A portrait of an "opportunist"

Tiffany 2022-03-20 09:01:34

I'll admit, before "Barry Lyndon," director Kubrick just made me feel bad. This Irish youth Barry's personal struggle history has to be reminiscent of Julien in "Red and Black". The film-like photography, the elegant and soothing soundtrack, and the narration of the attic storytelling-style other, these are things that even today's Hollywood directors can't match. But none of this is at the heart of Kubrick's style, including the two-stage sharp turn between good fortune and bad luck. It is worth mentioning that it was adapted from Thackeray's novel called "the luck of barry lyndon". The protagonist has successfully entered the upper class with his ingenuity. If it hadn't replicated the failure of the juvenile duel farce, it might have been another outstanding Fouche. His legendary career started with a duel and ended with a duel, but he was never the victor of the duel.
Barry is an excellent "opportunist" who is good at capturing opportunities and succeeding. From the British army to the Prussian army, from the commander of the Prussian army to the Irish knights, "defection" has become a natural thing. Of course, Kubrick is not an "art opportunist", he believes that his films are all repeating a theme: how evil in human nature leads people to depravity. Barry's possessive and controlling desires are on display in the conflict with Blington, which is quite restrained compared to Kubrick's other films. Look at "A Clockwork Orange" and "The Shining" and you'll see how Kubrick is into the evil show.
Perhaps, there is no good or evil in human nature, and good and evil only exist in the moment of behavior choice. Compared with evil, good needs more responsibility and more control, but evil can bring more physical pleasure to people. In other words, is good a repressed state of evil, the repression of eroticism over death (Freud's Civilization and Its Discontents)? It is more valuable to discover the evil of human nature than to discover the goodness of human nature, because evil is closer to human nature than good. It is true that Kubrick, the Jew, is more concerned with this profound subject than those vulgar Hollywood directors, and it is a pity that he cannot go any further on this subject. Even more regrettable, Kubrick's entire film career has not really escaped the shackles of Hollywood.

PS : may be it should be named as "a portrait of the opportunist", and it's not an epic film cause it's not about heroes.

View more about Barry Lyndon reviews

Extended Reading
  • Desiree 2021-11-13 08:01:24

    The attempt to reproduce the film structure completely in accordance with literature may not be very successful. Cool and humorous, I really want to laugh when I watch the extras stand or walk to complete the composition. Only Kubrick can let me endure Ryan O'Neal for three hours. The actors of the lady and the priest are amazing, especially for the latter. I wrongly blamed Van Eyck's paintings of people who really grew up like this.

Barry Lyndon quotes

  • Narrator: [voice-over] It is well to dream of glorious war in a snug armchair at home, but it is a very different thing to see it first hand. And after the death of his friend, Barry's thoughts turned from those of military glory to those of finding a way to escape the service to which he was now tied for another six years. Gentlemen may talk of the age of chivalry, but remember the ploughmen, poachers and pickpockets whom they lead. It is with these sad instruments that your great warriors and kings have been doing their murderous work in the world.

  • Redmond Barry: Sir, I... I have a confession to make to you. I'm an Irishman. And my name is Redmond Barry. I was abducted into the Prussian army two years ago, and now have been put into your service by my Captain Potzdorf, and his uncle, the Minister of Police... to serve as a watch upon your... actions... and to give information to the same quarter.

    Narrator: [voice-over] The Chevalier was as much affected as Barry at thus finding one of his countrymen. For he too was an exile from home, and a friendly voice, a look, brought the old country back to his memory again.