In a capitalist society like the United States, we are always careful to unleash our desires.
When we meet a rich man, we know that it is a temporary dependence, and we can make a steady profit by getting some fruit and changing clothes. It is not a class, there will only be a dreamy friendship, and there will be no sober equality.
When we meet the flower girl, we carefully package our desire as pure kindness, channeling it only into a kind of poor man's kindness at first, not allowing any dimension of trauma, and love is destined to face trauma.
In order to avoid imagining the future in which the little man will be hurt by love, we suppressed the most genuine human erotic desire.
"What if she knew he was just a short tramp?"
This vision hurts us.
We can't even believe the same sincere love from a flower girl.
We were afraid that after surrendering all our trust, we would only get violent damage from Capitalism.
We have long been captured by Capitalism. We despise the sacredness of money on the surface, satirize money worshippers, and don’t think it can show a person’s good character, but we believe in the power of money in every dimension of reality.
Capitalism has successfully made us think that "worshiping money is shameful, but no money can't do it", a gesture of yearning for "decent life" has exposed the fact that we are enslaved.
Some people even imagined like a saint that the homeless man who had to steal the rich man's money should "surrender himself" in a righteous manner in order to continue to maintain a "good and innocent image of the poor and the poor". If it turns out to be a tragedy of mispayment in the end, they also think it is a tragedy as it should be. Capitalism succeeds in writing the "morality" that sustains itself into the minds of these people. This is the great tragedy of our Marx education.
The florist is someone who has not been teased by Capitalism's discourse, and as she always does, she's true to herself. She looked forward to love and followed what should have been the most common and normal desire. Her genuine desire was higher than the invisible law of Capitalism to her: only if you are a healthy, beautiful and decent person, you are qualified to love and to be loved.
In the homeless person played by the master, we have seen Capitalism, the invisible decree, with its claws and claws. He fell in love at first sight and fell in love at first sight, but he was under the oppression of the law from beginning to end. He didn't dare to let her see the truth, he only dared to look at her from a distance. Knowing that she had gained light, he chose to lose his voice! He left only a fragile, vulnerable kindness! That's exactly what Capitalism wants him to have!
Pygmalion who has millions of people have been deleted, forgotten, abandoned faith: by persevering man most authentic desires. No matter how the ideology of Capitalism slanders it! Twist it! Tamper it! It must not be evil! vulgar! Humble!
In this film, the expression of that belief is love.
It is sublime! Holy! Beyond!
It is not natural, it only highlights this divine dimension that ignores all the shackles of power when people insist on their own love.
The flower girl could have "unrecognized" the sloppy and funny tramp, but she complied with her true desires without any evil intentions, and she "saw" her lover with joy.
The homeless man was not brave enough in the end, nor was he brave enough in the beginning. He was not like a flower girl who avoided the most direct spiritual oppression of Capitalism in her blind loneliness. How man is oppressed, because he sees it, he is oppressed even tighter and more breathless.
He goes out of his way to be kind in a Capitalism framework, but he doesn't go out of his way to love. He would have been a great victim of Capitalism had it not been for the flower girl's true erotic desire.
The flower girl is actually constantly "gaining" in the movie, and the tramp is indeed constantly "losing".
Is life a comedy or a tragedy?
When the answer is born in the original desire in your heart, how you choose to deal with it is already doomed.
If you betray it, you betray everything.
View more about City Lights reviews
