Judgment from the Other

Nelle 2022-03-13 08:01:01

"Trial" is a legal word, and many images related to law are used in the story, such as courts, lawyers, police officers, etc. Many people say that this story is a critique of the absurdity of the law, but I disagree. I think this view All are the result of interpreting the story from a realistic perspective. However, both Williams' films and Kafka's novels are obviously surreal, so the court in the story may not be able to match the court in real life, and the "justice" sought by the protagonist K is not real The justice of the meaning of the law is the justice of being born as a human being. Similarly, the legitimacy he seeks is also a kind of legitimacy about human existence, not legality in the legal sense. This point is actually pointed out in the story. In Kafka's novel, the courts that tried K were not the courts located in the government buildings, but the courts hidden in the narrow and closed attic. In the movie, although the place where the court is located has a huge gate, which symbolizes the superiority and inviolability of the law, it is full of people - this is also the same as the description in Kafka's novel, no matter how small the court in the story is. It is cramped or spacious, and it is full of crowded people. Therefore, it can be said that the so-called "trial" is actually a mutual "trial" between people. That is to say, the question discussed in this story is actually how people interact. The problem of getting along, in this sense, Kafka's "Trial" not only inspired Camus to create "The Outsider", but probably also inspired Saudi Arabia to create "Trial in Quarantine" (also translated "Confinement"), from Saudi "others". From the perspective of hell”, it is also possible to obtain a reasonable interpretation of The Trial.

The story is full of lengthy dialogues, but the absurdity is that there is no real understanding between people. From the landlady, to the neighbor Miss Burstner, to the confession to the crowd at the first trial, K's words always seem to be To be misunderstood, taken out of context, and intentionally distorted, this is the real situation in which each of us lives, so the "judgment" actually comes from any other than the self. There is no real love and kindness between people, which can be seen from the relationship between K and several women. In this sense, the story reveals the lonely situation in which people exist in the world. In this situation, personal innocence And justice will be drowned in the clamorous crowd.

:! ^ =

View more about The Trial reviews

Extended Reading
  • Josianne 2022-03-16 09:01:09

    @大館JC CUBE | Technically flawless, Perkins's lanky appearance and eccentric alienation are not bad, and the cast also has Romy Schneider and Jeanne Moreau. However, Kafka's spirit and energy only appeared briefly in a few bright moments at most (K's shadow near the end/K was hit on the wall by the dwarfed shadow of the three people who held him from left and right). After reading and watching the absurdity of Eastern Europe, I deeply feel that this kind of subject should be left to others to shoot...

  • Alphonso 2022-03-26 09:01:14

    Ao Fatty has a strong personal color, maximizes the stimulation of sound and picture/scenario aesthetics, and tortures the audience psychologically with the system's unorganized oppression and distortion of the dialogue that reverses the protagonist's words. Chatting around the wood-slatted room corridor is nothing short of a horror movie! The protagonists are all beautiful, the little witch in white, Luo Mi, is super cute, and the director's final narration makes me laugh and cry. The new building apartment is Le Corbusier? Pick the empty ground floor...@大光. PS and the version played by Pinter screenwriter Kyle in 1993 have their own advantages and disadvantages. In terms of reproducing the rhythm and temperament of the original, I think the later version is more clear and cold (die like a dog).

The Trial quotes

  • Joseph K.: I make you very uncomfortable, don't I? It distresses you to find me in your company. Yes, I've been told about that. Before, I thought you took me for a judge or at least an official of the court. I even thought you were afraid of me, but what you're feeling is pain. You don't like what you see, do you? It's my mouth. You think you can tell from my mouth that I'm condemned, that I'm going to be found guilty? Guilty!

  • Joseph K.: There are several possibilities I haven't explored yet.

    Priest: You expect too much from outside help, especially from women.

    Joseph K.: Women have influence! Take that Examining Magistrate. If he sees a woman, he'll climb over the bench and knock down the defendant just to get his hands on her. Yeah, that's an aspect of the courts you probably don't know about.