Poirot suffers crisis of faith

Christy 2022-02-07 15:00:01

First of all, I want to say that any film adapted from the original work of the same name by Agatha Christie cannot bypass the classic adaptation of 1974. It is true that the "Murder on the Orient Express", indeed , is an immortal classic.
It's a well-structured logic drama, and our protagonist, Detective Poirot, played by Albert Finney, is more of a god than a man.
Going back to our current 2010 version, in this movie, you get the full sense that Poirot might be perfect in his detective profession, but what about in everyday life? At the beginning of the film, he makes a soldier who has made a mistake appear, causing the soldier who values ​​honor to commit suicide. His feelings about this are: "He actually has other options. , and walked in front of the woman who was about to be killed, forgetting that God once said, "Who of you is without sin? "Allusions, just use "every country has its own laws and customs" to justify his own behavior. By listing so many facts, I don't want to condemn this Poirot in the movie, I just want to Said that the director actually wanted to tell us through so many facts that he is a man, not a god.
Judging from the process of Poirot's detection in this film, half of his ability to solve strange cases comes from his Half of his high IQ comes from his psychological quality that he is not easily moved. (Remember another great private detective, Sherlock Holmes, once said: "I never want to have love, because it destroys my ability to deduce logically.")
A The guys (criminals) who were being interrogated, in front of Poirot, confessed the fact that if he knew the true identity of the victim, he would kill the victim, these kind criminals! You are really not the opponents of the old Poirot!
But, I Thinking of a great detective like Poirot will also be devastated after this case, because for the first time in his life he has encountered a crisis of faith. The "faith" I am talking about here includes religious, moral, and legal.
The ending of the movie is really unexpected! The thin winter sun shines into the carriage, as if God is silently watching these people who he considers guilty or innocent, Poirot speaks generously, condemning these criminals who wantonly trample on the laws of the world, the criminals retorted: " If the law enforcers in the world are greedy and bend the law, God is silent about it, and we have the right to punish those who have committed crimes.
Poirot was really at a loss, so when he finally decided to let the group of criminals go, he clenched tightly. With the cross on his hands, tears rolled in his eyes. Because he didn't know whether his decision was in line with or against God's will?

View more about Murder on the Orient Express reviews

Extended Reading

Murder on the Orient Express quotes

  • Greta Ohlsson: There is a higher justice than the rule of law, monsieur!

    Hercule Poirot: Then you let *God* administer it... not *you*!

    Greta Ohlsson: And when he doesn't? When he creates a Hell on Earth for those wronged? When priests who are supposed to act in his name forgive what must never be forgiven? Jesus said, "Let those without sin throw the first stone."

    Hercule Poirot: Oui!

    Greta Ohlsson: Well, we were without sin, monsieur! *I* was without sin!

  • Mary Debenham: You said of the woman in Istanbul that she knew the rules of her culture and knew what breaking them would mean. So did Cassetti.

    Hercule Poirot: [harshly] And so do you!

    Mary Debenham: When you've been denied justice... you are incomplete. It feels that God has abandoned you in a stark place. I asked God... I think we all did... what we should do, and he said do what is right. And I thought if I did, it would make me complete again.

    Hercule Poirot: [coldly] And are you?

    Mary Debenham: [long pause, then] But I did what was right.