Love makes science powerless

Lexie 2022-03-02 08:01:47

After reading Keigo Higashino's original work and then watching the movie, I did find many adaptations.
The first of course is the characters. The actors appeared as the original cast of the TV series, so Kaoru Uchikai played by Yuki Shibazaki and the female forensic doctor who maintained a certain appearance rate in every episode of the TV series, which were not in the original book, appeared as a matter of course, but the role of the former was not as good as in the TV series after all. There are so many heroines, and they don't play a big role. However, the setting of the female forensic doctor was unexpected. Since the identity of Hanaoka Yasuko in the lunch shop was changed from the host to the proprietress, in the original book, the direct clue that the boss and his wife guessed that Shi Shen liked Jingzi became the female forensic doctor's casual guess that someone had a crush on Yasushi to give Inner Sea indirect inspiration. . The movie deliberately weakens Kudo, makes the plot more compact, and deletes the marriage proposal, which may make Yasukiko less hesitant and wavering in the final choice, but this arrangement also weakens Yasushi's feelings for Kudo. Not so convincing, It also lacks the original rich and tangled psychological activities. As for Jingzi, the biggest difference is the appearance. She changed from an ordinary middle-aged woman in the original book to a beautiful woman in the mouths of the people, probably to make the female forensic doctor's guess justified, but the actor who played her couldn't give me a beautiful woman. feeling, sorry. In addition, I also don't think it makes sense for Jingzi's identity change. The money she made in the past should have been taken away by her ex-husband Fu Jian. It is unlikely that she will be able to leave a lot of private money and open a store.
Secondly, probably due to the limitation of space, many clues were simplified, and a lot of dialogues and dialogues about the debate and discussion including bicycles were omitted. People like me who have read the book may not be very adaptable, because they already have the explanation and supplement of the book in their heads, so they cannot objectively judge the rationality and completeness of the logic of the film. But unexpectedly, the movie version also has some extra dramas. In addition to the psychological battle, the paragraph where Yukawa and Shishen meet to climb the mountain can also be regarded as an explanation and exaggeration of the friendship between the two, but let us see that there is nothing in the TV series. Yukawa, who can't, also has physical weakness and is obviously at a disadvantage. It seems that there are some inconsistencies and superfluousness. Some scenes even make me suspect that Shishen will kill people and silence them. In addition, the blood type A mentioned in the movie did not appear in the original book, which made me find that there is a bug in Shishen's plan. It should be possible to collect the blood type from the corpse. If Fu Jian's medical files indicate his Blood type, so how does Shishen ensure that the blood type of the homeless person is the same as him? This ill-considered detail is too easy to pass up.
The description of the psychological activities in the original is very detailed, but the movie seems to be insufficient in inner drama, so it tests the performance of the actors. Evidently, Tsutsumi has defended his status as the absolute leading man with his breakthrough appearance and brilliant acting, although he may have to be second in the cast. In contrast, the heartthrob Masaharu Fukuyama, who shines in the TV series, is eclipsed. This may also be related to the character setting itself, because in this case Yukawa does not use physical analysis, calculation and experiment like science and education TV series. The angle and method to solve the case, but purely rely on common sense, logic, insight and understanding of the stone god.
As a genius, Shi Shen was depressed and had to make a living by teaching students who did not understand mathematics and did not respect mathematics at all. His great mathematical mind was running at high speed in depression, and finally made everyone see him in the most regrettable and regrettable way. of ingenuity. Yukawa never understood why Shishen could make such a big sacrifice for a woman, because he couldn't understand what kind of mental journey Shishen went through. He was indifferent to the world, but the polite greetings and bright smiles of Yasuko and Misato ignited a fiery flame in his inner desire and enthusiasm. In his eyes, they were the top of his head. The angel who came to save him under the halo, Yasushi is a sacred and inviolable goddess, and it is the only meaning for him to survive in this world again. So he became more forbearing, humbly admired Jingzi in a corner where no one was paying attention, and watched Jingzi silently, until God gave him the opportunity to stand up to protect Jingzi and repay Jingzi. He used his actual actions to prove that his love can stand the test of God. In order to cover up the murder of Yasukiko and Miri, he actually killed another innocent person and was ready to pay the price of his life. Should we call this kind of love great? At least, such extreme, deep, strong and unrelenting love, no one is moved by it.
In this case, for the first time, Yukawa's obsession was offensive. I really want to excuse him. The reason he told the truth to Jingzi was not because it was uncomfortable to keep the truth in his heart and not tell it, nor was it because he was selfish and wanted to destroy the deception that Shishen worked so hard to run, but he couldn't help but blame him. Love cannot be calculated and proved by theory and experiment. Even the erudite and talented Yukawa can’t use it. The fact is that Yukawa is a love-deficiency patient with low emotional intelligence. He has no interest in unreasonable love. Naturally It is also impossible to understand the behavior and mentality of Shishen with a heart-to-heart. From the beginning to the end, he felt that the sacrifice of the stone god was too great and not worth it, so he couldn't watch Jingzi ignorantly. He told Jingzi that he should understand the meaning and sacrifice of the stone god and pay for it. Her reward is the affirmation of what the Stone God has done and what the Stone God deserves, but he is very wrong. What Shishen wants is not Jingzi's gratitude, but her happiness in the second half of her life, to exchange her life for the happy life of Jingzi's mother and daughter. This is the only and the last thing he can do, so his mission to regain his life is also It came to a perfect ending. This is what he thinks is most worthwhile. Perhaps while the mother and daughter are enjoying happiness, they will always remember that there is such a person who cares for them, which is an extra reward. The same extraordinary wisdom and the pursuit of scientific rigor and perfection make Shishen and Yukawa sympathetic. Shishen is also grateful to Yukawa, the only person who knows how to appreciate his mind, but Yuchuan can't read his heart. . In fact, Shishen never expected others to understand the meaning of everything he did, and he didn't need others to understand at all, but because of this, he failed. And for Yuchuan, I'm afraid it's also resentful.
Do not do what you want to others, Tang Chuan told the truth and transferred the pain to Jingzi. This is a very unkind behavior, but this poor and pathetic woman actually turned herself in and sacrificed for her for her true love. All the stone gods are so cruel. Yes, Shishen's kindness is something she can't repay in this life, but at least she can make Shishen feel at ease and comfort instead of hurting him. It is also an atonement. Bearing the guilt of never resting, enduring pain and suffering outside the prison but faking the illusion of happiness, on the contrary, it can make the Stone God feel happy and satisfied, which is the best reward for the Stone God. The only meaning of surrendering herself is to free Yasukiko herself, but the price is to put the sacrifice of Shishen's efforts on fire. If I were Shishen, I wouldn't have to wait for the day when the sentence was pronounced to be mad at her, and she never thought about it As a result, how will the underage daughter deal with herself. From this point of view, Jingzi is the most selfish.
Jingzi rescued Shishen from despair, but pushed him into another despair. This was something Shishen did not expect, but it was probably the biggest blow he had suffered in his life. He couldn't accept it. Jingzi was reading the letter. After the sincere and tearful letter, he still chose to let him down, not to let him be at ease, unable to accept the flawless topic he devised with his genius mind, but in the end it turned out to be nothing, which was undoubtedly given to him from behind fatal blow. This scene in the movie is even more sensational than the original. Shishen's face is distorted in pain, and his heart-piercing screams are just like the novel "as if he was vomiting his soul", but even so, he still died. He did not admit it, and made a last senseless struggle, Yasukiko knelt on the ground and kept weeping "I'm sorry", while Yukawa listened to the two people's cries in the room where he talked with Shishen before. It confirms the conclusion that "no one can be happy" when Ishigami admonished Yukawa. So far, the tragedy of the story and the character of Shishen have reached the extreme.
The limited wisdom of human beings is always powerless in the face of the vast and broad science, but what even science is powerless is human emotions and the decisions and actions taken accordingly. Shi Shen guessed the process, but guessed the ending wrong, leaving only two lines of turbid tears and a sigh.

View more about Suspect X reviews

Extended Reading

Suspect X quotes

  • Manabu Yukawa: Is it harder to create an unsolvable problem or solve it?