Victim trauma is never a legal consideration

Rey 2022-03-20 09:02:35

The Sino-German Film Salon held by Nanyi and Goethe-Institut (China), 2019.4.21, "Come out of thin air" was screened at Nanyi Cinema. Teacher Wang Qiang from Nanyi University and teacher Shen Xiaoping from Nanyi exchanged views after the screening, and they benefited a lot. , in this will organize the record of part of the discussion and speech.

The director eschews political stance and creates with humanitarianism.

The essence of human beings is loneliness, and the joys and sorrows of human beings are not connected (Lu Xun). (The lawyer and girlfriend accidentally mentioned the child in front of the heroine)

The heroine is pulled by two forces. She appeared in court with great grief, resorting to law and justice, and even the perpetrator's father testified and apologized to her. This all shows that the world is beautiful and loving. The other comes from the power and impulse of the person in her, which finally manifests as a desire to be reunited with the people closest to her.

The heroine is undoubtedly brave and strong, and when the court announced the verdict, she did not show the hysterical despair and grievance I thought, followed by clear and organized actions.

After taking back the backpack with the explosives, she got her period, and from the day of the tragedy, her whole body was in a state of extreme tension, and at that moment she returned to the normal functioning of the human body. She makes a clear decision in a rational and sober state. Even if an appeal is expected, legal sanctions and a just trial have nothing to do with her. Pure revenge cannot heal the pain. 's long-cherished wish.

The law has always maintained the stability of the overall social order, and the trauma and blows suffered by people's hearts are not what legal institutions and legal practitioners need to consider, and this is what art needs to pay attention to. Many contradictions and problems of mankind will never be resolved. Art awakens people's hearts and does not undertake the responsibility of solving practical problems. If the original intention of changing the law is to solve social problems from the beginning, creation will eventually become preaching.

View more about In the Fade reviews

Extended Reading
  • Sigrid 2022-03-22 09:02:38

    Because it is a Fatih film, we have the right to ask it to look better.

  • Trevor 2022-03-21 09:02:59

    The "big picture (in a small way)" mentioned a few days ago has appeared. The closeness of the geographical and class background of the victim and the perpetrator makes the motive for the conflict pure. The traditional drama factors such as judicial relatives and friends disappear, and the pressure and responsibility are maximized. You thought there was a reversal, but nothing happened. It feels like everyone has no way out. There is little hope for a newborn. Everyone unanimously liked the movie. Stuck in the situation, I personally think the Palme d'Or can.

In the Fade quotes

  • Katja Sekerci: [attacking Edda in court] Look at me, you cunt! I'll kill you!