A fake carnival

Cayla 2022-03-22 09:01:07

The movie seems to be full of feelings called "Lord of the Rings", the same Middle-earth world (is it the same?), the protagonist with serious fetishism, from marching to fighting (it looks good at the beginning, but is at a loss afterwards. Yun), they are all learning from the large-scale mirroring of the previous work...Every minute, it will tell you the relationship between it and the Lord of the Rings, but the two are too far apart. The feelings are sensational, and the feelings are beautiful, but, After all, it's just feelings, or it's just an illusion that we thought Peter Jackson still loved Middle-earth. "The Hobbit" is not "Lord of the Rings", but they are both Middle-earth constructed by Peter Jackson. I just don't understand why the difference between the two is so huge. The original work restricted the movie. This is mentioned too much. But behind this limitation is the mindset of the creators. I don't believe that Jackson is treating "The Hobbit" with his heart for "Lord of the Rings". "Lord of the Rings" is an epic. Before it is released, maybe many people just expect the movie to tell a good story. But the movie not only shows the epic, but also creates a world. "The Hobbit" is not an epic, nor is a novel, but it has a good story. What was the result of the movie. The key is choice. "The Hobbit" chose Bilbo, Thorin, Thrandil, Gandalf, and the Battle of the Five Armies, but never carried out its choice to the end, and did not really put the effort to present it. These characters and stories it chooses. As the protagonist, the hobbit, Bilbo does not have many roles in the movie. Using Akon gems to borrow flowers to present Buddha is his main achievement in "The Battle of the Five Armies", but it has no practical value. In the war, Bill Bo was stunned directly, and the protagonist skipped the main part of the film; as one of the most important props of the film, the status of the Akon gem and its ultimate destination, the film did not mention at all; Thorin was portrayed as a doomsday hero, But he is really too far away from the word "hero". Compared to a good leader, he is more like a paranoia; Gandalf, as the most present character, has been in soy sauce from beginning to end, bringing about the revival of evil. The news of Bilbo is the same as Bilbo’s game of gems. It has no effect on the movie. During the battle, he is always the farthest away from it. Compared with the clarity and order of "Lord of the Rings", "The Hobbit" has no idea what to shoot. Of course, the bigger problem is this war. It should not call itself the "War of Five Armies", but it should be called the "War of Five" or the Battle of Four. Thranduil, Legolas, Thorin, Kellett and Tarrell, their five heads-up play is the main theme of the whole battle. The Guardian Battle of Saint Helm Valley, the grandeur of the Battle of White City, the Five Armies The battle was barely seen, although this battle was considered the most tragic in the Middle-earth era. Except for the half-orcs' sharp offensive at the beginning, the battle formations of the elves and dwarves can be glimpsed. The following battle is really unimaginable: the army of half-orcs is gone, only a little bit of chasing Civilians (literally); Thranduil’s army is gone, it seems that the jungle elves are left alone to be handsome; the humans in Long Lake Town are disappearing from beginning to end. After Bud killed a large man, it seems that we will no longer I have never seen him; Dwarf, before the fight, everyone was afraid of the dwarf cavalry for three points. After the fight, they couldn’t see where the cavalry was. When Thorin led his men out of the castle, the movie gave The reaction shots of other people seem to indicate that more than a dozen of them may turn the tide of the battle... In the heads-up, the film uses the most Hollywood mode: remove the ambient sound, only the sound of weapons colliding and the babble of the two sides of the battle. , You know this is the final round of the victory, Thorin and Azog are like this (Azog's underwater camera is too beautiful to look directly at it, and the dwarf king can be killed by his eyes alone); All kinds of killers give time for the two sides to say goodbye. Kili and Tarrell are like this; the last-minute rescue can be classic such as "The Two Towers", or very bad such as "The Battle of the Five Armies", you don't know why they are When they appear, movies do not intend to do more foreshadowing, you don’t know how they affect the situation, and movies do not intend to do more pen and ink. …The Battle of the Five Armies was originally a melee. Humans wanted to rebuild their homeland (half of the movie), the dwarves love money and take revenge (not explained), and the elves want to settle accounts with the dwarves (not to mention) , The movie only does subtraction, not addition, so that the whole process is mixed up and mixed, and only the Cai Fan Xinqiao is left (the role of Thrandil, I really don’t know whether the movie is fan or black). The movie has no intention of doing more pen and ink, and there is an ending. The end of the war, the end of the song, and a hurried farewell. When "Lord of the Rings" opened up and closed, and refused to leave for a long time, and refused to put down the characters, "The Hobbit" was at ease. Only Bilbo and the surviving dwarves were at the gate of El Boer. Reluctant to leave: Thranduil doesn't know where to go; when Thorin started to talk about friendship, when Thranduil started to talk about love, no one knew why Legolas didn't want to go back to the jungle; Bud still didn't show up; Suo Lin didn't even have a funeral... In "The Return of the King", in order to tell the whole story, in order to say goodbye, the film abruptly lasted three and a half hours, but this time "The Battle of the Five Armies" is three "The Hobbit". "The shortest one in ", it seems that it just wants to end soon. In the middle of the film, Legolas told Tarrell in the northern fortress that his mother died here. His dad Thranduil never said that there seems to be no memory at all (if the origin of the white gem is placed on him On the mother's head, Thranduil will become more famous). If Peter Jackson really loves "The Lord of the Rings" and knows that he can't do what he used to do, he should follow Thrandil and keep his love in his heart. Unfortunately, he doesn't seem to know. Or, he doesn't love anymore. After finishing writing, I went to read the end of "The King of Invincible". For a movie fan, it would be a pity in life that he has not seen the "Lord of the Rings" trilogy in a movie theater. "The Hobbit" is the kind of TV, computer, mobile phone, etc. that would be a waste of time. I don't think this is an exaggeration. Why give it back to Samsung? As a prequel, I still can't make it. Give it Samsung? As a prequel, I still can't make it.

View more about The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies reviews

Extended Reading
  • Rosalee 2022-04-24 07:01:02

    2020.5.7 Alas, after watching the Hobbit series, I personally feel that it is much better than the Lord of the Rings. It's a bit sad that there will be no Middle-earth from now on.. I really want to see Gandalf Bill Beaufrodo go on an adventure again, Bud shoots Smaug to death The dwarves in the Lonely Mountain look for the Arken diamond Bilbo finds it first but doesn't give it to Thorin I didn't see what Sauron looked like. The elves came to bring supplies to Riverdale and asked Thorin for gold together with the humans. Thorin sent Bilbo mithril to negotiate with Bard. Bilbo brought the Silmarillion to Bard. I got up, and then the Orc Legion came. Sorin joined the battle. Then Sorin was going to fight the Orc directly. I didn't expect that there would be a group of Goblin Legions. Finally, Sorin and Orc exchanged for Kili and Fili, the two brothers also died. Tauriel is sad that Legolas has left his father to find Aragorn in the North! Gandalf accompanied Bilbo back to the Shire and everything in his house was sold for his 111th birthday

  • Easter 2022-03-25 09:01:05

    This is the most frustrated and most tasteless one in the Middle-earth series. The bad results of the first two films made the structure of the last one very deformed. After reading it, people miss the Lord of the Rings trilogy. So bad and dare to score 4 stars.

The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies quotes

  • Tauriel: [to Thranduil] There is no love in your heart!

  • Thorin Oakenshield: [last words]

    Thorin Oakenshield: [to Bilbo] Farewell, Master Burglar. Go back to your books... and your armchair... plant your trees, watch them grow. If more people... valued home above gold... this world would be a merrier... place...

    Bilbo Baggins: No! No, no, no! No! Thorin! Thorin... don't you dare!

    [cradles Thorin, who has already died]

    Bilbo Baggins: Thorin... hold on. Hold on. Look. The Eagles. The Eagles. The Eagles are here. Thorin!

    [realizing Thorin's dead]

    Bilbo Baggins: The Ea -

    [breaks down and begins to weep]