just thinking

Eloy 2022-10-22 18:28:07

A rejoicing major, a weary second lieutenant, and a philistine 1st class captured an unimportant bridge with dozens of casualties. A major who sticks to his post, at all costs, hopes to complete the task, but forgets the basic duties of a soldier, and does not realize "who is the enemy" until he is executed by his own people.
In addition, I think General Brian of Germany has an obvious tendency to let American troops cross the bridge. From his understanding of the bridge, not only did he not send troops to guard, but he transferred some of the defensive troops, and the ones he sent were not good enough. It's hard to say that it's just to save the 70,000 troops that are almost impossible to save.
If it is what I think, to Germany, is he a traitor or a hero?
The entire film is in a seemingly contradictory tone, both accusing the Nazis and mocking the victorious US military officers, cold-blooded, greedy, incompetent, and reckless. For them, human life is just a number. On the contrary, the description of the soldier is much more positive. When the greedy, gambling, and lecherous First Class killed a resisting child, the kindness of human nature revealed, the bravery and wit he showed in the face of danger, can be regarded as an American concept. The image of a good man in the protagonist, and the second lieutenant as the protagonist, judging from his age and rank, is likely to be a temporary officer promoted from sergeant.
Small people in power, Hollywood orthodoxy. American tradition.
Speaking of this, I actually thought of a line said by the German Field Marshal Katherine in another war film "Anchio": You and I have to beg hard to get (weapons and fuel), on their side, Sergeant A phone call will do.

View more about The Bridge at Remagen reviews

Extended Reading

The Bridge at Remagen quotes

  • Major Paul Kreuger: I understand the Russians are at the Elbe.

    Gen. von Brock: Yes.

    Major Paul Kreuger: And here?

    Gen. von Brock: Worse. Utter confusion. Every day I get orders to attack with divisions that no longer exist. Hitler still thinks he's winning the war.

    Major Paul Kreuger: The Army helped bring Hitler into power. Are you saying we made a mistake?

  • Major Barnes: Look, uh, Hartman, I know it's been a hard blow. It's always a shock to lose a buddy, a man you worked with and fought with. I mean, we're all human. I guess what I'm trying to say is... I realize Captain Colt was your friend. He was my friend, too.

    Lt. Phil Hartman: Bullshit.

    [Long pause]

    Major Barnes: Would you, uh... care to rephrase that, Lieutenant?

    Lt. Phil Hartman: You don't have any friends out here, Major. Neither do I. We can't afford them. Neither one of us.