This is the most rational analysis of
my infrared scanner. The failure I said was just not ideal and perfect, maybe It's the most real truth. Sometimes the truth is so terrible and sad.
Watching the movie The reader feels it. The saddest thing in the world is to be fooled and sold, and still laughing and helping others count their money, haha !
The Reader, an Oscar-nominated film, only won the award for Best Actress. I think the Oscar judges really missed the mark. In addition to the good performances of the actors, the film expresses the history and the emotions of the characters. I vomit blood very much.
"The reader" is adapted from the novel of the same name by the German writer Bernhard Schlink. At present, this work has not only been translated into 39 languages and sold all over the world million copies, and the first German novel to top the New York Times bestseller list.
At the 2009 Bafta Awards, Kate Winslet also won the Best Actress Award for the film.
In the 81st Oscars - Best Actress is also Kate Winslet "Life and Death" The Reader
Although the story takes place in Germany, it was shot in English as the main language for everyone to understand, so the books in the film are mainly in English. If the heroine does not understand English, it means that she does not understand her own mother tongue.
I read it first I paid attention to this film only because of other people's film critics. Basically, I applauded it with one side, saying that it was a touching love story that a boy read aloud for the woman he liked for many years.
But after watching the film, after my infrared scanning After the scanner scan, the story told in the film made me vomit blood so much that I came to the opposite conclusion. A German version of Lust and Caution and an illogical story and a very unfair trial and a selfish, narrow-minded, revengeful Bad man. After reading my comment, you will understand the reason for Michael's every move. You will understand why the lover Michael spends so much time reading to Hanna, but refuses to reply to Hanna's letter. Explain also Why did Michael read the 12-year-old recording to Hanna? He could go but never meet him.
Hematemesis 1: Before watching other people's film reviews, they praised their love and Michael's perseverance. I thought Michael was a man for love. The persistent lover is actually a selfish, stupid, cowardly, and deliberate vindictive maniac. He doesn't understand what true love is. He doesn't love his parents, his daughter, his family, he's narrow-minded, and he doesn't understand the true feelings of the world. hypocrite.
film began in Neustadt, West Germany, 1958, that year Michael15 years old, he unfortunately got scarlet fever, because he got help then 36-year-old actress Hanna, and grateful.
after a good start for a while they are sick Michael to Sex-based love. This is Michael's unforgettable first love and first sex. Hanna, who is 21 years older than Michael, used Michael's desire and ignorance of the opposite sex
to obtain physical and psychological satisfaction. Michael provided Hanna with It was a physical comfort, and through reading aloud, Hanna felt the happiness that she, an illiterate, could not do by herself.
Although this kind of love is rare, it doesn't hurt the society, it's just an emotion between two people. It's understandable to happen. I think this is the first love for Michael, so making him unforgettable is also a blow to Michael's future love outlook Big.
But for Hanna, it was just to use the ignorant teenager's desire for the opposite sex and yearning for love to satisfy himself and fill the emptiness, so he left without saying goodbye after that. Later, there was a clip that explained from the side that their relationship was not. It will last for a long time. When Michael's all-boy class has a new female classmate and Michael stares at Sophie in a daze, the teacher reminds him of the scene, which fully shows the inevitability of the end of the relationship between Michael and Hanna.
The failure of this story Many, first of all, Michael was only 15 years old at the time, still living in a big family, without the ability to work and live independently. So it is impossible for Michael to go to Hanna's place every day after school, read, read, wash, wash, etc. It all takes a lot of time. Parents don’t interfere and understand at all. It’s impossible to perfunctory parents with the excuse of getting lost every day. Both parents and schools should ask about this kind of thing. So Michael and Hanna don’t get along well. It may have been so smooth, without any twists and turns from other people.
After that, Michael studied at Heidelberg Law School in 1966, and 8 years later, he met Hanna in a Nazi case trial. After Michael knew that Hanna was illiterate and illiterate, he was very righteous. Say, this secret will affect the outcome of the trial. Super selfish and stupid Michael. The fact of this case is that one of their 6 guards must be the person who wrote the report and this person is their leader. But certainly not the illiterate Hanna .Very bloody The author used the name of justice to cover up Michael's selfishness and stupidity. He said that Hanna was illiterate, and it was the real justice for the other 5 people who lied and the leader who really gave orders and wrote reports. .
When Michael had the opportunity to visit Hanna in 1966, he backed away when he was at the door, and then sent his female classmates to the sun at night to vent his cowardice and narrow-mindedness. Hanna left without saying goodbye, and Michael wants to take revenge on her now. What a selfish and cowardly Michael, I don't like it.
In Neustadt, West Germany, after Michael divorced in 1976, he took his daughter back to the home where he lived as a child. Michael's mother said that you didn't come back to your father's funeral, and that you were willing to come back after the divorce. , I'm very worried about you.
Michael couldn't maintain a good marriage because of the damage Hanna caused to his love. After 10 years of Hanna's imprisonment, Michael got divorced. Michael saw the previous books and remembered his first love with Hanna, The pain of that defeat led him to have a plan of revenge after 18 years. He began to read aloud to Hanna like a madman. He wanted to rekindle his hope just like Hanna did, and then leave her fiercely without saying goodbye, causing her to fall into the abyss .
after taken after the authors describe Hanna, then 54-year-old Hanna has been with a woman listening to the dog, even touched to learn to read, I Kuangyun, then lived for 54 years, not even the Hanna this simple and common She doesn't know any words. And learning to read is to learn from novels, is it possible? The illiterate, illiterate, doesn't know all the letters. No one taught her to learn without a teacher, haha. A super failure for the sake of sensationalism. False It's illogical.
In 1988, when 66-year-old Hanna could be released from prison. Michael went to see Hanna at the restaurant, when Hanna reached out to Michael very enthusiastically, Michael touched her hand, immediately let go, and then very Indifferently told Hanna that he had arranged for her a job, a single residence, and that Hanna could go to the public library to read books in the future. Michael's actions showed that he would not live with Hanna outside prison, nor would he read novels again To Hanna.
Check out their following conversation in the restaurant:
Michael: You read a lot. (You read a lot)
Hanna: I prefer been read to. (I prefer to be read by others)
Hanna thought that Michael still loved her that he made so many tapes for her.
Michael didn't speak at this time
Hanna: That's over now, isn't it? (Both It's over, right)
(Hanna realizes it's over, before Michael said let her live alone and let her go to the library)
Michael still doesn't speak for
a while
before Hanna asks: Did you get married?
Hanna realizes Michael is 45 years old, so he should have been married. Maybe now Michael is so indifferent to himself because he has a family. Considering this reason, Hanna still has a little hope for
Michael . Michael: I did , Yes I did. We have a daughter...
Michael said he was married once and had a daughter, but the marriage didn't last long... The
two were silent and thinking
Michael: Have you spent a lot of time thinking about the past ? (Have you spent a lot of time thinking about the past) Here I think Michael's psychology is asking Hanna, do you regret all these years?
Hanna: You mean with you? (You mean those days with you?)
Michael: no, no I did not mean to me ( no, not referring to me).
here Hanna look of disappointment and surprise
Hanna: Before the trial, I never thought about the past. i never had to
Michael: Now? What do you feel now? )
Michael is finding out if Hanna is hurt by disappointment, like the kind of piercing pain that Hanna let him go swimming in the winter to vent.
Hanna: It doesn't matter what I think, it doesn't matter what I feel, are at the dead Still dead.
(how I think, how I feel does not matter, dead is dead) Hanna was completely disappointed
Michael:. the I WAS not the Sure the What you've learned Select this item
(I'm not sure you learn What) Michael Hanna pursued to determine whether heart hurt
Hanna: the What the I have have learned Select this item, Kid, the I've learned Select this item to the read.
(I learned what, boy, I learned to read)
Michael in the restaurant gave Hanna a Despair, I don't think there is any despair comparable to Michael's ruthlessness. After giving Hanna hope for 12 years, he pushed Hanna, who was full of hope for a life out of prison, into the abyss of despair. And died. Hanna only hurt Michael reluctantly once, Hanna knew that Michael would not last long, so he left him mercilessly. No hope was given to him, in fact, it was really good for everyone.
But Michael, on the surface seems to be a great lover, but Michael's stupidity, selfishness and cowardice, I think Michael is revenge for Hanna's hurt to his feelings back then. True love is not like this. After
Hanna committed suicide, Michael got To be relieved, the film describes that in 1995, 7 years later, Michael took his daughter to the place where he buried Hanna, which once gave Michael the best memories of his life, and the place where Hanna went out when he was in love. It is explained here. Michael's relief and redemption, let go of his hatred of Hanna, and keep their love.
Hematemesis II, a super mentally retarded and unfair trial. In 1966, when Michael accidentally met Hanna in court, he was on the sidelines A Nazi case. The cause of the case was the winter prisoner removal operation in 1944. Everyone knows that history, that the vast majority of Jews died in the concentration camps at that time.
Hanna was only 22 years old and five other The women were the guards in charge of the transfer. The plaintiffs accused the 6 of them of murder, saying that the 6 of them deliberately killed nearly 300 Jews. In fact, in the context of the war at that time, if they, as guards, released these Jews, Six of them will be subject to military law and will be shot. Under such circumstances, I believe that they who are used to the massacre will not risk their lives to release these Jews who cannot escape.
This seems to be just and righteous . The court of the court, what they do really makes people torture the justice of the law and despise their legal procedures. A fair trial is to make a lot of objective proofs to prove that the defendant has an inescapable guilt.
Therefore, there will be pre-trial and transcripts. Wait for the steps. After the transcript is completed, the suspect needs to read it and sign it. If there is this process, how could the illiterate Hanna escape the eyes of the bailiff, and how can she not feel that Hanna doesn't even know all the letters.
The court also said that all five people except Hanna denied their crimes at the time. Only Hanna was willing to tell what happened and surrendered. At that time, there were only six of them, and one of them must be the leader (the real responsible criminal). , Although the leader can deny it, but the other 5 people are well aware of it, why no one testified, not even the most honest Hanna, it's strange. The
court's final verdict really made me vomit blood. Is it a slap in the face, an inexplicable trial? It is not objective at all, it is super subjective, and the mastermind can be confirmed as long as the handwriting of the person who wrote the report can be confirmed in court. Huo, is there such a superficial judge? The report can be responsible If you write it yourself, you can also ask your subordinates to write it. As long as the handwriting is who is responsible, you will be responsible for it. Bring some wisdom, okay? As long as the suspect admits it, the culprit will be her. Hey, Feixue in June. An illiterate who is sincere, honest, illiterate and know how to repent, because he refused to let others know that he is illiterate, and was sentenced to life imprisonment. The real executioner, who is hypocritical and cunning, shirks his responsibility because he does not tell the truth. , but escaped life imprisonment, and only needs to serve 4 years and 3 months.
What is the world, where is the law of nature, the sorrow of mankind, the fall of the legal system, and a group of sanctimonious hypocrites make fairness disappear.
In fact, the real thing to praise in terms of human nature is Hanna, although she takes a lot of face, at least she is the most sincere and honest person. Bravely admits what she has done, truly repents, and donates her inheritance to the Jews. Hanna often chooses those who are weak and sick, because Hanna knows It is difficult for those old, weak, sick and disabled to survive in the harsh environment of the concentration camp for a long time. Most of the women died on the march, so she left the chance of survival to those who were healthy.
The second failure, Hanna was born on October 21, 1922 and joined the Nazi SS in 1943. Hanna described in the story is an illiterate who can only write his own name. Such an illiterate can only understand some life and spoken words. Vocabulary, right? But those novels definitely don't have a lot of colloquial vocabulary, there are a lot of vocabulary words that people with certain knowledge know. Even if Michael read it to her, Hanna wouldn't know what it meant, nor I can understand what Michael is reading, and it is even more impossible to enjoy Michael's reading. Michael is not so retarded that he can't even notice such a simple thing. It was only 8 years later, in 1966, that Michael refused to accept Hanna's trial. handwriting verification only realize that Hanna was illiterate, late failure ah.
so the German writer described as the female lead such a low level of illiteracy is really hard to get the whole story has a normal logic.
later, with the 36-year-old Hanna even the menu I don't understand how illiterate Hanna is. But the author arranged Hanna as a train conductor. In a country where the illiteracy rate is only 10%, the illiteracy rate in big cities should be lower. A junior illiterate can hide for so long. Was found, really admire, sweating. . . . .
When she was 54 years old, she only started to learn to read because she was moved. She was dizzy. After 54 years of living, Hanna, who is so self-motivated and likes to listen to people read, doesn't even know such a simple vocabulary as the word "the", and the author writes too much. Are you mentally handicapped? When you look at Hanna circling every tick in the book with a pen, have you found the feeling of learning to read when you first learned to read? Ha ha.
In 1988, when 66-year-old Hanna was finally released from prison,
I also understand why Michael didn't reply to Hanna's letter, and he didn't see Hanna for 22 years (because meeting is like sending a tape to Hanna, few outsiders can know, plus Michael's legal status, it's even more difficult for him to get in and out of prison. Some people will suspect that he is going to meet an old lover. So Michael doesn't go to see Hanna because he is not worried about the world's vision, but because he is afraid of seeing the light and dying. love, and then mercilessly let Hanna despair, to complete his revenge purposes.
in Hanna's death, Michael went to the United States that year saw the Jews plaintiff, in her conversation, Michael finally began to break out, this time for Michael Hanna Still love and hate. When the Jewish accuser asked about Hanna's influence on Michael, Michael revealed that Hanna had a bad influence on her, She's done much worse than other people. The implication is that what Hanna did to him was also bad , very bad. Seeing this, you should understand the reasons for what Michael did before.
The only thing that makes me happy in The Reader is that although the heroine has no noble personality, at least she is a sincere and honest person The people who have a good heart are also good-hearted. The justice incarnations of those sanctimonious judges and lawyers do things that destroy justice.
The film seems to describe a great lover, but from the analysis of the details, you will see that every step of Michael has cause and effect. Don't be mistaken by Michael insisting on reading aloud and thinking that it is his persistent love. If he really is If you love Hanna so much, you should start recording and reading for Hanna in 1966, when Michael was not married, not until after his marriage failed in 1976. Nor will Hanna be notified in 1966 that someone came to see her, but he left without saying goodbye, If Michael really loved Hanna, he wouldn't do such a thing. He wouldn't just record and read novels to Hanna. He had the opportunity to visit Hanna often, but he had never been there in 22 years. After finally reuniting with Hanna, he said such indifferent and ruthless words. Everything was just a revenge mentality due to Michael's resentment.
This is the most rational analysis of
my infrared scanner. The failure I said was just not ideal and perfect, maybe is the truest truth. Sometimes the truth is so terrifying and pathetic.
View more about The Reader reviews
