Is the mystery under the top of the mystery lake really revealed? (A lot of spoilers, please step in carefully)

Archibald 2022-10-14 16:34:09

This is my first time writing a movie review. The motivation for writing is to share my experience with my friends who have already seen it, because I don't know if I really understand the whole story. I feel that there are many mysteries that have not been solved. , so I want to exchange views.

The story begins when the girl wants to commit suicide, when the heroine first arrives at the top lake, and ends when the case is solved and the girl gives birth to a child. There are 2 clear story lines in the middle (there are many more story lines in the middle, but I don't understand them).

The first one, Tui's story line: As everyone said, Tui has no idea of ​​how the child came, and does not know who raped her. Unlike everyone who thinks Tui thinks her father raped her, I think Tui, a 12-year-old girl in a house full of men, has very little understanding of sex. So I don't know if she thinks her father raped her. It is possible to doubt: because for a girl, she and her father, a man and a woman, are in the same bed, and it is possible to get pregnant (the brothers said). But it's not necessarily the deciding factor: Robin offered to send Tui to her mother the first time she met her, but she refused (if you don't trust your father, it's best to stay away) Reaction). And the reason why she is so defensive about her father, or in other words, resistance, I personally think it is all because of the child. She didn't run away from the house in the first place, but what prompted her to leave was hearing her father's determination to take away the child, which she obviously wanted. So the question is, why is Tui so obsessed with this child? A 12-year-old child, as his father said, she was still a child, and something came out of nowhere, why is she so persistent? Obsessed with killing his father in the end? And his father, Matt, a drug lord, treats his mother like a Christian to God, confessing his crimes every day, and then beating himself with a whip. What he thinks of his crime is clearly not drug trafficking, so what is he doing? Does he know what Al is doing? He died so suddenly, and the conflict with his sons before his death, is there any deeper meaning?

The second line, the story line of the heroine Robin: The heroine Robin herself has many stories, and there are more stories around her. First, she was gang-raped as a child and gave birth to a daughter, while her boyfriend Johnno was also present. As for whether Johnno was involved in the gang rape case in the early years, I have never been sure. In the process of franking the whole thing, Johnno actually spoke very vaguely, and did not directly answer the topic of "whether he was involved" raised by his girlfriend, but it was obvious that he was extremely guilty. And after the conversation, rushed to find Sarge and kicked him out of Top lake. There are actually two possibilities. One is superficial. The guilt didn't protect Robin before, so I decided to drive him away now. This seems a little strange to me, since he was called away, then followed Robin into the car, and then was unable to protect Robin, it was all too coincidental. Why leave suddenly? Why do they meet again and say hello but not heard? And why does Robin have no impression of the car parked and her boyfriend getting in? With these doubts, what I am more suspicious of is that Johnno was involved in the whole gang rape case. On the one hand, Sarge was driven out because of guilt, and on the other hand, because he was the only one who knew the truth, so he was asked to leave to avoid his girlfriend and him. more contacts. There is also the sudden death of the heroine's mother, please allow me to suspect conspiracy theories, all of which have Johnno's share. I don't think there are any useless scenes in this story. Before, Robin brought her boyfriend and mother to dinner, but her mother suffered from cancer because she saw Robin and her boyfriend kissing, and the whole person was in unbearable pain. After that, J took R to the woods, and the two of them couldn't help being photographed by someone. The photo finally fell into J's hands, and we also saw that he took out his phone and kept operating something, in order to deal with J's The wound, they stayed in paradise for a period of time. After returning home, their mother died in a hurry, and R happened to have no mobile phone signal, did not receive a call from her mother, and did not see her last time. Al, the final boss, arranges for R to meet Matt on the yacht, and R, out of precaution, asks her boyfriend to pick her up and leave. At this point Al said: "Everything is going well." This makes me think that the story may not be as simple as a hero saving beauty.
Let's talk about another story. On the day he told Al about his story, Robin fainted after drinking too much. After waking up the next day, there was no difference. Combined with the ending of the story, we can know that R must have been raped that day. So, when exactly did she start to be suspicious of her boss? This has always been a question of mine. In the last episode, when Tui decided to go to the coffee party with his friends, R showed extreme anxiety, and finally saw the photo wall in the coffee shop and finally determined that A was the murderer, so he chased after the villa and immediately shot. understand A. So, when did she start to wonder? I really don't get it here.

Ok. Tired, go to sleep first. . The above are some superficial remarks, and I also hope to be able to attract more ideas. Let’s discuss and discuss the things below the surface of this drama ヽ(≧□≦)ノ

View more about Top of the Lake reviews