteo more irritable, and even more intolerable that the world was black and white, making him viciously question a rich man on New Year's Eve, accusing him of using his power to pass the crime on his servants.

The "librarian" came to the police station, which seemed to bring him a first-line hope of rescue. However, in the end, the two phone calls were not connected, and the fireworks outside the window aggravated his loneliness. determined to give up everything...

View more about The Best of Youth reviews

Extended Reading

The Best of Youth quotes

  • Sicilian Commissario: What were you looking for, joining the Police?

    Matteo Carati: I wanted some rules.

    Sicilian Commissario: And what do you do, with these rules?

    Matteo Carati: I apply them

  • Andrea Utano: I watch the midnight sun sink towards the horizon, then it stops and doesn't enter the sea. I think of my father, mother, and you, how you've always said that everything is beautiful. I think you were right. Everything is truly beautiful.