Ha 5--fragmented

Dannie 2021-10-13 13:05:32

After watching Ha5, I have a deep understanding of what is called a fragmented plot. Ha 5 books are very thick, so it is really difficult to adapt it into a movie. But seeing a movie that was dismembered to pieces by the director, I was still very upset. First of all, if you have not read the original, it is best not to watch this movie, because the plots are basically copied directly from the original. There is almost no connection between them. If you have never seen it before, you will have a strange feeling.
The movie should be climaxing, but Ha5, it feels like a piece of piece, as if there is a lot to show, but nothing is shown. Every chapter in the novel can be taken very brilliantly, but the director only extracts part of the content, and shoots according to the literal and simple content, so that the audience can "complement" the deep meaning according to the content of the novel. . The consequence of this is that the entire movie becomes a video novel, as if it exists only to complement the novel. When everyone is reading a novel, they will make up a scene you imagined in their minds. Now this lovely director has completely visualized this scene. He tells you: "Hey, this is the scene at the time. Look, it's similar to what you think?". However, in addition to some fanatical fans who like this feeling, I think the general audience would like to see a complete, in-depth and thoughtful adaptation of the film.
There was not much procrastination at the beginning of the movie, and Ha and the Dementors started to fight directly. Then the event is triggered. Back to the wizarding world, the hearing, the beginning of school, a few train shots, seeing the night ride, Umbridge, class, punishment, DA is established. It was done in one go, especially in the front. The scene changed so fast that I couldn't keep up with the director's rhythm. Why are you in such a hurry? The director deleted all the wordy sentences, leaving behind what he thought was the most classic sentence. However, the reason why the sentence is classic is that there is a story to serve as a foil for him, and a hard sentence is left behind without explaining anything, and the classic feeling is completely lost. After that, the plot will not be written one by one. The warm Christmas in the original book, the inseparable relationship between Harry and Sirius, the revelation of Professor Snape's memories to Harry, where did all these things go? I believe that all viewers who have watched Harbin 5 for the first time, if they have never read a novel before, absolutely ignore the death of the last Sirius. This buddy was completely adapted by the director and turned into a pure supporting role, as if his only purpose of existence was to give Harry provided some news. Hey. Not much to say, a really bad film.
One thing that stands out is the description of the section where the Weasley twins turned away from Hogwarts. I don't know how the director suddenly found it in his conscience at that time, and focused on describing it. It really left a very deep impression on me, and it can be regarded as a part that can embody the essence of the original work.
The final battle was messy, and it felt like a blast of guns. In the end, Harry made a cameo, symbolically wrestled with Voldemort, and said something thought-provoking. It's over.
After watching the film, he felt that Harry had grown up so much, and when he stood up and turned around, he forgot what he saw just now.
Feel free to comment. I like Ha5 very much, so I am looking forward to this movie. It is inevitable that there will be some personal feelings when commenting. Hami, please forgive me.

View more about Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix reviews

Extended Reading

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix quotes

  • Bellatrix Lestrange: [taunting Harry] I killed Sirius Black!

    [laughs]

    Bellatrix Lestrange: You coming to get me?

    Harry Potter: CRUCIO!

  • Bellatrix Lestrange: He knows how to play. Itty-bitty-baby-Potter.