"Are you a journalist or a businessman?"

Melany 2022-03-21 09:01:43

Organizations exist to achieve a certain purpose, and are created to break through the limitations of individual capabilities. The larger the organization, the more members, and the more things it can accomplish. However, the larger the organization, the higher the cost. This forms a paradox. The larger the organization, the better.

There is a cost to doing anything, and when the cost exceeds the limit that the institution can bear, it becomes virtually impossible to accomplish. CBS "60 Minutes" could have enough resources to obtain Jeffrey's testimony, support him to bypass the Kentucky ban, and hire a security company to provide security for him, which is impossible for a single reporter to do. However, when the news broadcast may be retaliated by the tobacco giant, CBS cannot support such a high cost, the video was refrigerated for a time, and Luo Wei, who insisted that the news value was higher than the safety of the company, was also exiled.

"Are you a newsman or a businessman?" Newsman pursues truth, businessman pursues profit, and the two cannot always be unified. The stronger the institution, the more likely it is to provide space for press freedom and not do pornography. Under the protection of CBS, journalists can let go of their hands and feet to do news, but there is no end to the nest, and some people have to become businessmen to maintain the existence of media organizations. In fact, there is nothing wrong with being a businessman. Organizations can do things that individuals can’t do, and can provide protection when individuals can’t support them. Some people have to temporarily let go of their pride and make roofs and walls. However, organizations have institutional constraints. The gatekeeper is always there. As a result, more and more media people integrate their resources and choose to go it alone, with less protection and more freedom, and use asymmetric advantages to fight against regulation. Television stations and newspapers are both institutions, and the Internet has given independent journalists more channels of communication.

Whether staying in an institution or choosing to go it alone, it is always good to seek the truth.

View more about The Insider reviews

Extended Reading
  • Rachael 2022-03-23 09:01:43

    They're just ordinary people under extraodinary pressure. But they told the truth.

  • Michel 2022-03-19 09:01:04

    The atmosphere is very well constructed, and the layout is very long without feeling redundant. On the surface, tobacco companies are actually a game about the media, the public and capital. Michael Mann's superb level of shaping the character's psychology is brought into full play in this work.

The Insider quotes

  • Jeffrey Wigand: Up to you, Jeffrey! That's the power you have, Jeffrey! Vital inside information the American public need to know! Lowell Bergman, the hotshot who never met a source he couldn't turn around!

  • Lowell Bergman: You go public, and 30 million people hear what you gotta say, nothing - I mean nothing - will ever be the same again. You believe that?

    Jeffrey Wigand: No.

    Lowell Bergman: You should. Because when you're done, the judgement is gonna go down in the court of public opinion, my friend. And that's... the power you have.

    Jeffrey Wigand: You believe that?

    Lowell Bergman: I believe that? Yes, I believe that.

    Jeffrey Wigand: You believe that because you get information out to people, something happens?

    Lowell Bergman: Yes.

    Jeffrey Wigand: Maybe that's what you've been telling yourself all these years to justify having a good job. Having status. Maybe for the audience, its just voyeurism, something to do on a Sunday night. And maybe it won't change a fucking thing. And people like myself, and my family are left hung out to dry, used up, broke, alone.

    Lowell Bergman: Are you talking to me, or did somebody else just walk in here? I never forced any of that...

    Jeffrey Wigand: I don't really understand, exactly...

    Lowell Bergman: Don't evade a choice you gotta make by questioning my reputation or 60 Minutes with this cheap skepticism.

    Jeffrey Wigand: I have to put my family's welfare on the line here, my friend, and what are you putting up? You're putting up words.

    Lowell Bergman: "Words." While you've been dicking around some fucking company golf tournaments, I've been out in the world, giving my word... and backing it up with action. Now, are you gonna go and do this thing, or not?

    Jeffrey Wigand: I said I'd call the kids before they went to bed.