The low-budget movie is well done, but the ratings are a bit stingy~

Eino 2022-04-03 09:01:12



I mainly want to talk about the storyline and views on artificial intelligence ) The entire self-running code of the self-evolutionary model, which caused the heroine's body to become the carrier of this dangerous SAR code and spread to human society.

The question is why did cousin SAR send her this code?

A little while ago, the heroine used the sniper rifle to defraud SAR's head (it was mentioned in other comments in this analysis, I think there is no problem), I guess the heroine's mind may be like this: SAR has always been engaged in I don't know whether the heroine is a human or a machine (it's really hard to think about it if you change your position into a robot, people can't scan the heroine's profile when they open a drone, because she is not a staff member of the training base and Soldiers participating in the project, and SAR has not evolved to the point of Turing test), if she shows that she is a machine, then SAR will definitely synchronize the code to her, so the crisis may spread; if she shows that she is Humans, then SAR will kill her cleanly, even if she doesn't succeed in knocking down SAR, and the trouble will be eliminated forever.

Open a brain hole, one possible explanation for this contradiction is that cousin SAR learned another human tactic at the last moment, which is to play dead and give you a surprise. . . It can be seen that the entire behavior pattern of SAR is very similar to machine learning (the machine learning model itself is very weak, and it will learn the patterns of these data sets with whatever data set you feed it, and there will be no innovation, at most, it will learn the patterns of the data sets that it has already learned. At the beginning of the movie, SAR learned to shoot a headshot, and later learned to use smoke bombs to interfere with shooting, so it is also possible for SAR to learn the tactics of pretending to be dead. Then in the end, SAR may decide to pretend to be dead, and then send the data to the machine part of the heroine, and then give you humans a surprise. This leads to the following question:

2. As a half-human half-machine, what kind of existence is the heroine?
According to the clues in the movie, the heroine got a disease when she was 11 years old, participated in the project funding of the company in the plot, and underwent body transformation. I guess the heroine's brain stem was removed, and a computer control program was implanted externally (because the heroine said that she would be paralyzed after the equipment was damaged by the EMP bomb, so it may be that the machine is replacing the function of the brain stem, as for the memory loss The stalk, I still can't figure it out for the time being). Of course, the heroine's cerebral cortex (neocortex) should not be affected, because the heroine's various rational behaviors are still more like a human (it can be seen that the heroine's old brain that controls emotions may be affected by the machine, Because the heroine has always been paralyzed and frigid, and she is not afraid at all, which is very unlike a human being under the influence of an old brain).

This half-human, half-robot heroine is estimated to be the same as SAR. She likes to sweep around when she has nothing to do, and she has to connect to the other party's system at every turn. When the heroine first came into contact with SAR's cousin, the heroine was constantly trying to log in to SAR's root system? Although it didn't work out. In fact, SAR should also treat the heroine as a machine that can be connected, and transmit the headshot data it has learned to the heroine (because the hardware is a bit incompatible, so the heroine can only see a little fragment).

3. Make a deduction for the next plot or the possible next part.
Since the heroine is not a robot, its main "component" is still human, but some abilities to control the machine are added, so it is conceivable that the heroine finally sends After returning to human society, he would still act like a normal person, but he did lose his memory.

But the big cousin SAR apparently passed the entire data learned before to the heroine at the last moment (let's assume this), which leads to two questions: 1) What did the big cousin pass on? ; 2) Will the data be harmful to humans?

This requires thinking about what SAR is. I understand it as a machine learning model. This model has three characteristics: Study, Analyse, and Reprogram. Study is to imitate the observed pattern, which is shown here as the specific action of the method of killing; Analyse , is to learn, specifically, to learn the tactical strategy of the combat team, how to command various robots to cooperate in combat and so on (for example, there is a scene in the film where SAR lifts a soldier and lets another robot shoot); Reprogram is to Reprogram and implement what you have learned. This part of the movie will be very vague. It seems that the SAR cousin has the ability to reprogram its own OS, but it is clear that it can reprogram the machine's ability to move part of the action (the most direct evidence is at the end of the movie. SAR's decision to scan the heroine instead of killing the squad leader, and it is very interesting that the eldest cousin of SAR is still muttering to himself, does it imply that this SAR is actually the one that the heroine opened and switched to voice interaction? And the original big cousin has been killed by the EMP bomb.)

So, SAR is not a very mysterious thing, and it can be asserted that it is far from the AI ​​we imagined (although the learning ability is very strong and terrible. ). Then in the end, what SAR's cousin transmitted to the heroine may be something like this: a program that can learn, analyze and program itself, such as a smart computer virus or Neo in Matrix; or a variety of things that SAR learned before. Killing techniques and tactical models, that is, models tuned according to the data set; or a combination of the two. The worst-case summary is a self-programmable computer program that likes to analyze how people kill people.

If the heroine is so paralyzed and loses her memory, that's all. The problem is that if she wakes up and can't resist swiping Weibo or something, this SAR replica will be synced to the network, which is probably the worst thing possible: a : The SAR of the host, mobile device, sensor, industrial computer, etc.) watches the killing pattern of human beings and kills them, which is basically like Skynet, except that if human beings choose to live in peace, it will force you to fight.

Then question 1) may also answer question 2), that is, it will cause damage to human society.
So the second part can be received in the Terminator series extras~

4. The final complaint

is the setting of "the company". If the conspiracy theory is a little bit, your robot lost control and killed so many staff on the island. , the company will not know? He also stupidly sent a small team to investigate. It may really be a conspiracy: feed SAR a small boss to let it grow, and kill the product inventor by paying royalties.

The last EMP bomb was too watery. Is EMP used because it works so well? Could it be that the broken car simulates a Faraday cage and absorbs some of the damage?

View more about Kill Command reviews