Pirates of the Caribbean 5's logical contradiction points out

Alexander 2022-03-19 09:01:03

The content of the fifth episode has a very big contradiction and discrepancy with the first four episodes.

1. The source of Jack's compass: Jack's compass In "Pirates of the Caribbean: Deathman", it is clearly pointed out that Jack exchanged something with the goddess of the sea (the witch at the time). It wasn't given to Jack by the old Captain Black Pearl. Unless it is said that Jack's compass was lost, it was picked up by the goddess of the sea and then returned by Jack, but it was not explained in the plot.

2. Regarding the setting that Jack will release Salazar if he gives up the compass: Jack has handed the compass to others more than once in the first three plots, but it seems that none of them have attracted Salazar. The specific plot can be watched previous movies.

3. Barbossa's daughter: The story time background of "Dead Men Tell No Tales" is set 20 years after the story of "The End of the World", and Barbossa is already in his fifties and sixties in "The End of the World" and Barbossa is also one of the first 9 pirates, older than Jack's father. But Barbosa's daughter in Dead Men Tell No Tales is only 18. In other words, Barbossa is an old woman? ? ? Even Barbossa gave birth to a daughter later than Tina gave birth to a son? (Turner's son is 20) Barbossa, 80, and his 18-year-old daughter, emmmm. This is obviously illogical.

All in all, the plot of "Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales" has begun to show so much confusion and inconsistency that I'd rather the fourth installment of the series be the final chapter. The quality of a movie is always based on the plot, and should not put the cart before the horse and only focus on whether the special effects production can deceive passers-by's movie ticket money.

I always think that the "Pirates of the Caribbean" series is a series of fan-oriented movies similar to "Harry Potter". At least the first three are not particularly friendly to passers-by. If this kind of film is only born to make passers-by's money If you change the plot, it will really disappoint the old fans.

We have all seen that the first three "Pirates of the Caribbean" are as exciting and epic as "Harry Potter", or even surpassed, but "Harry Potter" is finally faithful to the original, and it is close to the original. The field ended in almost perfect fashion. If Dead Men Tell No Tales is the final chapter in Pirates of the Caribbean, it feels like you're telling me a "legendary" story that you haven't figured out yet, anticlimactic, and I'm very unacceptable.

So just for this one, I can only give 2 stars, because the plot really disappointed me, an old Caribbean fan.

View more about Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales reviews

Extended Reading
  • Arden 2022-03-21 09:01:22

    Continue to consume Depp and the charm of the original sound, the plot routine is as deep as the sea.

  • Devonte 2021-10-20 19:02:51

    A mediocre, playful, meaningless sequel, the captain loses his charm more and more, and writes like an idiot, angry.

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales quotes

  • Henry: [whispers into a jail cell] I need to speak with you.

    Captain Jack Sparrow: [attacks Henry from behind, holding him against the cell door] Hand me your sword.

    Henry: I don't have a sword.

    Captain Jack Sparrow: What kind of soldier has no weapon?

    Henry: I'm currently wanted for treason.

    Captain Jack Sparrow: So not the very good kind then?

    Henry: I'm looking for a pirate, Captain Jack Sparrow?

    Captain Jack Sparrow: [let's go of Henry] Well today's your lucky day. Because I just happen to be Captain Jack Sparrow.

    Henry: [in disbelief] No, it can't be. I've spent years searching for... this. The great Jack Sparrow is not some drunk in a cell. Do you even have a ship? A crew... pants?

    Captain Jack Sparrow: A great pirate does not require such intricacies.

    Henry: Do you know how long I've been waiting for this moment? The risks I've taken to be here? Are you sure you're *the* Jack Sparrow?

    Captain Jack Sparrow: The real question is, who are you?

  • Henry: [Henry has just been rescued by the Flying Dutchman after attempting to drown himself to gain his father's attention]

    [sees a shadowy figure approach]

    Henry: Father?

    Will Turner: Henry. What have you done?

    Henry: I said I'd find you.

    Will Turner: Look at me, son.

    [half of Will's face and body are covered in barnacles]

    Henry: I don't care.

    Will Turner: There's no place for you on the Dutchman.

    [the Dutchman's crew can be heard in the background]

    Will Turner: They know you're here. Get home to your mother.

    Henry: No!

    Will Turner: Leave now. Before it's too late.

    Henry: I won't. I'll never stop. And if you throw me over, I'll come straight back.

    Will Turner: Don't you see I'm cursed to this ship?

    Henry: That's why I'm here. I think I know a way to break your curse. To free you from the Dutchman.

    Will Turner: Henry, no.

    Henry: I've read about a treasure. A treasure that holds all the power of the sea. The Trident of Poseidon can break your curse.

    Will Turner: [kneels down to hug Henry] Henry, the trident can never be found.

    Henry: I found you.

    Will Turner: It's just a tale.

    Henry: Like the tales of you and Captain Jack Sparrow? He will help me find the trident.

    Will Turner: You stay away from Jack! Leave the sea forever. You have to stop acting like a...

    Henry: A pirate? I won't stop. I want you to come home.

    Will Turner: [the Dutchman starts sinking back into the sea] Henry. I'm sorry. My curse will never be broken.

    [takes off his necklace]

    Will Turner: This is my fate.

    [places the necklace in Henry's hands]

    Will Turner: You must let me go.

    [reaches out to gently touch Henry's face]

    Will Turner: I love you, son.

    Henry: [the Dutchman sinks fully into the sea, forcing Henry to swim to the surface and reboard his rowboat]

    [while lying inside his rowboat]

    Henry: Captain Jack Sparrow.