Stylization is never the reason why movies are bad

Rebeca 2022-06-20 21:51:43

This is an Indian colonial version of "Spring in a Small Town", but the latter is limited to a subtle and bitter atmosphere, or that film can only refer to something else because it can't refer to too much, an awkward end, It makes the spring of a small town out of the reality shown by the image.

The real foothold of this "Black Narcissus" is not in this fake studio and deliberately setting contradictory daily situations, but in the light in the movie! In the stylized theatrical plot, the light in the natural illusion literally replaces the existence of God (character). Precisely because religion is a certain kind of transcendental, separated from the secular power, it is so easy to fall into the (movie) poles, it becomes a secular, naturalistic experience. In the film, it is not represented by the "plot" outside the camera, but a desire-image similar to Spring in a Small Town. Through the perspective of others, natural spaces and desires are symptomatized and become bright lights/colors. As the situation continues to fall into dilemma, natural codes are constantly "idolized" and become fetish objects or icons. In fact, there is no need to Distinguish the two, as fetish symbols are one, and both can easily lead to the behavioral logic of the individual, making the situation completely destroyed. In the film this is precisely the nun's revenge through stylized melodrama. But in the process, we encountered weak light and constant or even out-of-control close-ups. This is not a simple stage play leading to destruction, but the opposite pole to which the image falls.

The image itself is the speech and does not need to be actively expressed. When the audience gazes at the icon, it is silent, and so is God. It was in silence that the nun who was retaliated and threatened with death saved the faith and did not let it slide to the extreme end of destruction. So the light and close-up in the film are the symptoms of desire and the existence of belief in God. In the eyes of the melodrama audience, it is undeniable that Sister Ruth still went to destruction at the end, but her destruction did not end the image, but became a way for the image to speak itself and be reborn in faith. Between the confusion of God's silence and the destruction of the situation, Sister Clodagh found a way for faith to exist. Where faith exists, it is the presence of light, and it is also where the image speaks itself.

The hearty rain at the end shows that although God is silent, the movie will not end in silence. This is the image's response to belief.

View more about Black Narcissus reviews

Extended Reading

Black Narcissus quotes

  • Mother Dorothea: -

    [With Sister Clodagh: looking at photos of the palace at Mopu]

    Mother Dorothea: The house is nine thousand feet up - very cold, but good air. General Toda Rai, who has invited us to Mopu, has promised us every help. He was a little afraid when he learned that we are bound to our order only by yearly vows. I explained this rule to him.

    Sister Clodagh: Yes, Reverend Mother.

    Mother Dorothea: For more than a century, to serve voluntarily has been one of the glories of our Order.

    Sister Clodagh: And our greatest strength.

    Mother Dorothea: Exactly. He understands now. Is there anything you would like to ask?

    Sister Clodagh: Who am I to take with me?

  • Mother Dorothea: [the Reverend Mother and Sister Clodagh survey the sisters of the Order, determining who will go to Mopu] Remember, a community is not a class of girls. The sisters won't be easy to manage or to impress. Now, let me see. I'll give you Sister Briony. You'll need her strength.

    Sister Clodagh: Thank you, Reverend Mother.

    Mother Dorothea: Sister Philippa for the garden... Sister Blanche.

    Sister Clodagh: Sister Blanche?

    Mother Dorothea: You know what the other girls call her?

    Sister Clodagh: Sister Honey.

    Mother Dorothea: Yes, Honey. I think you'll need Sister Honey. She's popular. And you'll need to be popular... And Sister Ruth.

    Sister Clodagh: [Surprised] But Sister Ruth is ill.

    Mother Dorothea: That is why I want her to go.

    Sister Clodagh: Forgive me for saying so, Reverend Mother, but do you think our vocation is her vocation?

    Mother Dorothea: [Nodding knowingly] Yes, she's a problem. I'm afraid she'll be a problem for you, too. With a smaller community, she may be better. Give her responsibility, Sister. She badly wants importance.

    Sister Clodagh: Do you think it's a good thing to let her feel important?

    Mother Dorothea: Spare her some of your own importance... if you can.

    Sister Clodagh: Mother, are you sorry that I have been appointed to take charge of St. Faith?

    Mother Dorothea: Yes. I don't think you're ready for it, and I think you'll be lonely. Never forget: we're an order of workers. Work them hard. And remember... the superior of all is the servant of all.

    Sister Clodagh: I understand.