1. All the agents are not equipped with suicide weapons in case the incident is revealed, including the woman who performed the assassination mission at the beginning. The spy, the old gun captain, and the old ghost Gu Xiaomeng didn't have it. In the end, Xiaomeng asked for someone else to shoot on his behalf, which was not in line with the reality of the spy. However, Director Jin, who was not a special agent, carried a small pistol with him and died when he wanted to.
2. Female agents perform assassination missions at close range. Basically, there is no return, but there are no prognostic measures. After the female agent was caught, she couldn't die without a suicide pill, and she didn't shoot herself. After being tortured and tortured, she confessed everything. My secret service organization didn't respond to the arrest of the comrade, the contact information and the code base were not changed, and the old one was still used. Even the notice posted on the Temple of the City God was taken away without the slightest suspicion. I don't know if it's the sluggishness of my spy organization or the sluggishness of the director?
3. After Gu Xiaomeng died, my party sent people to secretly examine the body, check the clothes, and even read the underwear, and found important information. And after this female agent was caught, my organization didn’t pay attention. Her online and offline did not check whether she was killed or joined the enemy. All contact methods remain the same. The difference itself is not like the same organization. the behavior of.
4. Captain Wu will not touch the telegram from the procedure. So why encircle the captain in the first place? The logic doesn't make sense.
5. It is not Li Bingbing's responsibility to read Gong Hong (gong) as a female red (hong), but the responsibility of all the film's production staff headed by the director.
6. Singing operas can meet comrades and transmit signals. Singing operas are so important and extremely important information. The renegade comrades have even explained the original information. Will this be explained? Unlike the ancient passwords when marching and fighting, which were temporarily changed every day, it was a little harder for the enemy to guess. The same shadow play of yours has been sung among comrades since the beginning of your career. You have sung about comrades and sung about traitors, and they are almost sung into the International anthem. Enemies who engage in secret agents will not notice, do you not know? The reliability is too poor. This must not be the method used by the underground workers of our party. You can make it up out of the actual situation.
7. The headquarters is very large, there are many people in the unit, and there is no chance to chat. Suddenly it became "There are not many in Laoting, it seems that it is just the two of us." "Yes, Laoting fellows are just us", a minute ago I didn't know that Gu Xiaomeng was a fellow, but after knowing that he was a fellow a minute later, he ruled out the possibility that other people in the whole unit were fellows, which meant that before that, apart from not knowing that Gu Xiaomeng was a fellow, he already knew that everyone else was not a fellow. Is it reasonable? (Some people explain that this is a code in itself, but the unreasonable code will not make the enemy suspicious? If the enemy is a real agent, this sentence has already exposed two people)
8. According to the plot hint, Xiaobai should be an old man Ghosts have long been looking for good scapegoats. The notice was written first and the handwriting at the back, but the notice was written according to Xiaobai's handwriting. It shows that a long time ago, when the notice was first written, the old ghost found a scapegoat - Xiaobai, which shows how forward-looking our party agents are, but they did not bite to death at the most critical time. Xiaobai, on the contrary, did nothing and did not show any initiative to attack. This kind of secret agent method is really unreasonable, and there is no coherence in finding a scapegoat.
9. Why did Gu Xiaomeng identify the captain for the first time? "It's a tacit understanding." This false accusation can be determined to be acting. After agreeing with the will at the beginning, he began to deliberately design confrontations, from false accusations and reports, to quarrels, to almost fighting each other, from the strategic perspective of keeping one dead and the other correct. However, all this was before the two discussed countermeasures. Logically doesn't make sense. If the two people in the front already knew that they would kill one and save the other, why would they take the risk to discuss countermeasures later? This appearance is more reasonable after the rape scene.
10. "Put out what they said about each other before dinner." Wang Zhiwen looked at Takeda's face with admiration, expressing his admiration for his brilliant trick. However, the film never told or hinted the audience of Takeda's intention from the beginning to the end. As usual, the censorship is isolated and censorship is released, and the information must be faked. Either Takeda is too confident in himself, or the director is too much about the plot design. confusion. The direct consequence of this move is to let Lao Gun know the intention of the old ghost's accusation, and tacitly performed a mutual attacking rivalry, which further confuses the enemy.
11. "So Captain Bai died unexpectedly during the interrogation process, isn't it, Commander?", in order to evade responsibility and say it was an accidental death, how did Xiao Bai die? Torture to death? Commander killed? Assassination by my party? suicide? It's unreasonable to say that Xiaobai died inexplicably and for insufficient reasons. A character who tried his best to exaggerate his handwriting was out early, which greatly reduced the tension of the plot. Anyway, to die. The director wanted him to die, he had to die.
12. As soon as Xiaobai died, the Japanese were convinced that Xiaobai was innocent. The reason? Just because Xiaobai said he was framed before he died, so he was framed? Before Xiaobai died, Takeda and the commander were convinced that Xiaobai was a ghost. After Xiaobai died suddenly, both Takeda and the commander were convinced that Xiaobai was not a ghost. What made them change this judgment? The logic is unclear.
13. Lao Jin's death was not justified. Even if he wants to die, he should not use suicide. The film portrays him as a cowardly and fearful of his wife's relationship to become the director. Such a director of the Wang government who sells arms and keeps a concubine always brings a pistol for self-defense, but because of It is a bit unreasonable to commit suicide for fear of being punished, and suddenly changed from cowardice to bravery. It is estimated that the director meant that the enemy must die first to prove the stupidity of the enemy.
14. The Japanese used a ruler to measure Li Ningyu's naked body, and they believed the result without fail? What high tech is this? It can still be explained that either Takeda is too confident in himself, or the director is too confused about the plot design.
15. If using a ruler to measure a woman's body to determine her identity has a scientific basis, why not measure Gu Xiaomeng's body as well? If you measure it, you will know if it is an old ghost. Do you have to play with the old ghost of the Communist Party? It is said that it is a personalized punishment design, but a good movie should be expressed in the way of the film itself, not by the director to explain what is in the script but not in the movie. The film itself does not see the design of personalized punishment.
16. Who is important in the secret service organization? Is the old gun and the old ghost more important or the gunman? In order to protect the gunman, sacrificing the old gun and the old ghost, completely paralyzed this intelligence line? It does not meet the rationality of the agent.
17. Hum opera can transmit signals, so why not hum when the lame man is clearing the dishes? At this time, Li Ningyu went mad, but later, it was not seen that Li Ningyu's sudden madness at this time had any impetus for the development of the plot.
18. Li Ningyu's sudden rage when the lame man was cleaning up should be taken for granted as an act of sending a signal, but the Japanese have no doubts. why? Later, the performance of the other three people was analyzed, and they were even accurate to the eyes. But there is no doubt about Li Ningyu's sudden behavior. But she thought that Li Ningyu's behavior showed that she only had the actor Liu Linzong who sang dramas in her mind. The reason? What about logic? Why do you say that? Was it Takeda's wishful thinking or the director's forced arrangement? It is logically impossible to infer that Li Ningyu can be excluded.
19. What is the plan of the captain? Did he die or Gu Xiaomeng died? If you die, why don't you confess, if you let Gu Xiaomeng die, why expose yourself?
20. What is Gu Xiaomeng's plan? Die on your own or die? If you die, why don't you take the initiative to expose it, and if you let the captain die, why admit it to Li Ningyu?
21. After the agent was locked up, he only wanted to die and self-mutilation. Relying on this most low-level means to try to complete the task, it was not like being trained by a professional agent team. It only reflected the fearless spirit of sacrifice, but did not reflect the superb agent. Business level. Poor intentions and lack of creativity. It's far from a suspense movie, and it's a little bit more correct to say it's a war movie.
22. In the secret service organization, Lao Gun doesn't know who the old ghost is. He can only know who he is by singing, but he knows the identity of Shou Shui (deliberately avoiding his eyes), and the old ghost knows the identity of the actor (Gu Xiaomeng and Li Ningyu dialogue), but also plans Through the drama actor who rebelled against Li Ningyu, he also knew the identity of Shou Shui (deliberately avoiding his eyes), but he alone did not know who Lao Gun was. The old ghost is led by the old gun, but the old gun has never inspected his downline, and he does not know who the downline is. Is the line broken or continuous? Is the spy organization in the play a single line, a multiline or no line? It is contradictory in everyone. Those with a little common sense should know that although the agent system is mostly a one-line connection, it must be continuous. If you disconnect, you will not be able to tell your identity. From the beginning to the end of the movie, there is no hint to the audience, how the old gun and the old ghost, two people who do not know each other, and agents who have never met, how to achieve command and cooperation with each other.
23. The problem of guns. The organization wanted to investigate the old ghost and locked people up, but even allowed them to carry guns with them, not afraid of the old ghost killing him?
24, or the problem of guns. Director Jin has a gun, but the captain doesn't? The old man doesn't have a gun? Director Jin is all fortified, but the real agent is not fortified at all? To be slaughtered? Don't even have the old gun of the captain? At least show it.
25. "Captain Wu took out a cigarette and dropped one on the ground. I felt something was wrong, so I stepped on it." This sentence successfully framed the captain. However, if she wasn't an undercover agent, how would she know that the lame man was coming from the Communist Party, and framed others for throwing cigarettes and sending signals? If you have to make the Japanese and Director Wang so stupid, won't you ask back?
26. Since the smooth information exchange between the agents can be achieved by writing in the palm of the hand, why is it necessary to use tape to stick a bug in the "rape scene" scene to speak again? It is completely possible to communicate with the hand while shouting orally, but it will not arouse the suspicion of the enemy. The risk of sticking bugs is too great. What if there are missed stickers? What if the enemy suddenly rushed in to check? Wouldn't it be possible for both of them to be exposed? The logical contradiction here is: if the conversation can only be achieved by interfering with the eavesdropper, then the occurrence of handwriting communication should be avoided; if the communication can be realized by handwriting, then the previous interference eavesdropping device becomes unnecessary. In fact, it is very difficult to recognize the Chinese characters written by others in the palm of your hand. It is better to take a stone and write it directly on the ground. Anyway, the enemy does not have a camera.
27. "I'm their commander, how could they invite me?" "Why didn't they stop him?" "I wanted to stop, but I didn't dare to stop", the audience laughed and asked the captain's subordinates To see the captain, is the Japanese mentally handicapped or the director mentally handicapped? No more soldiers? Don't know about cross care? Do you have to use your own soldiers to take care of others?
28. Gu Xiaomeng's cigarette problem. If Gu Xiaomeng had the third battery, the captain would not need to give her cigarettes as a prop; if Gu Xiaomeng did not have the third battery, a box of cigarettes suddenly appeared as a prop to report herself. This is a contradiction.
29. "I've always wanted to help you, hurry up, we don't have time." Director Wang's line was very strange when Gu Xiaomeng was tortured. And the whole film does not explain the personal relationship between Director Wang and Gu Xiaomeng. From the perspective of the integrity of a movie, the so-called ambiguous relationship between Gu and Wang is unnecessary and unnecessary, unless the director intends to make a prequel from the very beginning.
30. Sing opera to send information about the cancellation of the action? The biggest question that has been criticized is that the comrades of the opera singing club were a little bit justified, but now they need to transmit different information through the change of singing and lyrics, which is estimated to be the master level of cryptography. Not only the person who sings is required to be a musician, but also the person who listens is a musician. It is necessary to be able to identify each note in order to distinguish the type of information hidden in this singing voice. It seems that everyone in our party’s secret service organization is a singer.
31. Since singing can transmit signals, why not sing it on the balcony in the middle of the night, high and low, far and near, the yard is not big, the spy comrades who are lurking will hear it no matter what? Wait until the medical room and sing with a blurred expression and go to the doctor in a hurry?
32. If only the hospital has its own comrades, why did the agents have no plan of action to get into the hospital from beginning to end? On the contrary, the final admission to the hospital was the result of a mistake. That is: Does the nurse know this line? If you know, why didn't you find an opportunity to connect earlier, if you don't know, isn't that a one-in-ten thousand coincidence? Anyway, a little nurse with a joint suddenly appeared, fell from the sky, and the right person appeared at the right place at the right time, very evil.
33. In the same way of singing and transmitting the signal, the little nurse who transmitted the signal pushed the door and went out before the captain sang "The First Emperor Goes to Nanyang". But in the flashback stage, the little nurse was still tapping her fingers when she heard the phrase "the first emperor went to Nanyang", and then left the operating room. The two times were completely different. If this mistake occurs, the director is too useless.
34. How did Gu Xiaomeng persuade Li Ningyu to report herself? Li Ningyu's reporting behavior was not motivated enough. Not enough reasons. At this time, Li Ningyu didn't know Gu Xiaomeng's plan to use underwear to spread information, but she knew that Gu Xiaomeng would definitely die after the report, so how did the information come out? You can't pass it on yourself, and the Communist Party doesn't believe in itself. She didn't know the biography of the captain, and she didn't know the identity of the captain. So how could she believe Gu's nonsense saying "report me to get the information out"? She was not successfully rebelled by Gu Xiaomeng, and she really couldn't understand Gu Xiaomeng's intention to die, anyway, she just took the cigarette case to report it.
35. If Gu Xiaomeng has any oral last words, it can only be passed on to others through Li Ningyu, because this is the last trustworthy person she saw before her exposure, and it is unlikely that it will be passed on to Li Ningyu through others.
36. Threatening family members is really unreliable. It was originally a private action, everything was going on secretly, and you dared to shoot Wang Jingwei's brother and wife with great fanfare? It seems that this low-level Japanese officer really doesn't want to mix, or he is a neurotic paranoid. It seems that the director really has no other plot design method, so he has to apply this oldest gang threat method.
37. Gu Xiaomeng used a needle to open the handcuffs, what was the purpose? Wearing handcuffs can't provoke the other party to bite the other party's ear with his mouth? Wouldn't it be more shocking to bite someone's ear in handcuffs? The agent has a needle that can pierce the handcuffs, but not a suicide weapon. An agent needs the help of others to commit suicide.
38. The reason for the death of the old ghost was not sufficient. A weak woman fought with a Japanese officer, and there was no lethal weapon in her hand. There was really no reason to shoot him to death. Besides, it was so important to finally find the old ghost , An important figure in the Communist Party who can be used for meritorious service, but let him die easily. Unless, Wang Zhiwen is helping her secretly.
39. The old ghost died. The Japanese set up an ambush in the Hundred Herbs Hall, but there was still no shooter. It seems that the information was leaked out. So, why did the Japanese not track down how the intelligence got out? Why can the captain and Li Ningyu survive safely? A movie that doesn't fully explain the storyline seems to have to wait for its sequel.
40. Use the body's underwear to send signals? What guarantees that one's underwear will be discovered by comrades instead of being discovered by the enemy for further use? His online old guns are still in prison. Will his identity be known to his comrades? Will it be a problem, and can he be accurate enough to check the information on his underwear? In fact, it is precisely because of the design of the plot to transmit information through underwear that the originally clear espionage plot appears chaotic and the logic is contradictory everywhere.
41. If the peripheral comrades knew about Gu Xiaomeng's identity as a special agent, isn't Gu's death itself a signal? The comrade who passed on the information was suddenly arrested and killed by the enemy. Regardless of whether the previous information was true or false, the operation should be cancelled. Even Wang Jiazhi knew that the former stronghold could not be visited, so would our party's secret service still believe the previous information? You have to let the dead say, "The previous information was false, I exposed it, you see, I was killed by them", comrades can know, oh, that information is false. This may be the slowest spy organization in the world since human beings.
42. The Japanese anti-assassination operation has not been cancelled, and the identity of the old ghost has been confirmed. At this time, the enemy will return the old ghost's body to his family for an obituary? The Japanese are not worried that the assassination team will cancel the action plan after the news that the old ghost is dead?
43. The reason for Director Wang's death is not sufficient. Is the ghost looking for a dead person to replace it? Wouldn't this lead to a greater level of investigation by the superiors? Tell your superiors that Wang Chu, Jin Chu and Xiao Bai died in the firefight with each other? Or did Wang Chu kill the other two and then commit suicide by drinking bullets? The final result also proved that killing Wang did not free the Japanese, and they returned to the country as a criminal after being investigated for three months.
44. The reason for the assassination of Takeda was not sufficient, the assassination arranged by the organization? Not like, nor should, not necessary. I want to kill myself, why? To avenge Gu Xiaomeng? childish. Which revolution is not throwing blood, and taking revenge for personal feelings is not a revolutionary act, and it should not be done by secret agents. It might be more reasonable if Wang Zhiwen suddenly resurrected to kill the Japanese. For this Japanese ending, it would be better not to kill.
45. It is unreasonable that an intelligence station is fully infiltrated by our party, but there is no military command.
46. Using subtitles to show the mental activities of the old ghost is superfluous and has no meaning. It is known as a suspense film, but subtitles of psychological activities appear from time to time, which is a failure of the film itself.
47. Anti-Japanese victory, the pseudo-Wang government was annihilated, and the captain who worked in the Wang government agency was rewarded by the leadership, and Li Ningyu still needed the captain to come forward and write Chen Qing to the organization to save his life. At this time, Li Ningyu didn't know Is the captain's real identity? It also takes a long time for the captain to come over and tell her, "Actually, Xiaomeng and I are both members of the Communist Party"? Unless Chen Qing is writing to the Kuomintang, then the captain has a dual identity: the Communist Party and the military secret agent.
48. "Xiaomeng asked me to tell you that everything she gave you will be left in this cheongsam." When did this transfer take place? I wouldn't say such a thing before reporting the captain, because it was the captain who asked the captain to sacrifice. It should be the captain who left Xiaomeng's last words instead of Xiaomeng's last words to the captain. After the report, I never saw the captain again. It is even more impossible to leave a message on my underwear and also leave a message saying that I left a message to my sister to let her pay attention to the cheongsam. Therefore, there is no space and time for this "report". Unexplainable, unless Xiaomeng shuttled, or the captain shuttled. It should be more likely that the captain will shuttle. If Xiaomeng can shuttle in time, she will directly take the time machine to chat with her favorite sister Ning Yu.
49. "I originally planned to be tortured a little to make a confession. In order to protect Xiaomeng's transmission of signals, I would rather die, but I don't know why I committed a sinew when I was tortured. If I didn’t confess, the director just wouldn’t let me recruit. But Liu Ye’s method was so fucking vicious. I still recruited, but no one believed me. Then they suddenly stopped torturing me and sent me to the infirmary. There, I suddenly saw a lesbian who had taken over in the past. I don't know if she has cultivated to the highest level of accepting passwords, but I can only try it. I don't know anything. When I woke up again, I heard that Xiaomeng was killed by them. I vented my anger on Takeda. I decided to assassinate him without reporting it to the organization. I can't explain why I did this. Yes, who wants to know, ask the director, anyway, I cut off his neck artery under the eyes of a group of Japanese soldiers. It's strange that his blood didn't spurt out, but came out after he fell to the ground. Killing people used to feel different. But it is worth mentioning that I survived unscathed under the siege of hundreds of Japanese, just like I stepped on a mine for someone in "Assembly", and then the mine exploded. I was able to get out of my body like a legend. Later, the Japanese surrendered, and I finally didn't have to be an underground party. Although Li Ningyu was not a comrade of our party, she still helped us, so I also helped her to the organization. She wrote the evidence to prevent her from being convicted. I heard from comrades that Xiaomeng also sewed information on her underwear. After her body was sent out, a lesbian secretly went to check her underwear and found it. I am proud and proud to have such a comrade. Suddenly one day, it may be Xiaomeng who asked her to give me a message, saying that she left a message to Li Ningyu. On her cheongsam, I can't remember whether it was Xiaomeng who asked her to me or whether it was her cheongsam. What's the matter, now that I'm older, I can't remember a lot of things, anyway, I suddenly found out that Xiaomeng left a last word..." - Captain Wu's memoirs
50. "My sister died because of her exposure. Before she died, she sewed clothes for herself. For so many years, that clothes were never willing to wear, and they were well kept in their suitcases. For many years, every time I think of my sister, I must take the clothes in my arms and look at the thread she used to sew for herself before she died. The thread is very strange. I have read it countless times. I am a secret agent myself, and I deal with Morse code every day. I didn't even see that this strange stitch of different lengths was Morse code. I heard that the ordinary Communist Party agents checked Xiaomeng's underwear a little and found a Morse code signal sewn into it. I'm stupid, it's because the director made me, a professional cryptographic genius student at the University of Pennsylvania, suddenly stupid. ." - Li Ningyu's memoirs.
Summary:
1: This film seriously insults the intelligence quotient of wartime intelligence personnel, and to a certain extent the audience's IQ. Is it so difficult to make up a story for more than an hour?
2: "The Sound of the Wind" is far away from "Lust and Caution", like a thousand miles away;
3: The "Godfather" that claims to be out of China is really too ambitious, and how can an impetuous mentality produce a high-quality product.
Suggestion:
Suggestion 1: Make this film into a film exam to correct the wrong questions, and let the undergraduates of the Directing Department of the Film School answer the final exam.
Suggestion 2: All the main creators of Fengsheng will form a group to play a killing game, which may improve the level a little. College students born in the 1990s can be hired as game consultants.
Suggestion 3: "Wind Screenwriter, your mother told you to go home and rewrite the story"
View more about The Message reviews
