I like this version very much! So post the mixed comment here!
----------------
Actually, the first half of the original Persuade is very exciting. Compared with other JA love comedies, persuasion is richer and less distinctly stupid or clever-old love that cannot be forgotten, realistic persecution, mental growth, chaotic surrounding environment, and it is difficult to distinguish between good and evil. And at the center of everything is the contest between Wentworth and Anne spanning the youth and youth.
Good love is a close contest. When is the right time to hold out a heart, and when is the master of your heart willing to trade with your own heart. Zhang Ailing is good at writing this kind of contest, but the method is very imaginary, like a lancet lightly cut into the bone, no blood is seen. Jane Austen (hereinafter referred to as JA) is more realistic. Specific to every look, every word.
In this contest, it was Wentworth, the richest diamond king, who had an overwhelming advantage over the old girl Anne who rejected his proposal eight years ago. But Anne is a kind girl who is silent but leads Wentworth's every move.
Because she really knew him too well.
Anne's insight into Wentworth is even deeper than her own. In Uppercross, Charles' brother used to serve on Wentworth's ship, so the couple enthusiastically asked about that period of history and expressed regret that their son had left Wentworth's ship. And Anne, she saw the subtle change in Wentworth's eyes and the fleeting mockery at the corners of her mouth and immediately came to the conclusion-perhaps it was Wentworth who wanted to send him away. Even when Wentworth vented his anger or showed off to the two young girls and showed his love to the two young girls, Anne knew that he probably didn't like any of them.
When Anne in the original book faces the cool and arrogant ex-boyfriend Wentworth, she always keeps the essence of Tucao Niang in a calm manner. At the end of the original book, Anne can't afford to look at Wentworth's father and sister. The invitation to the dinner party unexpectedly sent a copy to Wentworth, and Tucao Niang immediately perceived it. Wentworth accepted the invitation very politely, but his eyes were full of disdain.
It's a pity that Anne's keen insight and well-developed small theater in the brain are really difficult to express in the movie, so we can only comfort me by saying that "the heroine in a love novel always has an overbearing president who falls in love with me inexplicably".
(07 version) The
07 version of Sally Hawkins is actually very beautiful, but ITV obviously wants to show Anne's status as a wall flower at home-dressed like a maid, few sets of beautiful clothes and jewelry, the beginning of the chapter is busy talking and not moving. She was full of tears, unlike a girl who kicked her first love, but like a divorced woman—especially thinking that Wentworth was going to be engaged to someone else. After crying a lot of tears, nose, saliva, and blowing candles, I saw me After hundreds of years of scalp numbness, I feel embarrassed for Anne.
So in this version of persuasion, Anne’s pain and grievance far exceed her ability and intelligence and her ability to perceive Wentworth’s ideas. No wonder some friends who have only watched the movie will say that the final outcome is that Anne is out of luck. .
On the contrary, the 71 version of Anne is so beautiful, it is comparable to Vivien Leigh! No matter how gentle and intelligent she is, her radiant face makes any of her inner shows seem worthless, and this is obviously not JA's intention. After all, it's not just young handsome men and beauties who have the right to talk about an unforgettable love.
(Amanda Root, version 95)
In the 95 version of Anne, Amanda Root is also a beauty, but the director's intention is not to wear cosmetic contact lenses and play soft light to create beauty. On the contrary, this edition is a bit embarrassing to be realistic. The director almost gave up his intention to please the young people of our age, and only wanted to reproduce Wentworth and Anne who belonged to JA. Anne is very old with makeup, and the wrinkles on her eyebrows can't be covered. But JA didn't say how beautiful Anne is. If she is beautiful, the dad of her appearance association will not only love the eldest daughter and ignore the second daughter. But the calmness and tenderness showed from her patiently listening to everyone's complaints in the uppercross. I really like the scenes where Anne walks in the brown velvet cloak. When she sits in the hedge, she listens helplessly as Louisa misinterprets her past to Wentworth, and she has to endure Mary’s nagging, but she sits in the cloak and sits quietly. There, there is a kind of low-key nobility, a kind of firmness and helplessness to go through a thousand sails.
(Version 95)
Let's talk about Wentworth. Because of Rupert Penry Jones (hereinafter referred to as RPJ), who is so handsome and blind, I have watched the 07 version of "Persuasion" ten times. But when I read the 95 edition, I have to admit that compared to Wentworth, the rich second generation in "Whitechapel" or the 007 in "13 Steps" are more suitable for his face-RPJ's face is too flawless , It's really not like a soldier who has been bumping at sea for eight years.
JA has already said in the novel that these navies are often older than their actual age, and they seem to be more than 60 at the age of forty. In the year when I reunited with Anne, Wentworth31, even if JA said that he was handsome, objectively speaking, it was probably a blessing of 20,000 pounds. Ciaran Hinds is far from handsome, but he is tall, with sharp features, and looks like a handsome man who has experienced weather conditions. With a more realistic navy uniform, it is quite reductive.
(RPJ, 07 Edition)
However, RPJ has a kind of cleverness and determination, which is very similar to the description of Wentworth in the original book of JA.
The most criticized version of the 07 version is probably the ending. From the beginning of writing a letter, it is nothing short of the party-state IP. In the original book, Wentworh is a background board for writing letters in a room to make a noise about the marriage of Zhang Luo Anni's brother-in-law's sister. But when Anne whispered to Wentworth comrade A about the new marriage and old relationship of the deceased comrade B, Wentworth's pen dropped (╮(╯▽╰)╭) Ah, yes, the arrogant man who devoted himself to writing letters Young Wentworth was actually eavesdropping. Then, there was Anne's most frank and obscure confession in the whole book, comrade A said that men are the ones who are hurt in the relationship, and women are more happy and tired of the old. Anne replied, I think the strength of our women (this is not an enviable strength, you don’t have to covet it) lies in the fact that they can love their lovers forever, even if they are not alive or if they lose hope. Go down.
Then Wentworth began to write letters quickly, looking like he was about to run away quickly. But! After he went out, he ran back in such a thunderous manner that he put the letter he had been writing in front of Anne, and then... ran away again.
It was the proposal letter that was half pain and hope.
The 07 version is the most changed version. There was no such scene at all. Some only Wentworth rushed to Anne's house and asked her whether she was engaged to someone else. If so, the house he rented from her house would be cancelled. When Anne answered no, she took a close-up shot of RPJ's blue eyes and idiotic expression that made people turn into idiots. Then began the Bath Marathon where Anne chased Wentworth and ran Bath for a week.
Everyone thinks that you have to kiss after you confess, so good. But please tell me the 07 version of Anne squeezed Wentworth's letter and ran around Bath City out of breath and tiptoe to reach Wentworth's lips, Wentworth actually lowered his head slowly and with a little mockery. Waiting for her to come up? This is really not like the long letter just now confessing that he had offered Anne a heart that was “half pain and half hope that has been broken by her once”?
The 95 version shot the letter, and also shot Anne pinching the letter to find Wentworth, but did not take the Bath Marathon. Anne was blocked by the marching crowd on the road. When the crowd dispersed, the man was in the dimly lit place. Plain and subtle than the 07 version.
(Version 71) Version
71 is basically a 3D stereo audiobook. If you don’t look at the screen, it’s like reading the persuasion original by roles. It is loyal to the original, and it is really boring, especially when Anne and Lady Russel are discussing Wentworth. However, it should also be the most ladylike gentleman in these three versions. When Wentworth apologized to Anne, sorry for taking your seat. An answered quietly and gently, no. Then he raised his hand and asked him to continue. This is the feminine temperament that is missing in the other two versions.
So when I watched the 71 and 95 versions, I completely understood why I couldn’t watch the 05 version of "Pride and Prejudice"-if you want to find a little bit of British classical country obstruction, boring, trivial and JA in the movie. It’s very careful, 05 big girl version of P&P is definitely not everything is too clear, sharp edges.
In the persuasion, Aunt JA provided three models for the romance novels of future generations: older unmarried young women, arrogant and cool young men, and male-to-female hearts and female-to-male bodies. However, in terms of the richness of the character's heart, few can surpass the originator JA Auntie.
In the 20th century, Beauvoir summarized the inner monologue of JA Fu and Anne:
I long to see you, but please remember that I will not ask to see you. This is not because of pride, you know that I have no pride in front of you, but because it only makes sense for us to meet when you want to see me.
-------END---------
This is... it was written at the beginning of 15 years, why has it been hidden...because I am too lazy to find pictures>_<
View more about Persuasion reviews
