Talk about the emotional logic of the dark phoenix

Santino 2022-03-21 09:01:53

I think the logic of the story is adequate, although it's not very good. The emotional logic seems to be that everyone is more angry, but my judgment is also OK, and I don't think it has escaped the usual emotional style of Chaman.

At the beginning, the source of Qin's tragedy was explained. She caused her mother's death because she could not control her ability (emotion). If she were a normal girl, nothing would happen or the damage would be far less than this, just because she was a [mutant], the damage she could do was far beyond her control.

People are afraid of things they cannot control.

So she felt guilty and painful. She felt that her fault was her fault. She couldn't accept herself like this. If she hadn't met the professor, the girl's psychological trauma would have swallowed her up. The phrase "You're not broken" saved her. However, the professor left behind the bane: he concealed that her father was alive and hated his daughter. This practice is debatable. The professor's [ego] is too sure that he can save a person, but when the truth that has been suppressed for many years surfaced, he did not think clearly about what kind of emotions the person would be attacked by.

Do I think he is wrong? I do not think so.

But he couldn't think he was wrong.

Because of what he did, Qin felt that he was hurt, so he was wrong.

So I also don't think Jean's ability (emotion) to awaken unexpectedly, and the consequences are unreasonable, including her forcing the professor to walk, I don't think it's shameful to vent her anger. Finally, in the professor's mind, the young Qin calmly said to him that [I forgive you] is growth after anger. What Cha Man has always emphasized is inner growth, not simply controlling emotions, but facing it and coexisting with it. So in the end, Phoenix Qin said to the white-haired witch: It is my emotions that make me strong.

So in my opinion, from beginning to end, the emotional line is drawn round. Also as Yimei said, remove the superpower/alien element, this is a family drama, a family member has a psychological problem, what to do with the people around you. Although it's not as grand as everyone wants, I don't think Cha Man has always pursued the external pattern. The Cha Man I fell in love with was like this.

View more about X-Men: Dark Phoenix reviews

Extended Reading
  • Constantin 2022-03-23 09:01:53

    The worst and ugliest episode of Fork Man, Quicksilver takes three seconds, Nima, the screenwriter and director has a line saying that there is someone above me... Fortunately, it's a free IMAX ticket, wasting my precious sleep time.

  • Alysa 2022-01-28 08:05:08

    The only one among so many X-Men that hasn't appeared in Uncle Wolf for so many years is a unique end. cherish.

X-Men: Dark Phoenix quotes

  • Young Jean Grey: Can you change the station?

    Elaine Grey: When the song's over, honey?

    Young Jean Grey: You said that two songs ago.

    John Grey: You know this is a classic, right?

    Elaine Grey: Okay, how about I make you a promise? When you're old enough to drive, you can listen to whatever music you want. Hmm? That a deal?

  • Professor Charles Xavier: What do you think?

    Young Jean Grey: I can't stay here.

    Professor Charles Xavier: Okay. Why not?

    Young Jean Grey: It's too nice.

    [sighs]

    Young Jean Grey: I... I break things.

    Professor Charles Xavier: Well, how does this sound: If you break something, anything, I can fix it.

    Young Jean Grey: Not anything.

    Professor Charles Xavier: I can help you. I can help you so that you never have to break things ever again.

    Young Jean Grey: You think you can fix me too.

    Professor Charles Xavier: No. No, because you are not broken.