Pirates of the Caribbean 5's logical contradiction points out

Alexander 2022-03-19 09:01:03

The content of the fifth episode has a very big contradiction and discrepancy with the first four episodes.

1. The source of Jack's compass: Jack's compass In "Pirates of the Caribbean: Deathman", it is clearly pointed out that Jack exchanged something with the goddess of the sea (the witch at the time). It wasn't given to Jack by the old Captain Black Pearl. Unless it is said that Jack's compass was lost, it was picked up by the goddess of the sea and then returned by Jack, but it was not explained in the plot.

2. Regarding the setting that Jack will release Salazar if he gives up the compass: Jack has handed the compass to others more than once in the first three plots, but it seems that none of them have attracted Salazar. The specific plot can be watched previous movies.

3. Barbossa's daughter: The story time background of "Dead Men Tell No Tales" is set 20 years after the story of "The End of the World", and Barbossa is already in his fifties and sixties in "The End of the World" and Barbossa is also one of the first 9 pirates, older than Jack's father. But Barbosa's daughter in Dead Men Tell No Tales is only 18. In other words, Barbossa is an old woman? ? ? Even Barbossa gave birth to a daughter later than Tina gave birth to a son? (Turner's son is 20) Barbossa, 80, and his 18-year-old daughter, emmmm. This is obviously illogical.

All in all, the plot of "Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales" has begun to show so much confusion and inconsistency that I'd rather the fourth installment of the series be the final chapter. The quality of a movie is always based on the plot, and should not put the cart before the horse and only focus on whether the special effects production can deceive passers-by's movie ticket money.

I always think that the "Pirates of the Caribbean" series is a series of fan-oriented movies similar to "Harry Potter". At least the first three are not particularly friendly to passers-by. If this kind of film is only born to make passers-by's money If you change the plot, it will really disappoint the old fans.

We have all seen that the first three "Pirates of the Caribbean" are as exciting and epic as "Harry Potter", or even surpassed, but "Harry Potter" is finally faithful to the original, and it is close to the original. The field ended in almost perfect fashion. If Dead Men Tell No Tales is the final chapter in Pirates of the Caribbean, it feels like you're telling me a "legendary" story that you haven't figured out yet, anticlimactic, and I'm very unacceptable.

So just for this one, I can only give 2 stars, because the plot really disappointed me, an old Caribbean fan.

View more about Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales reviews

Extended Reading

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales quotes

  • [Henry saves Carina]

    Henry: From this moment forth we are to be allies!

    Carina Smyth: Considering where your left hand is, I'd say we're more than that!

  • [Jack is to be executed]

    Captain Jack Sparrow: Guillotine? Sounds French. I love the French! How bad can it be? It's French.

    [sees what the guillotine actually is]

    Captain Jack Sparrow: Oh, that bad. I've changed me mind!

    [is frog marched up to the guillotine platform]

    Captain Jack Sparrow: You mean I have to walk up stairs as well for this?

    [is strapped to a body board]

    Captain Jack Sparrow: Here's an idea, how about a good old-fashioned stoning? I'd kill to be stoned right now!

    [gets put in the guillotine]

    Captain Jack Sparrow: I'm not normally one to complain, but this basket is full of heads!