I've seen a lot of everyone's film reviews, but I don't want to talk about feelings, and talk about the truth. I can't write this to you. Then let's talk about who is the murderer.
There are four versions of this murder. The thief's version, the wife's version, the victim's version, and the woodcutter's version. First of all, we must pay attention to a few points, that is, what these versions have in common.
1. The husband is dead. 2. The wife was fucked. 3. The wife ran away. 4. The dagger is gone. 5. The horse was ridden by a robber.
The more important similarities are as above, let's take a look at the differences in each version, which is quite interesting.
Robber's version: 1. People were killed by homicide, and they were finally killed through more than 20 master battles. 2. It was killed with his double-edged sword. 3. The woman let him kill. 4. He and the woman XXOO woman accepted it after a brief resistance.
Women's version: 1. People are killed by women. 2. People are killed with a single-edged dagger. 3. I am unwilling to XXOO with the robber. 4. If your husband hates yourself, you will kill others by mistake.
The version of the dead soul: 1. Suicide. 2. It is a dagger that kills oneself. 3. Suicide was because the wife was about to get along with the robbers and she was humiliated.
The woodcutter's version: 1. People are killed by robbers. 2. The murder weapon is a great sword. 3. The kung fu of the two is not good, just like a fight with a child. 4. The woman had a good idea with the robber, which led to a fight between the two men.
The author's personal analysis of the truth is as follows: 1. It will not be suicide. 2. It will not be killed by a woman. 3. People are killed by robbers. 4. Robbers and men don't have much effort. 5. If a woman wants to leave a man, it may be because the husband and wife are unhappy or something. 6. The dagger was picked up by the woodcutter and sold.
Why? Talk about the reasons.
First, the samurai will cut his belly when committing suicide, and it is not reliable to stab himself.
Second, in the three versions, women have to provoke and kill men. This condition is basically true. She will not and dare to do it herself.
Third, it can only be killed by a robber.
Fourth, judging from the character and conduct of the robber, if a womanizer's martial arts is strong, he will do a lot of harm, and he can be caught by a stupid fork, which is not very good.
Fifth, the woodcutter has nothing to do with them, and his views are more objective. The women he describes are neither loyal nor licentious, and more reliable, so what he said about women should be true.
Sixth, the dagger is gone, and in the end it can only be taken by the woodcutter, and the woodcutter is willing to adopt an abandoned baby and there is the possibility of atonement.
In fact, it only needs a small condition to be determined to know the truth, that is, the wound of the dead, the single toughness is killed by the woman, and the double blade is killed by the robber. Why doesn't the movie make it clear? Kurosawa is smart here because he is smart. This is a story without a foregone conclusion.
View more about Rashomon reviews
