She's not RBG

Kamron 2022-01-29 08:13:02

Let’s first summarize the differences between the film and reality:

?Ruth didn't go to class instead of Marty, but collected class notes from his classmates for him

?It wasn't Ruth who went to see Charlie for the first time, it was Marty

? Rival lawyers never turned to the Pentagon for help, but a DOJ team did. All legal summaries that differ by gender were submitted by the Harvard law department chair after losing the case, hoping to overturn the verdict

?Never moot court, RBG never got emotionally out of control--in her whole life (with a side note, my biggest complaint about this movie is that it doesn't show her rare composure at all, but instead tearful, speechless)

?Half the couple's debate was decided early on, not because of worry about her ability

?There is no final rebuttal, because she has already persuaded the judge and does not need extra time (this is her strength!)

? RBG has never blundered or flustered in her court statement - and in her entire life

?Mel Wulf was sacrificed. He and Ruth were friends who had known each other since childhood. They understood each other. Ruth joined him within a few days.

?Ruth proposed to speak to the Supreme Court himself, without any recommendation. She convinced Wulf that it would be beneficial to the case to have a woman present.

?The senior female lawyer who helped her in the film has never participated in the defense of women's rights cases, and this role is only placed in general to pay tribute to women in the legal profession who have worked hard for this before.

Personally, I feel that it has greatly reduced (if not completely unshown) the power of RBG? ‍♀️And it's really too similar to "Legal Blonde"...

View more about On the Basis of Sex reviews

Extended Reading
  • Dane 2022-03-26 09:01:14

    【C】The great is the real person, the movie is the mediocre. When I think about it, my favorite thing to watch in junior high school is this kind of movies that are so neat that they don't look like movies. You see my aesthetic standards in film will change, and so will people's perceptions of the role women can play in society. Nothing is always reasonable. It takes the courage to change and the courage to step out of your comfort zone to get ahead. "Customs" and "customs" are not and should not be the gold medals of the traditional dross. More than a hundred years ago, women's foot binding was also a custom.

  • Trevor 2022-03-19 09:01:10

    The final speech was full of tears. Forget the family motto "be a lady", forget the "gentle and elegant", it is a gift for friends and lovers. Be a soldier, stay angry at injustice, learn to be angry, dare to say "I dissent", because anger will help you and become the strongest force, because even if you are gentle, quiet, introverted, shy, rational, rigorous, Self-discipline, intelligence, humor, tenacity..., but as long as it touches the cake of the vested interests, it is also scolded by opponents as "witch, villain, devil", still "notorious", and even by men of the same camp Friends ridiculed as "shrew". "I'm not asking for any perks for women, all I ask is for men to get their feet off our necks."

On the Basis of Sex quotes

  • Ruth Bader Ginsburg: It's not a privilege, it is a Cage. And these laws are the bars!

  • Ruth Bader Ginsburg: [testifying before the Tenth District Court] We're not asking you to change the country. That's already happened without any court's permission. We're asking you to protect the right of the country to change.