Almost every episode makes me want to fall. Adapt, adapt, I can understand. The adapted plot can be explained and even better than the original, which is the best, but after the adaptation, not only the plot collapses, but also the characters collapse together, which is really unbearable!
Philip:
Philip is actually my favorite character in the whole book because he has two sides. He is smart and religious, but because he is too religious, he has his own stubbornness and stupidity in some aspects, which often causes great harm to the people around him. But people are not perfect, and I like Philip because of his shortcomings. However, on TV, it can be said that Philip is the most messed up person!
1. In the first episode, the life experience and origin were changed, and the shrewd mind of this person was not explained at all.
2. The deceased abbot directly became Philip's adopter. Philip's status in the King's Bridge and the status of a reformer, which were extremely important to this person's image in the original work, all disappeared.
3. When I went to King Stephen to fight for the ownership of wood and stone, during the negotiation with Mrs. Hamley, I directly stated that I hope the other party will protect the personal safety of Miss Elena and her brother! ! How innocent are you, Philip, or how stupid? This episode really makes me want to kick people! Philip should be a devout Christian but at the same time a very shrewd person, so he wouldn't let the sheep go into the tiger's mouth like this! What's more, it is set in the movie that he has always grown up in Wangqiao, so it's not like he doesn't understand the people of the Hamley family! More importantly, it is absolutely unnecessary! In the original book, after receiving the king's assignment of Xialing County to them, William Hamley happily ran to the castle, as if to inspect his own property. Isn't it reasonable to bump into Elena directly? Why make a joke that Philip betrayed Elena directly! (I'm furious--!
4. Ellen was revealed to be a witch, and Philip secretly sent a knife and let her escape. I don't say anything. Philip on this TV is not a monk! In the book, Philip persuaded Tom and Allen to separate for a year as punishment for concubinage. Allen was so angry that he took Jack away. Such Philip is a typical Christian, and he has lost his mind in this regard. On TV, he is neither religious, nor has his own rules to live by, nor is he smart (see 3).
5. When the church was burnt down, Philip tried to save the saint's skull, and the skull was smashed into pieces; as a result, at the instigation of others, he agreed to secretly replace the skull of an ordinary monk, deceiving people that it was a saint. Well, I can understand to a certain extent, the effect that this contrast is trying to create. But, again, Philip's "religious" image is ruined! ! ! What a departure from the original character setting~~
6. Philip didn't stop Jack and Alena from cohabiting... In short... In short, this Philip is not the Philip of the original book.
7. Philip, how come the white-haired Philip is so funny... The last sermon, Philip, you are always lacking in eloquence.
Alena:
This first princess, later royal sister. The actors are good and generally controlled, but the problem is:
1. The transition is too fast, too fast to believe. A few hours ago, the princess was living in a fantasy, and then she knew immediately that it was time to kill; she knew how to make money when she saw wool... All the transitions, foreshadowing and gradual changes in the book: such as being deceived by forest guards, such as finding Not being persuaded to be a prostitute before work, such as being advised by a wool merchant to think of doing business - these plots are all gone.
2. The scene where the father was beheaded actually prayed to the king in public. Although this is not impossible, it is unreliable to directly expose yourself and pray like this without any bargaining power, Elena! Although you are acting brave.
3. This noble lady is close to love at first sight for Jack! ! ? ? I don't think it's good at all. She didn't even notice Jack when the book started, Jack was five years younger than her. The process of slowly discovering Jack's talent in the book, I think, is what attracts me most to the love complex in this book. It is so boring to adore each other as soon as they meet!
4. I am angry, I am really angry! In the last episode, Alena got mad at Jack, accusing him of caring about work and not home... Hey! Alena in the book is grumpy and angry, but it was Philip who forced them to separate, and she was very angry! Then your TV cut out the plot of being forced to separate, and also made Alena angry like this. This really wants to portray her as an unpleasant image!
5. When Alena thought of using Elizabeth to attack the castle, she was a little too... not thinking about Elizabeth! In the book, Elizabeth is at home anyway. Elizabeth escaped from here. Do you want to send her back? Don't ask people first if they want to? Alena, you are too much! For your own selfishness! And then running up to Jack as if to show off the win...I don't like you at all! = =
Jack: The
actor is quite good, very in line with Jack's poetic and artist temperament. Where it fell apart:
1. The quarry brawl. When people say a duel, do you duel? Do you think you are really a knight? People fight professionally, and your hands are used for carving. How can you be a fool after being smashed by someone with a hammer! Are you not looking for your own death when you fight someone? How can you be so brave? I was expecting this if you had any good ideas to defeat the opponent. As a result, you are a mentally handicapped person who ran to hit a stone with an egg! (I'm speechless with anger! - But, think about it calmly, this guy who dares to burn a church can really do anything. Does an artist have an innate impulse?
2. Lakeside storytelling events It's really sad, so the beautiful love scene was wiped out like this (bug, you said you don't remember, I know it's excusable). The original poem was the first time Alena noticed Jack, when it started to sprout; it turned out that they had already kissed on TV, I fell! Then, in the knight story that Jack started to make up, he kissed Alena for the first time. That unknown kiss What's the point! What's the point! It's absolutely the point! When it's on TV, what? It's just an ordinary romance, with no features at all! All the good parts of this love story have been cut off and replaced, and I'm so mad!
3. That last speech, too didactic, a little fake.
Tom and Allen:
This pair is the worst. Allen, in particular, is more faithful to the original. However, if the two are separated for a year, let's be separated for a year, why are they secretly running to a private meeting? It has no effect on the plot... Is it just that the director wants to shoot H?
William's mother:
1. At the beginning, several scenes of this mother and son made me sick to my stomach, why is such a perverted Oedipus? By the fourth episode, William's mother actually killed her husband and I broke down. Why are bad people so bad that they even kill their relatives? This family of three should have been united to do bad things together, this is a bit too much to write! The level of mother-child love is also a bit too much, which is disgusting. And every time Who do you hate the most? Who do you love the most? Gives me goosebumps...
2. She kills the Archbishop of Canterbury... = = Don't say anything.
Alfred:
1. The part where he went to the lake and Alena was swimming was absolutely unbearable! ! ! ! ! Outcry! ! ! ! Alena's secret base is Jack's alone! ! ! Why let this guy go to waste! ! !
2. Why did Alfred love Alena? Alfred in the book is a cold-blooded guy who doesn't love anyone. He married Alena not out of love at all, but out of jealousy and revenge for Jack! Now it's changed to this, it's become a love triangle, it's not fun! ! !
Alena's younger brother, Richard
1. This younger brother in the book is very useless and makes people want to smoke. He's actually pretty good in the movie, at least he's a young man with a certain amount of courage and courage. When I was reading the book, I felt that it was not worth Alena's devotion to him; I didn't feel that way when I watched the movie. It's hard to say whether this character's complete adaptation is good or bad. It's just that, my sympathy for Alena decreases.
2. Why do I think Richard with long hair is handsome in the last episode?
3. Richard went back to use the people to form an army. In the book, there is a background of famine, William's tyranny, and the rampant bandits, Richard just happened to organize this group of scattered people. When he got to the TV, he ran to give a speech... Sweaty.
Elizabeth:
1. Good girl, good work! It seems that the TV version does not have enough time for Sister Alena to enlighten you and teach you to be brave, and you are born to be brave! orz So all the women in this TV are born brave...Whether they are good people or bad people, women win! Think: Miko Ellen, Alena, Elizabeth, Queen Maud, and William's mother! The world of women...
2. When attacking the castle, that leave it open was too buggy! ! ! It's illogical! How to do such an unsure plan? Two women go on an adventure! And Elizabeth has never been dignified, and suddenly she looks like a wife. It's strange that those servants and soldiers will listen to her. = =
Martha:
Ah, I know you love Jack. But wouldn't it be better not to say it? Why did the TV change to this, steal the ring, and finally confess?
And then you ended up getting married? Shouldn't you be single?
The unbearable plot:
1. Martha stole the ring
2. King Stephen fell to the ground when he inspected the King's Bridge Cathedral. It was too pretentious, too fake, too mysterious! (The entire political line has been strengthened well, but why do you want to engage in such a weird plot like a dream?)
3. This must be complained! How could the Hamleys let William's wife sit there and listen when they were talking about a murder plot with the Warrens! ! ! ? ? ?
4. What kind of dagger assassinated Jack, and then the assassin was actually... Alas, speechless
5. William murdered his mother... This family is crazy! ! In the original they are just bad people, not mentally ill! !
6. ORZZZZZZZ! Is Remigius actually gay? ! ! ! = =
7. The last poisoned dagger, Alfred died like this... It's not as good as the original book... I don't know how to complain.
8. The final judgment, I really don't know how to complain... I'm really powerless.
9. In the end, William was hanged by the people, what should I say?
10. Warren's escape, too much like a Hollywood movie = =
11. This is unbearable! The final princess-prince wedding scene. . . . . = = This is not a romance film, okay?
Supplement the good plot:
1. When the quarry was recaptured, when the monks sang hymns, I felt a lot!
2. The church collapsed, very tragic.
3. People worship the Weeping Virgin.
Also: in the last episode when Warren went to find Alfred, a row of red apples lit up in the house!
View more about The Pillars of the Earth reviews
