As a viewer, I also thought about it. The tricky and subtle thing about this moral decision is that the client himself, as a young child, has no power or ability to choose. So in this case, the society has to make the choice on her behalf. Under the existing law, it is clear that she should be raised by her mother, even though we know that her future life may be bleak as a result. The film does a great job of exaggerating the possible consequences of this choice, so at first my choice was leaning towards the old sheriff. But on second thought, would we still make the same choice if we didn't know the situation on both sides so well, if we didn't know who was the good guy and who was the bad guy? I think the answer should be no.
View more about Gone Baby Gone reviews