Josh told Riley in bed that he liked her music, Riley asked him which song he liked, Josh smiled awkwardly, and said you should write a song for me, Riley said that every song is about you. This dialogue is easy to understand. The songs made by the wife are all based on the husband’s emotional starting point, but there is definitely no such song here. It is specially titled for Josh and Josh knows it, otherwise he will not laugh and interrupt. . I need to confirm one thing: even if Riley's tune is all about her husband, it's probably emotional and Josh doesn't know it.
Josh went to Outland to save his son not long after, and then was trapped in Outland, and the perverted old man got on him. After he met the soul of the dice medium, he returned to this time and space to save his daughter, and then kept playing the piano to warn Riley and himself in this time and space. It is said in the play that the tune he played was specially written for him by Relais (Riley and Fake Josh also had this passage in their speech: Relais: I said that the piano can play by himself, right? That piece! Fake Josh! : What happened to that song? Riley: You don't know? Fake Josh: What do you know? Riley: I wrote this song specifically for you, but you don't know it and the ending echoes: Josh: It's me, I'm back Ryley: stare~ Josh: That's the one I played Ryley: stare~ puff~ I should have thought it was you, you're the only one who played so well~~~) Here
comes the problem. The plot of 2 is immediately after 1, and Josh has been trapped in Outland, so when was this song composed? When did Josh receive this piece and have enough time to master it (he can play it, after all)? Could it be that Riley did it for Josh after that night talk in bed? Where is the foreshadowing?
If there is a foreshadowing, I should have overlooked it. If there is no foreshadowing, it should be regarded as a bug.
View more about Insidious: Chapter 2 reviews
