When I saw Captain Hoffman, I sounded in "My Commander, My Regiment", and there was a very unpleasant character Ah Yi at the beginning. He is a Shanghai native, a major who has never fought in war, and he has several beautiful medals, which he got through training and reading in the military academy. It is such a character, who is still the first commander of the Sichuan Army and the Cannon Fodder Group (before Long Wenwen arrived) in the image of a useless soldier among a large number of soldiers. I believe that most of the group fans Are all familiar. When it comes to military discipline, you can imagine that the bottom of China's army is defeated, and even hungry and precarious, they all know the absolute authority of the officers. In the gathering place, Ayi has the highest personal image and appearance besides Mi Long. Although it is not the image of a fat head and big ears, it is also the image of a white-faced scholar. Agreed to compare the lieutenant and deputy company commander Meng Fan, who is purely a soldier, a soldier who can get along a little, and the other soldiers at the bottom are simply a description of the image of a beggar. So why does the useless Ah Yi maintain his image of a white-faced scholar even in the midst of a collapsed army, and he can't starve him at ordinary times. He has no personal charm at all, but Mi Long or Meng Fan always surrounds him when he is the center? This is incomprehensible to civilians who have never been in the military. This is the absolute authority of the officer.
Only those who have really served in the army will know what it means to oppress people at the first level of the official university, not the superiors and subordinates of ordinary institutions. From this point of view, no matter how bad the captain is, even knowing that he will take everyone to death, the people of this ship have no choice. The only exception that can be done to the officer is actually when the captain decides to act treasonously in the second season, and he can be attacked or even killed if necessary. From the fact that Hoffman was exiled at the end, the military court knew that there was something tricky, and he actually let go of the mutineers. It can be seen that no one in the crew really knew the army at all.
Our party's army has an iron law, which can also be said to be common to all armies in the world. It is higher than all military laws, all unreasonable and powers that we understand. That is to obey the superior and obey the command. (We call all actions follow orders) This is actually a meaning. Whether the army's combat effectiveness is strong or not, whether its weapons are updated or not, and the times change, this will never change.
In reality and work, we civilians can completely refuse to face some unrealistic orders. For example, there is a poisonous gas in front of me, and they want me to close the valve. I think it may involve my personal safety and refuse. This can be done, but the military absolutely cannot. As long as the other party is your immediate superior, you must execute it, otherwise you will be disobeying the military order, engaging in military law, and shooting at the highest level.
Agreed, although it was 1942, the German submarine operation was a great success, and the soldiers complained about not being able to participate in the encirclement and suppression of merchant ships. Could it be that this was a mutiny? Some netizens analyzed that the soldier missed the honor, the possibility of promotion, etc., so he held a grudge and intended to retaliate against Hoffman, and finally exiled him.
What are you kidding? According to this understanding, then soldiers from all over the world, those soldiers who go to remote areas, can easily rebel against the frontier every year, and they can completely ask to be replaced by soldiers near the metropolis, with good benefits, high salaries, and excellent living conditions. This is not going to work at all.
We are in the workplace, if the work is not going well, resign, immediately come here, change a place, the military is not a place you want. In a sense, in the military, in fact, many basic rights and interests have been wiped out. In addition to obedience, obedience, even if you do not obey, you have to obey.
Even if you succeed in killing the captain, you will definitely die in the military trial you will face later, and even your family will be implicated. Novels often describe such a group of people, even if the general's personal guard among the ancient generals, if the general himself dies, for whatever reason, all personal guards have only one end, and they are dead. The only thing that can be done is to grab the corpse, send it back, and finally commit suicide to save the family. It seems very unreasonable and very inhuman, but in fact it definitely exists in reality.
Even if it was written in the logbook that Hoffman was hit in the body by an enemy plane, the first mate (the one who died of chlorine poisoning) must take command as soon as possible. Second, the first officer died, and the first duty officer or wheel chief was in command of the result. The captain, chief mate, duty officer, and wheel chief are the four major officers of the submarine. In some settings, there will be a fifth, that is, the navigator, whose function will sometimes be the same as that of the chief mate. In other words, it was impossible for the captive hostage captain to command. From the moment he was captured, the captain's own position and rank were directly reset to zero. Unless ordered by the command, the status of recruits and sailors was higher than him. In principle, he was no different from that American Jew.
The funniest thing is that with such a big loophole and such an obviously problematic logbook, the military court also intervened in the investigation, but there was only one result, and everyone was released out of propaganda. Even if Goering intervenes to keep the captured captain (after all, he is promoted as a fighting hero), then the other crew members have only one way to die, and they will be shot directly. Just kidding? The Propaganda Department will also care about the little minions, and it is enough to have only one propaganda hero. As a result, the screenwriter was directly disgusted, the whistleblower was put on trial instead, and the other sailors were safe.
This shows that there is really no military logic. Part-time jobs are the same as many brain-dead dramas in China.
In fact, I want to praise a lot of anti-Japanese dramas. Although many plots are unreasonable and the plot is shocking, but after a closer look, there will be plots that will make our audience respond. That is, the protagonist wants to rejoice in his revenge and revenge on the little devil, but an order from a superior has no choice but to be sullen. Then the superiors carefully enlighten.
In reality, there is only sulking, no enlightenment. Military personnel only have orders and obedience, and other combat literacy and so on are completely secondary. This is why, during the First World War, in the face of German machine gun fire, the soldiers of the British and French allied forces could only be like targets, holding their heads high and advancing to death. And this happened more than once.
Who knows, this is bound to die, times have changed, but the soldiers at the bottom have no choice, until the superiors feel that this tactic is really unfeasible, and then order to change to trench warfare, long-term siege, and innovative tactics. Do low-level soldiers and officers have options? No choice. You must also go to death. Some netizens commented that they pretended to be dead and fell to the ground. If they were discovered by the supervising team, they would probably be shot dead. Not even crawling forward. The platoon tactic is to maintain the formation, keep your head high and move forward steadily, even without firing a shot in the middle.
It was obvious that several divisions in the front were ruthlessly killed by German machine guns, but when it came to the latter divisions, there was no choice. The platoon tactics could not be abandoned until the afternoon of the same day, when the order from the top came (sadly, but the officers below did nothing wrong, and everyone was right, this is the reality). If someone disobeys, it is wrong.
Therefore, from the moment Hoffman was exiled, in fact, the rest of the people were bound to die. The funniest thing is that in the third season, another rich second-generation young captain has been set up, which is still an old routine. The only thing that is fortunate is that in the third episode, the new captain is not at fault, it is the fault below. In fact, the first officer in the plot thinks it is unreasonable, and this statement is unreasonable.
The sonar soldier heard a friendly warship passing overhead, but he didn't report it, not his fault, but also the captain's fault. Also, after getting out of the mine siege, the captain ordered an emergency ascent, which is totally fine. The propellers have been damaged by the agitation of the chain, do not float, are you still waiting to fish on the bottom of the sea? The most funny thing is that the captain's mother actually asked the first officer's wife to help him speak kind words. Although I don't know about submarine operations, I don't think there is a problem with the command of the captain himself.
The submarine itself can perform emergency descending and emergency diving instructions. This one has been withdrawn in the training of the first season here. The most obvious is the emergency dive, all the redundant crew members go to the bow, and the emergency floats up, and all the crew members go to the stern.
If it is a regular dive, it is actually to open the gate, release the water, and use the buoyancy to go up and down. This is the safest and most peaceful way. Float up, empty the tank, and float slowly. In the third season, the captain's order is to empty the water tank and use buoyancy to float, and it is not an emergency float (I don't know if it is a problem with translation subtitles). What can be wrong?
The sonar soldiers didn't report that there was a boat on it at the first time, causing the submarine to float up and overturn a small German ship. This normal person is the fault of the sonar operator. In the plot, it can also be said that it is the fault of the new captain, and he is not suitable to be the captain. I really don't understand where this logic is. Co-authoring the captain in the submarine can still know the information of the outside world. Even no one who has been a sailor knows that the only perception of the submarine underwater is the sonar operator.
Also, in the third season there is a harmony incident where the first officer destroys the ship. This time it was actually a scratch periscope. I don't understand this logic, this first mate also thinks he is very good and should be the captain, and then the captain here is the second-generation airdrop captain. Co-authoring such an unreasonable act to seize power again?
Should any deputy commander in the army seize power every minute, kill the main leader, and then hold the power, Lao Tzu finally stands out.
Personally, I really don't understand. This kind of power grab, like the spy scene forcibly inserted here, takes into account lesbian, feminist, black, and other messy settings. However, this is also a feature of American TV series, and their policies must require taking into account the needs of people from all walks of life. So there are messy plots added to many plots, so don't be surprised. Maybe even Snow White will be a black girl someday. The show is called the German Bureau, but it is actually a joint filming of the United States and Germany. In short, aside from those messy settings, just look at the shooting techniques of the submarine itself, and some are still very good. It's something that was not in the old movie "Sorry From the Sea".
For example, regular submarine training at sea. Submarine supply ship disguised as a merchant ship. Submarine commander in Lorient, France. The setting of the hedgehog anti-submarine bomb is set by the duty officer. All are very good. There is a subtitle error in the first season here, the first vigilante. Many people thought it was a translation error, or that there was no such job at all. In fact, it is the four or five officers of the submarine I mentioned earlier. Captain, first officer, duty officer, wheel captain, navigator. Among them, the duty officer is actually the temporary supreme commander when the captain is resting. The first mate and the captain are generally set as the first security officer, while the duty officer, the wheel captain, and the navigator are the second security officer. In fact, to put it bluntly, the submarine arms are set to exist in two shifts. There are two systems of command.
In terms of position, the captain is the largest, followed by the first mate, then the duty officer or navigator, and finally the wheel captain. The first two are the first set of command system officers, and the latter two are the second set of command officers. The length of the wheel is not understood by everyone, only the diesel engine and the generator set. Even in the VX sequence of large German ocean-going submarines, there is one more role as a material quartermaster. He was also an officer on a submarine. Has command power.
The second submarine is the non-commissioned officer. Generally, it is a functional position, such as the torpedo commander at the bow, the stern, and the electromechanical commander. This is the one who is directly responsible for maintaining the power system. In some places, it is set as a mechanical maintenance engineer. Sonar operators, radio operators, prevention and control guards, and in some places, the detectors are combined into one, which is the best use of the submarine's eyes. When necessary, they wear black blindfolds and use binoculars to search for targets at night and during the day. This role is also the only non-commissioned officer with a telescope out of the five officers. Medics, etc.
The rest are ordinary sailors. Have done all aspects of training, as well as deck weapon operation, loading torpedoes. Routine maintenance and other groceries.
View more about Das Boot reviews
