The second half is an insult to IQ

Grayce 2022-03-23 09:01:17

I like the movie review (absolute belief and relative belief) of the currently hottest Moon Watcher! Basically speaking out about my flaws in this movie. Supplement below.

I thought it was pretty good when I watched the front, but the film fell apart from the moment when the sage asked the heroine whether she believed in God or not. I think as a scientist, the heroine's better answer to this question is: I don't need to believe in the existence of God. At present, there is no convincing evidence to prove that God exists, so logically I tend to God No, if there is strong new evidence one day, then I or even the entire scientific community will overthrow our previous views and convert to God. This is science. Science is not like mathematics. Science only relies on the available evidence (experimental results, etc.) to select the most likely hypothesis to produce these results. If there is a result that contradicts the original hypothesis in the future , then the scientific community is happy to overthrow previous assumptions and make new ones. So science is never right, it largely represents the most probable assumptions we can make with our current human cognition. In addition, to a senior NSA official in the film: Occam's razor is not for you to abuse, you ignore the premise of this principle - you even investigate whether the two assumptions you make can be perfectly explained The status quo is based on the subjective belief that both assumptions are reasonable, while one assumption is simple and the other is complex. It is necessary to investigate whether the big local tyrants manipulated the whole thing. If so, there will always be some clues left; and if the heroine really crosses, then there must be some abnormal evidence, such as 18 hours of video, etc. If it is true The only thing is that there is none at all, either this matter is really beyond the current human cognition, or this time-travel is false, so it is reasonable to make the inference that the heroine has not traveled through (it can only be reasonable, It is not correct, because Occam's razor is only suitable for principles, not principles, theorems, axioms, and this principle also has a "

View more about Contact reviews

Extended Reading

Contact quotes

  • Voice of NASA: [When the first Machine starts on] We have begun the full scale test of Earth's first system built by the sharing of knowledge with a neighbour in our Universe.

  • Palmer Joss: [during the IMC's candidates selection] Do you believe in God, Dr. Arroway?