she's still there to be stared at

Opal 2022-02-24 08:02:17

After so many years, I am afraid that Joan of Arc under the lens of Bresson still cannot be surpassed by the later image.

Before going to see this movie, I first watched "Joan of Arc" filmed in Canada in 1999. It was a big movie I saw when I was a child. Lily Soboski, who lost her long hair by the water, was my childhood. The most beautiful face in memory.

Until I finished reading Bresson's story of Joan of Arc, I thought that this Joan of Arc, who was dressed in men's clothes, was tenacious, responded calmly, and had the wisdom of struggle, should be closer to the real her. At the same time, she also has handsome eyebrows, a soft face and spring-like eyes.

Lily's version of Joan of Arc has an epic narrative that unfolds the major events of Joan's life as a memoir. And Bresson's Joan of Arc, like a convicted person who was brought to the audience for trial, her image was gradually established under the gaze of the audience, and her experience gradually emerged in the conversation.

Bresson focused on Joan of Arc, not the legend. So he told the actors not to think for a moment during the performance that they were Joan of Arc. He tried to faithfully recreate the process of Joan of Arc's trial, like a documentary director, with great enthusiasm for realism.

The truth is in the details that are so easily overlooked. For example, Joan of Arc's bare feet stumbled on the way to the stake. No one remembers Joan in this way, so this scene is unsurpassed. The robe she wore to death, the men's clothes and boots she was burned with, in these plain places, lay the poetry and truth of this story.

The girl was gone from the charred stake, and everyone knew that she was burnt to nothing, but they still stared at the charred stake as if she were still there.

View more about The Trial of Joan of Arc reviews

Extended Reading
  • Dennis 2022-04-24 07:01:24

    Simple and concise stable medium shots, and a few piercing peep-through faux-mask lenses are brilliant. Stripped of emotional restraint, trial after trial is like a cold whizzing wind. From being imprisoned to going to the burning site, the camera is repeatedly aimed at the feet, a Joan of Arc walking on the doctrinal centralization.

  • Delmer 2022-04-20 09:02:33

    Bresson seems to have taken a different path with his back to Dreyer. The steady medium background, low-contrast tone, and the presentation of audio-visual elements (close-up of footsteps and noisy crowds) restore a space-time with a realistic depth, almost Like a court-trial documentary program or a video of a drama rehearsal, in his footage, the characters are always mechanical and indifferent (the expressions of the church personnel are dissolved in the rigid movements), and they respond to a certain will like a marionette, except for the lines and the cross. , nothing makes one think of the divine, Joan of Arc is more like the girl next door in trousers who strayed into the set, which may be Bresson's purpose, with a modern gaze, to interrogate the original divinity of the story, and use the camera to contain it , the ending is strong.

The Trial of Joan of Arc quotes

  • Jeanne d'Arc: I place my trust in God and love him with all my heart. He is my judge and king of heaven and earth.

  • Jeanne d'Arc: I've done no wrong. I believe in the articles of faith and the ten commandments. I trust in the synod and pope and wish to believe what the church believes.