------------------ -----------------------The following is the author's original text----------------------- -----------------------
== I hope that those who come to discuss can finish reading my post, rather than just come in and smash it. Welcome to rationally discuss the logic in Captain America’s 3 essays. Don’t enter into personal assaults with brain-
dead fans. At the beginning of the film, Wanda failed to control her abilities and injured civilians by mistake. She watched the accusations on herself by name and surname in the TV news.
At the beginning of the film, after Iron Man finished his speech, he met his mother in front of the elevator who had suffered the pain of losing a child. He looked at his mother's condemnation of him.
They also face the news, face their mothers, and face blame, with the same fear, pain, and confusion.
Later, Vision said to Wanda: People will fear you more. Wanda replied: "I can't control other people's fears, but I can control mine."
Until the end, when Rod, who was doing rehabilitation training, said firmly: "I didn't change my mind", Tony couldn't even give him one. Affirmative or negative echoes, eyes still erratic, painful, and confused.
The Scarlet Witch had been reborn from the ashes, and Iron Man finally died in Ultron's wounds.
======
Sukovia Agreement. A ridiculous agreement, it was made by people who had prejudice against the Premier League. It was simple and rude, without negotiation, and ignored the opinions of Premier League. After signing, you can do whatever the politicians ask you to do, freeze judgment and give up the right to choose.
They are sweating blood and sweating, wandering between life and death to maintain justice, reward is a paper agreement, and deprivation of freedom is completely reduced to a tool of politicians. Thinking of the United States team series of the Avengers 1. Iron Man series, they fought desperately to protect the people. After the victory, they were contented and proud, and their hearts were cold-the superhero was stepped on by public opinion.
Is there any difference between a superhero who signed such a bill and the Winter Soldier who was brainwashed by Hydra? ——Perhaps not as good as the Winter Soldier, the Winter Soldier is an unconscious weapon, and they have become the living dead.
========== The
US team asked Watson: Will you hire a lawyer for the Winter Soldier? Watson sneered, and said, "Are you making me laugh?"
Tony had conclusive evidence, and after knowing that the culprit was Moser, the psychiatrist, he told General Rose. General Rose looked at Tony contemptuously and said: Do you think I will believe you who have been defeated? At this time, Iron Man's expression was flat and he couldn't say a word. Iron Man has experienced painful battles with his old friends and almost lost his best friend Rod; in the eyes of General Ross, he is just a dog who has not completed the task.
This is the politician in the MCU. They only need what they want and despise the program. When you succeed, in order to use you to hold you high, after you fail, they will step on you again and don’t care about what you do. How hard have you worked, what have you lost. And Iron Man, even betrayed himself to these people!
Iron Man said that after signing the agreement, it can be amended.
The US team said: You can continue to deceive yourself.
The US team knows clearly that once an agreement is signed, there will be no more room for maneuver to negotiate with politicians, which is nothing more than trying to seek hide from a tiger. After the US team was dismantled, the expression of Iron Man lowering his head and not speaking also showed that he actually knew that he was deceiving himself.
==========
Who is the Virgin?
Many people say that the US team is not the Virgin, but the US team is not. He is always as solid as a rock and his face is full of edges and corners.
The wrong plan in Team US 2 is wrong even if Fury puts it to the top; the wrong agreement in Team US 3, even if it can be exchanged for a momentary family fun, is also wrong.
And Iron Man gave up his soul in order to please the people, to appease the politicians, and to be the self that Pepper hopes for. There is no principle to please all parties, this is the Virgin.
Who is selfish anyway?
The US team's selfishness is to protect the Winter Soldiers. The US team almost signed the bill because of selfishness. However, when he heard that Wanda was slapped, he woke up and abandoned his selfishness.
Iron Man's selfishness is to get rid of regret and self-blame for Ultron. For his selfishness, no matter what the agreement looks like, no matter what the agreement will make himself a puppet, he still has to sign the agreement.
==========
Look at what Tony said:
Tony: [No matter what form, I am willing. 】——The
translation is that I don’t listen, I don’t listen, no matter what the agreement is, I just want to sign it.
US team: [Tony, someone died in front of you, but you can't give up. If we are not responsible for our actions, we are giving up.
If we act according to the rules set by people, the rules will change. ]
Tony: [So, my weapon being used, I discontinued. ]
US team: [That is your choice. If we sign an agreement, we give up the right to choose. What if they let us go where we don't want to go? If there is a place that needs us, they won't let us go? We are not perfect, but it is better than taking orders from others. ]
Tony: [If we don’t do this, they will also force us. 】
-Here, Tony, in fact, has been unable to refute the US team's words, so he had to move out and was forced to say helplessly. The US team reasoned with him, and he played hooligans with the US team.
(There is still an argument later, I really can’t remember the lines, but in the end Tony couldn’t refute the American team from the point of view. The above paragraph is included in the trailer, but unfortunately no one has translated it, so many people failed to carefully. Taste the logic in the view of the US team.
Spider-Man said to Captain America: [Iron Man said, you are doing something that you think is right.]
——Iron Man couldn't say these words to the US team, so he had to say to a high school student who didn't know the truth and admired him, using this kind of psychological hint to cover up his extreme unconfidence.
==========When
Iron Man sat on the ground, my heart was sad. Who is this person? He is no longer the Iron Man who is full of confidence, walks on the road with his own flash, and flies in the air with sparks and lightning. He succumbed to the fear of others and lost to the sense of horror of taking responsibility for mistakes.
I even started to miss the Iron Man in the comics. Rather, he almost killed Spider-Man, copying Thor to kill so many people, but he is so hard, instead of this cowardly appearance that is always wronged and persecuted: He even dares to "you are doing what you think is right" Speaking to a high school student, calling Wanda under house arrest as "protection" comes from deceiving others, speaking to hurt teammate Black Widow in order to protect herself.
The US team has long seen through: where there are people, there will be misunderstandings and misunderstandings, where there are groups, they must be guided by public opinion. It must be wrong. You can't make everyone understand you, and you can't win without sacrifice. What they do is not to make everyone nod in praise. What they do is to do justice and take responsibility when they make mistakes.
Captain America is a very special superhero himself. He is not afraid of his own abilities like other heroes, he has been confused about the use of abilities, and finally recognizes himself through battle. He did not have this process. He knew what he wanted to do from the beginning, and his ability was what he wanted. Baptized in the rain of bullets, his faith has long been unshakable.
As for Iron Man, his knowledge of abilities is actually on the same level as Wanda. After the US team 3, his growth is not as good as Wanda.
==========
Steal a picture
The reason why Rod agrees to the agreement unconditionally is because he is a good soldier. And Captain America was never a good soldier. He just does what he thinks is right. At the end of Team 3, the captain also said, I believe in inner strength, and they didn't let me down. What flashed by the camera were the restrained but firm eyes of the Scarlet Witch, Ant-Man was entertaining himself in prison, and Falcon was always ready to be rescued by the captain. They really have a strong heart
==========
Let’s say more, it was originally the American team who brought Bucky, Falcons, Witches, Hawkeyes, and Ant-Man to fight the five Winter Soldiers, because Iron Man signed the treaty and had to obey Rose's command. He blocked the US team at the airport and became the US team and Bucky.
Iron Man should thank Zemo for killing the five Winter Soldiers instead of starting them. Otherwise, he would really make a big mistake when he signed the agreement.
==========
than miserable really boring
than anyone else who was even worse ah
World War II hero, died for the country, into its own after waking up they want to kill, not miserable miserable
dead father and mother, I want to the maintenance of peace, did not control the power, resulting in more than a dozen lives were lost, then public opinion was reviled by name, or even as a "weapons of mass destruction," the captain, not miserable miserable
death of a child's mother, not miserable miserable
losing family Zemo is not miserable,
but most miserables are passive miserables. The Winter Soldier was brainwashed, the witch's parents died in Sukovia, misunderstood by the group, the mother's child was killed, and the Zemo family was killed.
On the contrary, Iron Man’s misery was half caused by some weaknesses in his own character (of course, his parents were not killed). Ultron’s mistake made him passive after the reunion 2. He signed this wrong agreement and made him It was very embarrassing to be turned around by General Ross. Iron Man's character is his charm, but also the weakness which is particularly easy to make mistakes there are to be exploited
==========
speak a little private thing
last Iron Man sitting on the ground, I almost cry
It feels like a self
Afraid to take risks, to opt out, fill in the College Entrance Examination parents, working parents arranged object is finalized parents of
fear of the consequences, so that their cowardice and mediocrity
==========
really be how Perfect supervision, there is really no way to discuss the results. After all, in the real world, how should people be regulated? After hundreds of years of discussion, there is no accurate answer, let alone a virtual world built by comics and movies? The only certainty is that the form of supervision must not be the "Sokovia Clause."
==========
Please pay attention to what Iron Man said: [Regardless of any form of supervision, I am willing. 】
This is simply breaking the jar. No matter what the agreement looks like, whether there are loopholes or not, it must be signed, rushing to get rid of the responsibility.
This sentence shows that Iron Man is not like [He is looking for a way to change the status quo. 】Just eager to find [a way to get rid of the fear of hurting others]
=======
"Fear of hurting others" exists in the hearts of heroes, but many people have overcome this fear, such as Wang Up.
The loopholes in the agreement were obvious, and the captain had already said it, and Iron Man couldn't even refute it, so he still signed it. One thing, you know it is wrong, and you still do it. This is not an attempt. This is a crime knowingly.
[As for the form of restraint, he didn’t consider that much] It was precisely where he renounced himself. He didn’t think much about signing the agreement. He just wanted to sign the agreement hastily to seek inner salvation. This is why he relied on himself and was later engaged by General Ross. The reason for being so embarrassed.
========
Discussion: (Q is a passerby, A is the author's reply)
Q: If the actions of superheroes do not conform to public opinion, shouldn't they be restricted?
A: You know, the first public opinion is not necessarily correct, and the restriction of the second Premier League does not mean signing the Sukovia clause.
Q: What I don't understand the last few days when I watched you in a circle is why everyone stands in the position of Super England and no one considers the feelings of civilians. Isn't the latter easier to bring in under normal circumstances? Anyway, I think that if there is a Super League in the third dimension, it should definitely be controlled, and those with dangerous behavior should be culled immediately. No matter how loopholes in the bill in the movie or being used by villains, "Super League needs to be restrained". I think it’s correct
. I am opposed to Iron Man’s view that "I will agree to whatever constraints are imposed", and I am even more opposed to "Chaoying is instructed by the government to do whatever it takes." Because the government in the MCU worldview is really unreliable, I will write the evidence. In the text.
Q: In extreme terms, I don't think Super Elite should exist, let alone save them. Chaoying and the people who produce Chaoying first create chaos, and then solve the chaos, and then be promoted to the altar, isn't it funny?
A: Chaoying really shouldn't exist, but since they do exist, you can't say that they die. Moreover, the existence of Chaoying contributes far more to society than it brings side effects when solving problems, right? For example, the little spider pushes a truck that has crashed. Isn't it that Iron Man creates Ultron that first creates chaos and then solves it? . . The other bosses were not created by the Super
League, eh Q: After the Winter Soldier was transferred to Berlin, some of the things Iron Man said to the American team were quite interesting. He laughed at himself and his father were both troublesome people. Pepper broke up with him and thought He is an unregulated person, and his personal reasons for signing the agreement are quite good. The US team said that he did not accept the agreement, but he would bring it up when he saw bad signs. I felt that he would want to discuss more suitable terms with other people, including government representatives, but unfortunately there was no time...
A: No Without that time, he discovered that Iron Man had put Wanda under house arrest and lied that he was protecting Wanda. This shows that the government just wants you to sign the agreement, and the agreement has no possibility of maneuvering at all.
Q: If the bomb blows up, it's not to blame the person who placed the bomb, but the Red Witch. This logic is also NB. Is it because the bomb villains can’t afford to provoke them. If they provoke them to blow up your family every minute, Chaoying will blame themselves so it’s better to bully? This is like a robber robbing a bank, the police caught the thief and the civilians were involved in the fight, and then blamed the police for not finding an open area to fight the robber with a rod.
A: So when I saw the painful Scarlet Witch, I felt that the Super British were so sad.
Q: The government did not provide financial support to the Avengers. Why should the Avengers be supervised by them? This makes the most sense...
A: Hahaha This view seems quite right. . .
Q: The United Nations itself in the play is in a complete mess. It puts people in an underwater prison without trial, and the United Nations officials deliberately tortured and insulted the suspect (Zemo). His lethality is not equal to that of the Winter Soldier. This It is contrary to the spirit of the United Nations human rights conventions.
A: The politicians in the MCU worldview are all in a mess. . . There is nothing good about the decisions made by the entire team of 3 governments in it.
First condemned the witch, and then killed the Winter Soldier without going through the legal process, not giving it to the Winter Soldier's lawyer. Iron Man lost so much, but when General Ross faced him, he seemed to face a dog.
Q: The Winter Soldiers who committed countless crimes in the past 70 years have not been discovered by the government, and most people even think it is just a legend...Such a killer Will a face-up photo be taken after the bombing? Such a big loophole, zf deliberately ignored, and did not follow the process at all, directly issued a killing order. The zf in Team 3 is unreliable everywhere.
A: General Rose just confirmed the captain’s point of view:
[If we act according to the rules set by people, then the rules will change. ]
[That is your choice. If we sign an agreement, we give up the right to choose. What if they let us go where we don't want to go? If there is a place that needs us, they won't let us go? We are not perfect, but it is better than taking orders from others. ]
Q: To be honest I was a civil war comics iron man black, but really think comics Iron Man is very charismatic. Although he insidiously darkened the little spider, he collected Thor's DNA at the first meeting like a madman, and he was very positive as a scientist alone. Excluding conspiracy theories in the comics, he really believes that the bill will win a bright future before he supports registration. In the movie, this is really getting more and more regressive.
A: I originally criticized the iron man in the comics (actually, the US team is a bit dark in the comics, although his position is correct, but he is also very cruel), but he also shows his courage with such a politician feeling. Instead of the weak middle-aged man sitting on the ground and being used by others.
Q: From physical violation to geography, from architectural violation to society, routine fights, patterned rhythms, and forced to say that there are no bugs, there are deep meanings, and there is no more self-deception than this.
A: Hahahahahaha, you are right, comic Power against physics
=======
View more about Captain America: Civil War reviews
