This is a movie that can sanitize the mind

Carrie 2022-12-26 16:53:44

When Harvey, the warden of Alcatraz, discovered the bird breeder, Bos. After Troud's manuscript on the attack on the prison system, the two had a "horrifying" conversation -


- you never once showed signs of reforming

- reforming?

— yes, rehabilitated

— I wonder if you know what that word means.


The unabridged version of Webster's International Dictionary says the word comes from the Latin root Habilis, which is defined as: to restore dignity.

Have you considered that part of your job is to give a person the dignity he once had?

Your only interest is how he behaves.

You said it to me once a long time ago, and I never forget: "You should behave as we want".

For 35 years, you didn't back down an inch from your position, you wanted your inmates, danced like marionettes outside the door, and it was all in compliance with the mandatory values ​​you established, in compliance with your requirements for obedience, for behavior. The norm, and even your sense of morality, Harvey, that's why you failed, you and your entire science of prison management failed, because you stole from prisoners the most important thing in their lives-- their personalities.

After going out they are lost, like robots, with a step-by-step life, but have a deep, deep hatred in their hearts for what you have imposed on them, and once they have a chance to take revenge on society, they won't let it go. The result? More than half returned to prison.

After listening to the above "horror" conversation, I suddenly realized that some so-called school education is no different from prison education. The difference is that the former gives partial freedom but is depicted as a so-called "new" from a blank sheet of paper, while the latter is compulsory education to "rehabilitate". As well as some rhetoric that promotes "collective" - ​​"you should behave in accordance with our requirements", "according to the mandatory values ​​you have established, your requirements for obedience, norms for behavior, and even your sense of morality ".

——Some education and some propaganda received in the past are "toxic".

A good movie can really purify the mind and purify the brain!


Written in watching "The Shawshank Redemption"
2013.1.3

Note: "The Bird Breeder of Alcatraz" was watched at the end of December 2015, and on the last night of the New Year's Day holiday in 2016, I found the film while watching "The Shawshank Redemption" There is also a bird breeder, so he took the opportunity to write down his feelings to prevent forgetting.
(The scene appeared during Andy’s first meal in prison. He found a bug, and an old inmate next to him saw it, asked for the bug, and fed it to the young bird that was still in his pocket. I don’t know if it’s an Easter egg buried by the director, or just a coincidence)

View more about Birdman of Alcatraz reviews

Extended Reading

Birdman of Alcatraz quotes

  • Robert Stroud: Why did you come 2,000 miles for nothing? Just to see me once a month?

    Stella Johnson: I came because I'm your wife, that's why. Bob, the only life I got is you.

    Robert Stroud: Then you've got a damned poor future, old girl. I'm never gonna get outta here.

    Stella Johnson: I could get a job in a factory. I could write letters every day. It would be like old times.

    Robert Stroud: You'd wither away and die waiting. Forget it, Stell. It's the end of the line.

    Robert Stroud: Please, Bob.

    Robert Stroud: Now, listen to me. Listen carefully. You fought your heart out for me. You fought your heart out for me, but the sun's gone down. And don't look for it to rise again. I want you to pretend that I'm a dead man. I want you to pretend... that you're standin' on my grave.

  • Harvey Shoemaker: Bob... I've been sent here as a delegate of the Bureau to make you an offer.

    Robert Stroud: That's what I've been waiting for.

    Harvey Shoemaker: Now the bureau is willing to let you keep your birds. You can even sell 'em. Now this is their official proposal. You can continue to raise and sell the birds, but the profits will be turned over to the prison welfare fund, and you will receive a salary in the form of a share of the profits. I consider that quite a generous offer under the circumstances. Frankly, it's more than I would have offered, had I the authority.

    Albert Comstock: Well, Stroud?

    Robert Stroud: Let me see if I understand you. You're proposing that the United States government go into the canary-bird business. That's against private enterprise. You sound like a Bolshevik, Harvey.

    Albert Comstock: You have no legal right to raise canaries at all.

    Robert Stroud: I know. Rule 60 of the Federal Bureau of Prisons Manual: "An inmate cannot be permitted to operate a business, no matter how legitimate, while in prison." That right?

    Harvey Shoemaker: You quoted it correctly.

    Robert Stroud: That's what I thought. That's why I'm confused. The rule says I can't have a business. You say I can, provided I give you the profits. It's reinventing regulations. It's not like you.

    Albert Comstock: Mr. Shoemaker came all the way from Washington to try to work out a plan so you can keep your blasted birds.

    Robert Stroud: Don't con an old con, Warden. He came because of public opinion, and you know it. 50,000 signatures on a petition. Congressmen jumping all over MacLeod's back. I think I got you over a barrel, Harvey.

    Harvey Shoemaker: Is that you last word?

    Robert Stroud: I could use more room. For my birds.