It's not a movie review, it's a discussion of the plot. Tactical mistakes about humans

Kitty 2022-03-23 09:01:18

I found out why the humans were slaughtered in the film, and the fortifications were not suitable for fighting the Zerg. The fortifications in the film are mainly based on trenches and low bunkers, which are the popular form of fortification in the world. But this kind of fortification is not to fight against the hand-to-hand combat-oriented army like the Zerg. This kind of fortification is adapted to the enemy with a large number of artillery.
Against the Zerg who mainly engage in hand-to-hand combat, the most suitable fortification should be the higher and thicker the city wall, the better. It is a pity that human beings still chose the ditch due to habitual thinking, so they were slaughtered.
By the way, the U.S. military bases in the anti-terrorism war have not adopted tall city walls, and they have suffered a lot in the confrontation with terrorists and guerrillas.

ps: In the age of cold weapons, whether it is China or foreign countries, city walls are the main fortifications (the popular castles in foreign countries can be regarded as city walls with very short perimeter). Later, with the rise of firearms, the huge power of the explosion made the city walls mainly made of bricks and other rigid materials vulnerable to the attack of cannons. A typical example is the case of the Ottoman Empire conquering Constantinople, the capital of the Eastern Roman Empire in 1451. The walls of Constantinople stood for thousands of years, but they collapsed quickly under the fire of artillery.
In order to deal with the threat of artillery, the city wall was first lowered in height (not easy to aim), and secondly, the slope to the outside was slowed down and a large amount of earth was used as a building material. Compared with masonry, soil has poor mechanical properties, but under the impact of explosion, the soil itself can absorb a lot of energy, while the masonry will shatter, resulting in the failure of the fortifications. Slowly the walls became trenches (foxholes).
In the movie, the Zerg have weapons that can fight low-Earth orbit, but they rarely see artillery-like weapons in ground combat. Therefore, in fact, it has always been cold weapons. In response to such an opponent, humans should build fortifications and fight against the Zerg with deep trenches and high bases.
[Of course, in the novel, the Zerg has a more imba burrowing ability than in the movie, which can quickly destroy the continuous city wall, so humans may have to consider using a decentralized fortress system instead of the continuous city wall. 】

pss: Modern military bases have inherited the construction idea of ​​fortifications, and deep trenches and high fortresses are rarely seen. This is reasonable if it is against an established army. But if it is against guerrillas or terrorists who lack heavy firepower, I think deep groove and high base are more effective.

View more about Starship Troopers reviews

Extended Reading

Starship Troopers quotes

  • Sky Marshal Dienes: We must meet this threat with our courage, our valor, indeed with our very lives to ensure that human civilization, not insect, dominates this galaxy *now and always*!

  • Carl: We thought there might be a Brain Bug on 'P'.

    Carmen: You knew and still you sent them?

    Carl: We couldn't afford to launch an operation if there wasn't one.

    [both Carmen and Johnny look at Carl with contempt]

    Carl: You disapprove? Well, too bad! We're in this war for the species, boys and girls. It's simple numbers. They have more. And every day I have to make decisions that send hundreds of people like you to their deaths.

    Johnny Rico: Didn't they tell you, Colonel? That's what the Mobile Infantry is good for.