"The Butterfly" movie review

Marvin 2022-09-11 10:20:48

Butterfly-kun told Renni that the story of a Japanese woman committing suicide for the U.S. Navy in the opera is only moving because it conforms to Western fantasies. If it were a Western woman who committed suicide for the remarriage of her beloved short Japanese businessman, she would probably regarded as a fool. Rennie ended up being similar to this western woman and was ridiculed by the whole country, but he didn't think so, he was deeply in love with Butterfly Jun, a woman with oriental charm, even though he already knew that she was pretending, and the time he spent with Butterfly Jun It was real to him, he used suicide to express his deep feelings, and deduced the scene that Western men can also commit suicide for Eastern women. The role of Butterfly Jun is sandwiched between loyalty and emotion. On the one hand, he wants to do things for the organization and obtain information. On the other hand, he longs for free love. He loves Renni, so I hope Renni will face the reality that he is a man. However, he reluctantly found out that Renni didn't love him, but him dressed as a woman, so he gave up. The once fantasy, the submissive oriental women and the cruel white people, seems to be reversed now, and such an ending is not only ridiculed by people in the show, but also not accepted by outsiders. Farewell My Concubine is more popular by comparison, and the two films released in the same year seem to be the exact opposite in this regard. The role of Butterfly Jun is also acting in Peking Opera, and the housekeeper speaks Cantonese, a bit like Zunlong's experience, this role is really suitable for him.

View more about M. Butterfly reviews

Extended Reading
  • Domenick 2022-03-17 09:01:08

    In such an obvious intercultural communication text, it is simple to read Orientalism and Oriental-woman-feminine structure, but as Rey Chow said, this is not the core of the film. This kind of thinking refers to "illusion" as a deliberate deception or "false consciousness", that is, Western men are Eastern women who desire disguise because of illusions. When illusions are referred to as structural problems of human cognition, the analysis of "ideology, misogyny, and racism that devalue illusions" must be re-analyzed. We need to see how Eastern women conceal their clothing, seducing and lusting Western men, and exercising their power as Phallus. Renni becoming a butterfly (madam) is not only a sign of the inversion of power, but also an attempt to reject the gaze. In the process of drawing himself into a butterfly, his illusion-like independence gained through the original narcissism in the mirror phase ends. Will disappear. This also implies that the femininity and "Oriental woman" are the truth about himself as a Western man. As a Western man, he just dreams of becoming the Western penis of an Eastern woman. A fundamentally different approach to the East has emerged in the West.

  • Arnold 2022-04-22 07:01:49

    The first time I watched Zunlong play was [The Last Emperor], and then I watched [Mr. Butterfly]. Since then, I have been indescribably respected for Zunlong's acting skills.

M. Butterfly quotes

  • Rene Gallimard: Our world is changing. We French lost our war in Indochina because we failed to learn about the people we sought to lead. It's natural, therefore - correct, even - that they should resent us. How could they do otherwise, when we refused to treat them like fellow human beings?

  • Rene Gallimard: The Oriental woman: when she's good, she's very very very good. But when she's bad, she's Christian!