The Experiment of Obedience---The Experimenter's film review record

Zion 2022-04-04 08:01:01

"The change is real, it's lasting, and it's in your life very quickly." We are influenced by and obey authority because human nature wants to be less and less thoughtful, like The Road Less Traveled The "entropy" mentioned in the implementation process is actually not as rational as one thinks, but relies more on letting others make decisions and be responsible. That's how the truth came about, even though you rejected it in your heart, you did it anyway. Before we know it, we all become "executioners", either to ourselves or to others. This experiment was done in 1961. If the current experiment is not voltage but something else, it is hard to imagine what the result will be. People will refer to other people's opinions for uncertain things, and obeying authority makes people feel "safe" , After the voltage is excessive in the experiment, everyone will look back at the person who set the experiment, but nothing has changed much. The one who responded more is an electrical engineer~ But in fact, the volts of the voltage is a common sense. Not just authority, but also the submissive influence of groups, and experiments with line length in the film. There is no objection to obedience in the film, just the tragedy of uncontrolled obedience. The shooting method is also very unique, using Shakespeare's narration style, and the color scheme of the set and the rendering of the atmosphere have a feeling of nothingness. "Most people in the experiment pressed the last level, and no one went to the next room to check, although no one forcibly forbid it, just verbally said, you must continue, even though I was wrong, I was too much Yes, I am against human nature, you have to continue, there is no reason, this is an experiment". People will be domesticated, and the rules can be used in the opposite direction or in the opposite direction. "No one is persecuted!" The test is whether people will think through and make behavioral decisions. The result of the experiment is that people understand the importance of their own behavior. A lot of people have doubts in their hearts, I shouldn't have done it, but I did it anyway, and this is why, and it makes me blame myself. We always think that all human behaviors are caused by inner thoughts, but sometimes people's behaviors also depend on the environment he is in. At this time, the power of the situation overcomes the power of the human heart. In a sense, the development of modern society means that people become less and less thinking, become more and more machines, and become more and more distant and lonely, because more and more things can be done without cooperation. . No one can take responsibility for you, even if he says so, even if he is an authority. The importance of self is often overlooked. The book written by the professor of the experiment is called "Submission to Rights", the professor is: Stanley B. Milgram. 65% would raise the voltage to 450 volts (maximum), "People don't have the guts to resist authority, that's what the experiment tells me." 35% felt responsible for their actions and blamed themselves a lot. This data may have changed a lot to date. What we believe, in fact, we do not believe, and what we condemn, in fact, we cannot change. Many people look at the sky and watch this experimental film, which is the "multiple ignorance effect". It still applies today. Kafka is mentioned twice in the film. Why don't you believe in yourself. The experiment was controversial and was nominated for an award. The details of the costumes in the play are very reference to that era. Rights and conscience confront each other. "There was a time when I felt that there was a human response in all situations, both men and women, and I felt like we could be called human and accepted by the world, but now it's often that people don't see the whole situation, Seeing only a small part, human beings have begun to divide their labor and engage in specific work in a narrow field. Our every move has to stand at a high point and look at the overall situation. I call this the agency state.” (meaning letting others act as agents. you) a person can choose whether you become an agent or not, but once you are in it is very hard to get out. (The original words are that it is impossible to get out.) This is also a misguided authoritative. Disrespect the facts, listen without hearing, let alone think according to the facts. "When we choose the other half, we also choose the current situation." At the end of the film, it is said that the results of the experiments redone in recent years are not much worse or even more serious. Self-awareness is the first step towards liberation. ) This is also an authoritative misdirection. Disrespect the facts, listen without hearing, let alone think according to the facts. "When we choose the other half, we also choose the current situation." At the end of the film, it is said that the results of the experiments redone in recent years are not much worse or even more serious. Self-awareness is the first step towards liberation. ) This is also an authoritative misdirection. Disrespect the facts, listen without hearing, let alone think according to the facts. "When we choose the other half, we also choose the current situation." At the end of the film, it is said that the results of the experiments redone in recent years are not much worse or even more serious. Self-awareness is the first step towards liberation.

All of them were memorized in the process of watching the movie, so I just recorded them. There is no logic in many places, so I just record them.

View more about Experimenter reviews

Extended Reading

Experimenter quotes

  • Stanley Milgram: I believe we are puppets with perception, with awareness. Sometimes we can see the strings. And perhaps our awareness is the first step in our liberation.

  • Stanley Milgram: Human nature can be studied but not escaped, especially your own.