urban birder

Coralie 2022-09-03 03:11:03

When the modern state of production pervades the whole society and life is divorced from its own essence, it becomes a massive accumulation of landscapes, and everything that exists directly is only a distant appearance.
-

Debord John Frankheimer's The Birdman of Alcatraz, based on a true story, Robert Stroud, rebellious and irritable, was sentenced to 12 in 1909 for murder In 2008, he killed the jailer who prevented his mother from visiting the prison and faced life in prison. The turning point of his life came from his accidental discovery of an injured little sparrow. The careful care not only made the little bird's injury better day by day, but also gradually repaired his scattered mind and long-broken disposition. Prisons also found that allowing prisoners to keep birds would directly help reduce management costs, and they advocated it. Eventually, Robert Stroud became an internationally renowned ornithologist, the "Birdman of Alcatraz," experimenting in prison, medicating, and publishing monographs.

The word bird breeder reminds us of Beijing Renyi's play "Bird People" - a story about a group of urban "idlers" related to birds: the former famous Peking Opera actor San Ye, who is good at raising birds, is well-mannered when it comes to singing, reading and fighting. From time to time, he tells about the cultural connotation and bitterness behind the behavior of bird raising. He is the spiritual leader of a gang of birders. Humans and birds have built a mutual understanding, which has become a reversal of the reality of the decline of Peking Opera and no successor, and it is also the third master's rehearsal of an ideal world. Ding Paulo, a psychoanalyst who returned from overseas, tried to cure the mental illnesses of these bird farmers and dig deep into the various problems of the national subconscious, so he set up a mental rehabilitation center for bird people. In the end, the third master gave him a psychoanalysis in the way of "Bao Gong's trial", and staged absurd farces.

The relationship between the two kinds of "bird people" and the two kinds of urban bird farmers and birds can be compared to the two possibilities of "self-organization" of vulnerable groups: the former, with the attitude of "healing", cares for vulnerable groups carefully, and treats them with care. It is regarded as a means of guarding self-moral perfection; the latter, with the attitude of "cultivation theory", brings oneself and vulnerable groups into a scene of mutual encounter, and jointly builds a way to the unknown field. From the attitudes of two bird breeders towards birds, we can clearly understand: In Robert Stroud, the premise of personal value establishment is that birds are victims of diseases, and there is no possibility of their own cure, so they need people With the help of people, we can continue those basic survival guarantees; and in Sanye, the value of personal behavior lies in the realization of those unsustainable ambitions in people from the bird. With his careful teaching, birds can be separated from their natural life attributes, and under a series of disciplines in line with aesthetic connotations, they have become famous names sought after by bird breeders. Simply put, it is "people are after birds", not "birds are in need of people".

View more about Birdman of Alcatraz reviews

Extended Reading
  • Winfield 2022-06-21 21:35:33

    Re-watching in 2019, it is amazing. It's actually such a scientific story. Burt's performance is particularly moving. He shows the rebelliousness at the beginning and the soft side of human nature that he occasionally shows later, which makes people feel distressed. There are waves in the story, and it is in every detail, and the sympathetic love is also played with full enthusiasm. It is quite heart-wrenching in several places, and no character is monotonous and flat. It was the first time I saw it in a group activity, and Da Qi Te gave a lecture. 20091026 said: Take it as a traditional inspirational film, but I always feel that it is not magical enough. The language of the lens is very brilliant, and I agree with what the water horsefu said, and many of the problems in it are explored in a general sense. For the first time, I stood at Shupa and watched a whole movie with C~ Everything starts from a new one~~

  • Marley 2022-06-21 18:46:53

    Similarities between prison and education: trying to change a person, always trying to make him behave according to his own standards, but forgetting the most fundamental source of respect and motivation for the individual - interests and goals.

Birdman of Alcatraz quotes

  • Elizabeth Stroud: Sit down, Robbie. I want to talk to you about her.

    Robert Stroud: About Stella?

    Elizabeth Stroud: Your association with her will bring you nothing but trouble.

    Robert Stroud: I don't know what you mean.

    Elizabeth Stroud: I thought from the start she's the wrong kind of a woman for you to align yourself with.

    Robert Stroud: She's worked her heart out for me. She saved my bacon.

    Elizabeth Stroud: All right. She was of use temporarily, but she's served her purpose. And now if you'll follow my advice, you'll get rid of her.

    Robert Stroud: I don't understand what you're talkin' about, Mom. She's my wife.

    Elizabeth Stroud: Your trouble began with that other woman in Alaska. She's the same kind of a woman. She's a common adventuress.

    Robert Stroud: Don't say things like that, Mother. She's a good woman. And she's kind. And she'd do anything in the world for me.

    Elizabeth Stroud: It's disaster, Robbie. She'll bring you nothing but heartache. Besides, all she wanted was the publicity.

    Robert Stroud: Mother... you can't be serious. I can't believe this is happening.

    Elizabeth Stroud: Give her up, Robbie. Forget her.

    Robert Stroud: You act as though you wanted me here for all time. With you as my only outside connection.

    Elizabeth Stroud: Then you choose her instead of your own mother?

    Robert Stroud: Don't say any more, Mother. Please.

    Elizabeth Stroud: That's your decision? To desert me?

  • Robert Stroud: Why did you come 2,000 miles for nothing? Just to see me once a month?

    Stella Johnson: I came because I'm your wife, that's why. Bob, the only life I got is you.

    Robert Stroud: Then you've got a damned poor future, old girl. I'm never gonna get outta here.

    Stella Johnson: I could get a job in a factory. I could write letters every day. It would be like old times.

    Robert Stroud: You'd wither away and die waiting. Forget it, Stell. It's the end of the line.

    Robert Stroud: Please, Bob.

    Robert Stroud: Now, listen to me. Listen carefully. You fought your heart out for me. You fought your heart out for me, but the sun's gone down. And don't look for it to rise again. I want you to pretend that I'm a dead man. I want you to pretend... that you're standin' on my grave.