Fact 1: Luna has stationed more than a dozen clones on the moon to save costs, and the so-called cost here is left to the discussion below;
Fact 2: The use period of clones is three years . The sam of the three-year contract is already vomiting blood and hallucinations. It is estimated that the technical conditions at the time of the plan were initiated. The limit use period of clones of a certain age is three years, so the contract is designed for three years to let the full contract sam. It just walks into the incinerator automatically (sam himself only thought that was the standard procedure for returning to the earth).
Fact 3: According to eva's age of 15 years, this plan has been implemented for 15 years. If the clone is replaced every 3 years, 4 replacements have been made, and the 5th, 6th, and 7th sams appear in order.
The film also gives a lot of information to make the following inferences completely credible. The specific reasoning process is not wordy, only the results:
Inference 1: There must be many similar mining bases on the moon, and there should be clones of sam. Reason;
Corollary 2: The true non-clone Sam is still alive and lives with his daughter after his wife’s death. In theory, Luna’s fault is merely to make clones and kill them.
Corollary 3: The so-called rescue team is actually the continuous recovery of sam from various mines within the moon range that cannot work normally due to accidents. Of course, they know the secret of cloning, and the 4th generation sam should be killed or disposed of by them.
Well, friends who watch the film seriously and have a certain logical analysis ability should all agree with the above points, then please further enjoy the fun of thinking ------ found that this film is flawed:
Mistake 1: Luna uses human cloning to save costs. In fact, this is the cornerstone of the castle in the sky, otherwise there would be no need for the clones in this film to exist. Consider from this perspective, what money can be spent more and less to use clones. Extra money: launching N clones to the moon, including N times the supply, maintaining a three-person rescue team (or more than one), and establishing three satellite signal jamming stations for each mining site. The life support system of each mine. Less money spent: Sam's salary, Sam's training fee (according to the 5th generation of Sam's mouth), round-trip air tickets for each mine site replacement every 3 years. It’s time to break them one by one. It can be seen that the cost saved by Luna is completely revolving around sam, or to be precise, revolving around the left-behind staff. In fact, after looking at it for 2 hours, one can draw a conclusion, that is The irreplaceability of sam’s work is actually quite low. I regularly go to the mining trucks dispatched to recycle the energy barrels? Report the parameters of the minecart every 24 earth hours? Get rid of, when a mining truck has been able to integrate mining, screening, refining, and canning, is there no technology to go home and unload automatically? Gerty can even activate clones on his own, launching fuel back to the earth, and reporting parameters can’t be done? Haha, if luna really wants to save money, there should be no such thing as cloning. According to common sense, the biggest cost of space exploration is the payload of each flight, but look at the scale of the three jamming towers, how big is the spacecraft transported from the earth to the moon? It's not a spacious single-family villa like Sam, a dozen of Sam's independent refrigerators. Considering that the audience here is often tortured by logic, it is very painful, but the screenwriter is to explore the ethical issues of possible abuse of cloning technology in an extremely closed environment. I had no choice but to turn a blind eye to this malaise;
Mistake 2: When Gerty thinks, God laughs. OMG, the mass-produced Gerty has the ability to think independently after spending 15 years on the moon. Is it true that the environment changes people? As a clone, Sam actually has very few permissions. Without Gerty's acquiescence, the door cannot be opened. The paradox is that Gerty, who was cruel and cruel in the previous 4 generations, has suddenly evolved AI to the 5th generation, even the unspoken rules between you and me. No one knows it. This is another sensational robot after Arnold, the terminator who sacrificed himself. The question is, could Luna put such a robot on the moon? The live of Gerty and the earth needs to be projected on the screen and let the 5th generation eavesdrop so much? The rescue team clearly knows about the cloning, why can't they wait for them to clean up the scene and activate the 5th generation of sam to be foolproof? Yes, these should be problems that cannot be solved by the screenwriter. The movie really needs the No. 2 actor Gerty to promote the plot. It would only be more absurd to find out that you are a clone only by meditation. Sam's ridiculous "We are not programe, we a human being." is more like a supporting actor nomination for Gerty.
Well, in the end, looking back, the poor screenwriter left a lot of information in order to make the plot a little more complete, and he left a lot of information in the film to justify it. First, I don’t comment on whether it is successful or not (because each audience has different cognitive abilities in appreciation and understanding. If you don’t believe me, please see the thread downstairs), but with only one actor, it can make the film so full (for example, please see the uncle), this kind of professional ethics is also worthy of the audience’s admiration. Of course, the little sensation of tearing off the Kick me note is indispensable, although it is cheap and cute.
It’s pure self-entertainment to scribble a bunch of words. If you get angry, please watch the news network.
View more about Moon reviews
