————【Spoiler Spoiler Spoiler】————
——【Pure personal guessing, don’t like it, don’t spray】——
After the second brush, I noticed some foreshadowings and doubts that I didn't know for the first time, and then I wanted to write my brain out to discuss with you. The movie itself is an open ending, there is no certain and certain ending. So I don't have any meaning of "what I said must be reasonable/correct", I just talk about my observations and insights.
The following are purely personal observations and guesses. If you have an understanding of different endings, welcome to discuss, but don’t like it.
[Suspicious point 1: The heroine does not vomit because of lying. 】
In her memory, she told the old man that I had a glass of champagne today (x2 times) so I couldn’t play chess with you, when I went to the room after the party; however, in the police officer’s memoirs, Fran asked her if she wanted to drink. ? She said no, I'm working.
Personally, she guessed that she deliberately made everyone think that she would really vomit if she was flustered in the family game. So the truth everyone heard was just the truth she wanted everyone to believe.
[Suspicious point 2: The old man may have known what chess Marta was playing early in the morning, but the player sent did not win. 】
Why did they suddenly cut off everyone's funding after so many years, and now let them start from scratch after so many years? When the old man talked to Marta: Wealth is a curse, I did it for their good.
I personally guess that the old man is worried that after his death, his children will be killed because of wealth problems. If they are allocated to the children according to their ideals, and everyone knows that after the father passes away, the children will take in Marta. At that time, what Marta does to these people who can’t play chess, they may not find out until death, but the US team except. The old man said from the beginning: "He is so alike to me, he loves to play chess, and he is too confident and drama." (But neither can win Marta's chess.)
When the US team and Marta were in the restaurant, the US team suddenly said: "Grandpa said that I play chess very well, but you win more. I don’t know why he told me this sentence, or what it means. But there must be something special in it. "(Maybe it's the American team's battle book with Marta here)
I personally think that the US team specially led her to the burnt site and wanted her to trade according to the points. It turned out that the detective was there. Marta could have driven away as soon as the detective was so far away, because the detective hadn't seen who was in the car at all. She deliberately waited until the detective approached and saw the US team and her clearly, the US team was talking, and then drove away. The US team was arrested, and he recruited all of them. The two of them have been crazy since you came to the restaurant, and I used to play chess. In the end, the US team lost. She lost because of her "liing and spitting" trick.
[ Doubt Point 3: Knife]
When the old man saw the real knife next to his seat, he played with him and said, "Do you think the prop knife is actually a real knife" (probably that means) and then forcefully inserted it on the table. (Give a knife close-up)
In the end, the US team did not hesitate to drew one of the knives on the seat of tens of thousands of knives, and stabbed her. It was accidentally discovered that it was a prop knife.
Personally, I guess that the US team knows his home well. As for the many knives in the seat, which one can be pulled out/which is the real one, he knows, so he drew the knife and stabbed her so confidently. The old man said to the knife as if he had discovered the prop knife originally placed here, but it was changed into a real knife. The old man's words can also be guessed whether it means: I thought Marta was a prop knife, but she turned out to be a real knife.
[ Doubt 4: Marta’s cell phone, Fran’s death]
Marta's phone has close-ups many times, and the cracks on the phone screen proved to be the phone that has been used for a long time. First of all, she has always carried her mobile phone with her. Why did she never use the mobile phone at the night when the old man died? Obviously you can call an ambulance with your mobile phone? But she used a landline phone instead.
When Fran’s hospital finally called, I noticed a close-up of the phone’s screen: "xxxx hospital, phone". I think of the previous cell phone close-up, when the detective called her because she didn't know the detective's mobile phone number, it said: "It should be: Detective Blanco, phone" (Maybe: xxxx), here is maybe. If there is a phone number in the address book, there will be no maybe, and why the phone call from the hospital is a "mobile phone"?
And counting the time she met with the US team, they discussed at home, went to the scene of the fire, and chased cars. If the US team had injected her with morphine, she would have died. When she was deciding whether to save Fran, she saw the morphine bottle on the ground. Doesn't it mean that you will die within a few minutes if the bottle goes down? When she knew that Fran was bound to die, she decided to take an ambulance and pretend to surrender herself, using Fran's chess to force the US team to confess guilt.
I personally think that Fran will definitely not live that long, if the US team injected her with morphine. Maybe Fran said that You did this.
So the call from the hospital may have been set up in advance by her.
[Doubt 5: Blood stains on Marta shoes]
From Marta's account/memories, when she opened the door for the second time, the old man committed suicide in order to stop her. And she was standing at the door, far away, and separated by a chess table. After the old man cut his neck and committed suicide, she cried at the door for a long time and couldn't get up, and then left the house as the old man said. When she came back again, she never entered the old man's room. How did her bloodstain come from? Will blood splash to the door?
(But everyone says it will splash... just ignore this, hahaha)
——————————————————————————
In the end, when the US team was captured, the eye contact between him and Marta was like a sword.
The look in the US team's eyes: "This woman is really amazing, I lost."
In Marta's eyes: "Now, do you know the meaning of "I always win more than you in chess", right"
Then Marta finally took the old man's water glass and old man's shawl on the balcony, drank the water peacefully (again provocative?) and looked down at the group of losers below.
Overall, still think that Marta is not a simple and kind person? On the contrary, the feeling after reading it for the first time is not so strong. (It may be that I have too much brainpower to think too much.) But why did she confess everything to the unfamiliar American team so casually? His personality shouldn't be such a trustworthy person? I am also a little confused here...
View more about Knives Out reviews
