Too many problems are intertwined in this extremely cruel movie

Lucile 2022-03-21 09:02:33

There are too many issues discussed in this film, especially through the echoes and contrasts of the plot, which creates a huge sense of shock, and it is difficult to calm down under the shock.

about war and survival

When it comes to Lebanon, the impression has always been a war-torn country. Although the living conditions of the Zane family are extremely poor, there is no war in the place where they live. The little girl who appeared behind was a refugee from Syria. She had to sell things by herself at a young age to make a living. Black mothers who smuggled from Ethiopia also come here to work. There is no worst, only worse.

The little boy Zane lives in a slum-like place with his large family. Neither of his parents seemed to be working, but they had five or six children who lived in harsh conditions. Small children have to go to the streets to sell homemade drinks for a living, going to school is non-existent. Zane followed his mother to buy medicines with fake prescriptions and dissolved them in water as a product for the prisoners. Later, in order to survive, he also painted a gourd and made such a "drink" to sell on the street. His mother was afraid that the child was too young to run around, so she tied the child's foot with a chain. Later, in the care of black children, Zane had to do the same. Such "learning ability" is so cruel in survival.

about fertility

In the first part of the film, the parents who are separated by a curtain are in ooxx, and the children are all awake and listening. Even if they live in such poor conditions, the family is crowded into one room, the children don't even have a decent bed, and the mother behind is still pregnant, and a new life is about to be born. It also echoes Zane's lawsuit against them at the end of the court, depriving them of the right to continue to have children. Not everyone in this world is qualified to be a parent.

The Ethiopian woman who smuggled in, found a job with false documents, worked hard to support herself and her child, and even took her child to the place of work and locked him in the toilet. Where is the child's father? The whole film is not explained.

About identity

There are agencies and channels for people to apply for asylum, Zane wants to go to Sweden, the agency asks him to find ID, he goes home, his dad is furious that people like them don’t have such a thing; his sister married at 11 The person was pregnant, died of bleeding outside the hospital, and was not admitted to the hospital because she had no identity; the black mother could only hide her child, because the child was born as a black family; the last shot is also the poster cover of the movie, Zane finally Have an ID photo.

At the end, I hope that every child in the world will be treated with kindness. It is a child who is not treated with kindness. Whose fault is it? Country, war, family, yourself, or is there really nothing wrong with anyone?

At the end, most of it comes from the real experience of the starring children. The little boy ended up living in Norway with his family (whatever it was). And what about kids and other people who don't have the ability (fame) or the money (bribes to brokers and smugglers) to go out and become "refugees"? Sweden and Norway, which are like paradise in the movie description, can go to what kind of people?

The movie is really miserable, so miserable that many people shed tears silently when they saw the ending, including me. But after I was moved, I couldn't help thinking of the Syrian child who died on the beach, because in that photo, European countries opened their doors to refugees, and with the influx of refugees, those people caused a terrorist attack and explosion. .. In this world, no one should be more contemptuous than another's life, but such stories of farmers and snakes make people wonder, will this world be better?

View more about Capernaum reviews

Extended Reading
  • Julius 2022-03-28 09:01:07

    A child who seems to be less than ten years old, there is sophistication in his eyes, there is discernment, there is stability after life's hard work, cool, swaying, indifferent, and there is no longer hope and no longer Wail solidified into deep and deep sadness, just imprinted in his pupils. There are a few scenes I really like, one where he wanders in the absurd children's paradise, stripping off the coat of the statue woman, exposing her breasts, a flash of urchin. In one case, an illegal immigrant mother was arrested. She had a baby to be fed at home. She expressed milk in the refugee camp. The milk and tears flowed down. The young mother raised her head, looked up at the invisible god, and cried, Forgive me God, forgive me my son. This scene hit my heart hard. A clear film, with a few specific people, can torture our conscience, let us care about the situation of a nation and a country, and let us jump out of crude political slogans and critics' blasphemy, the film is almost divine. - You see, there, there is a child, he has no home. #Bo Bonnie Movie Group#

  • Erna 2022-03-23 09:02:34

    Although similar realistic propositions have been shown many times in the works of Mandoza and Dane, and children's perspectives are not new, but compared to the former's fierce hand-held lens, Labaki chose to play steadily and return to the orthodox shooting method. , the style is no longer above the content, and the technique is of course much gentler. The two lines naturally converge, and at the same time, the whole chaotic and complicated environment is brought out from the perspective of Zain, so that the appeal in the court finally came lightly. Impressive again. Too frequent and intense drama conflicts may be contrary to the principle of realism, but I always feel inappropriate to use the word "tear jerking" to stamp such films hastily. The pain of life itself is not as simple as tear jerking. You can also look at "Shame", which was also included in the top five in the Olympics last year. The shortcomings of the two courtroom dramas have been selectively magnified by many people, but if you think about it carefully, it should still belong to the existence of the flaws. Looking back, this and the same year's "The Thief Family" really belonged to Yuliang for a while. Otherwise, it is guessed that according to the taste of the last Cannes jury lineup led by the big devil, the Palme d'Or will be awarded the Palme d'Or. Department.

Capernaum quotes

  • Zain: Your words pierce my heart. I no longer want to see you. You're heartless.

  • Zain: I want to make a complaint against my parents. I'd want adults to listen to me. I want adults who can't raise kids not to have any. What will I remember? Violence, insults or beatings, hit with chains, pipes, or a belt? The kindest words I heard were get out son of a whore! Bug off, piece of garbage! Life is a pile of shit. Not worth more than my shoe. I live in hell here. I burn like rotting meat. Life is a bitch.I thought we'd become good people, loved by all. But God doesn't want that for us. He'd rather we be washrags for others. The child you're carrying will be like I am.