Dismember 5

Arden 2021-10-13 13:05:32

2007.08.11 04:35

First of all, I have to say that my preferences for watching movies have always been quite personal. I don't think all movies are commented objectively.
so, please choose to watch.

I am a fan of the HP series. Ii original work, and also the four previous movies.
I always think that it is unfair to compare movies with original works because they are not the same starting line.
Just like "Lan Yu", I distinguished its original work from the film.

But from the point of view of selfishness, as a loyal reader of the original, it is impossible not to recall the plot in the book while watching the movie.
Today, I recalled the fifth book that I couldn't bear to mention more since I read the book.
Then I was disappointed.
And this time, there is really no way to look at the movie from the perspective of a movie-watcher.
Therefore, it is impossible to write a movie just how it behaves.


Let me summarize.
There was no nonsense at the beginning, and after a brief explanation, he went directly to the encounter with the Dementor. The dementors here have changed from the image in the third part. Their capes and hats are all gone, and if they are gone, they are gone. But after changing their image, it looks like they are watching the Necromancer in "The Mummy"?
The neighbor Mrs. Feige (if the name is mistaken, forgive me) kindly took in Xiao Ha and the content of her own identity was shrunk.
Then Xiao Ha was picked up -> the crowd met hurriedly -> rushed to the hearing without stopping -> somehow he arrived at the station and the school started. The pace is unparalleled, there is no nonsense, not even good things.

To school -> Umbridge -> Dumbledore's neglect -> Umbridge's punishment (this is actually a good point of inking for the mental activities of Hart, but shrinks) -> DA establishment -> Wes Mr. Lai was attacked -> Dumbledore suddenly threw Xiao Ha to the professor without an explanation (adapted) -> The professor just took Xiao Ha by surprise but didn't teach him how to practice "brain defense"? (Is it because the director didn't shoot or was it clicked by the scissors hand? OTL)...


Then KISS, which is known as a super selling point, appeared. The foreshadowing was weak and the progress was rapid... Please ignore the Qiu fans or Ha Qiu.

Then I had a nice~~~not lively Christmas...
——Many of the things in the book that are too detailed, to be honest, I can't recall all of them, and the content that is retained is relatively large.
For example, the professor’s memories, such as gifts, the laying out of Sirius’s character, such as this warm Christmas that involves the deep feelings between Sirius and Xiao Har...

Then go back to school -> Hagrid back -> see the professor's Memories (big adaptation + shrinking, here is a very important plot for Xiao Ha to reflect on himself and his father’s behavior... silently) -> DAs are caught (adapted, see also adapted. The betrayer becomes autumn... although not Volunteer, although I don’t like her, it makes people very uncomfortable) -> Seeing Hagrid's giant brother (adapted) -> Wizard rank exam (adapted) -> The twins stunned Hogwarts (handsome, even without The many splendid deeds in the book are still one of the impressive shots in this episode) -> Xiaoha was deceived -> Umbridge was unlucky -> The six-member team went to the Ministry of Magic -> War, Hit, hit, hit -> Sirius falls -> Voldemort appears, then flashes -> end.


The reason for the topic is dismemberment, because this is the biggest feeling I have gotten from sitting in the theater for two hours.
Maybe it seems that there are not many problems with fans of non-original fans, but the most unbearable thing for me is that everyone knows that movies are limited by space, and it is inevitable to cut down on the plot. However, in the plot left behind, it should be fulfilled and logically coherent. Instead of intermittent like I saw tonight, I just saw the plot performance and was immediately cut off, so I feel that no plot is complete. It's like sprinkling some soil in every pit, filling it up and occupying the site.
The film is most taboo to say everything, but the result is expressed but it makes people feel that it is not as good as not to say anything!

The adults' drama is pitiful.
Tonks is a little bit funny anyway. Lupin's appearance has changed and his lines are more streamlined. The Phoenix member who reselled things seems to be absent at all. The Weasleys' roles are also similar to those of a superhero, let alone Sirius... …

And Luna who is outstanding is indeed as praised, performing well and conforming to the best! That kind of subtle tone, distinctive manners, maturity older than her age... Her love directly led to how many people were struck by the wrists of Hermione who were rationed to Ron, infinitely hoping for Halu-of course, on The advent of Yueha 7 completely dispelled this idea.

Umbridge’s actor is indeed worthy of the drama. She is shuddering when she speaks with her accent. The viciousness behind her pretending to be cordial is indeed unmatched, laugh...

the scene of the crisscrossed crystal ball falling collectively Very seductive, the design of the patron saints of the DAs is quite interesting. In the end, the battle in the lobby of the Ministry of Magic seemed to be magnificent and thrilling, but I felt that the gimmick was real enough.
It reminds me of the last paragraph of Ha 4. Although Xiao Ha's method to deal with Voldemort is simple, the tricks are quite limited. In the end, he managed to escape by relying on the help of his parents and friends. It is not a tricky thing, but it is full of sincerity. I was very nervous for him.
Today's big climax, while dazzling, there is a little bit missing. The lens will flicker quickly and will be forgotten quickly.


Without further ado, I admit that my personal emotions are heavier for the book Ha5.
And I have never, rarely, resented a movie like this.
So my viewing experience may be biased and not calm enough.

Ha 4, which has also cut a lot of plots, compared with Ha 5, it really makes me feel that it was a pity that I only watched it three times at the beginning!
This is the first movie that I don't want to see again in the near future since the HP series started. The treatment is surprisingly similar to the book, but for such a different reason.


above.


View more about Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix reviews

Extended Reading

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix quotes

  • Bellatrix Lestrange: [taunting Harry] I killed Sirius Black!

    [laughs]

    Bellatrix Lestrange: You coming to get me?

    Harry Potter: CRUCIO!

  • Bellatrix Lestrange: He knows how to play. Itty-bitty-baby-Potter.