"Red Dead Redemption": Even Leoni is copying Akira Kurosawa?

Grayce 2021-10-22 14:31:24


I heard early on that "Red Dead Redemption" was adapted from Kurosawa Akira's "Intentional Stick", but there are many ways to adapt it. The most outstanding adaptation is new wine in old bottles, to create a second time. The worst adaptation is to copy it intact. I really don’t know it. I was shocked when I saw it, except that the scene of "Red Dead Redemption" changed from a Japanese village to a small western town, with a knife turned into a gun player, other character designs, plot trends and even line processing were almost the same as Kurosawa. The previous works of Ming Dynasty are exactly the same. I was stupefied that Leonne had directly taken Kurosawa's script and filmed it. It seems that this master who later made a great movie like "Once Upon a Time in America" ​​was also inevitable when he first debuted. Traces of imitation, or simply called worship.

Because of the bead and jade in the front, Leonnet’s adaptation seems quite satisfactory. The original political allegories and doomsday prophecies are all gone. Eastwood’s shooting posture is very handsome, and it’s cool to be surrounded by a blanket-like coat all over his body. To the extreme, but the calm tough guy is still inferior to Mifune Toshiro, who always shrugs his shoulders. After all, Mifune has won the Venetian actor twice (one of which was based on "Intentional Stick"), and Ister Wood later became an outstanding director, but his performances were more typified and idolized. No wonder the old man won the Oscar Director Award twice, but the film actor never paid attention (it seems that there are very few nominations)

View more about A Fistful of Dollars reviews

Extended Reading
  • Paris 2022-04-20 09:01:17

    A is on the left, B is on the right, and I am in the middle. Sure enough, it is a copy of "The Stick with Heart". Although the details of the plot have been changed, the credit for the overall play is definitely all from the Kurosawa group. But the film itself is still very good. Although it is a genre film with a very simple plot, the rhythm of the plot is really good. The chivalrous love is fully displayed in the overturning, and the environment of the wild and disorderly border town is slightly constructed. It's average, but with Morricone's classic music, the atmosphere immediately rises (but I have to say that it feels a little overwhelming), not to mention there is a 4K restoration on the big screen, which is so handsome that he has no friends. "You're going to need a coffin," indeed.

  • Elsa 2022-04-23 07:01:26

    The Italian team remakes the cool 1960s western film from Akira Kurosawa's works, with the title, the music, and the figure (being beaten)... Also, the martial arts film/Hong Kong gangster film really can't absorb the swordsman and western films. Little, the drunk man holding grass and the pony brother holding toothpicks are also replicas of Dongmu holding cigarettes in this play.

A Fistful of Dollars quotes

  • Silvanito: I'm alive, and I want to remain with the living, understand? And when I'm dead, I want to remain with the dead. And I would be unhappy if somebody living forces me to remain with the living.

  • Joe: [He's hiding in an empty coffin outside the coffin-maker's shop] Come here.

    Piripero: I can't see anybody.

    Joe: Come here!

    Piripero: [Goes over to a coffin on a wagon; Joe is inside] Dios mio!... What are you doing in there?

    Joe: Never mind. Get me out of here.

    Piripero: But, you're not dead yet.

    Joe: I will be, if you don't get me out of here, quick. Get that lid down!