Humane? ——The Children of Huang Shi

Keyshawn 2022-12-24 04:23:32

After looking back, I found that there are still big names. Brother Fa and Sister Qiong have appeared in it, and I feel that the performance is still in place.

But the overall feeling is that there are too many bugs, too many. How should I put it? The screenwriter does not understand history, let alone some fundamentals of history. For example, the New Fourth Army soldier played by Fa Ge does not really look like a New Fourth Army soldiers, or a small leader. Are there activities of the New Fourth Army in Nanjing City? At that time, the New Fourth Army had just been established, so they wore armbands. It was TG's consistent policy not to kill prisoners. I don't believe that he would condone others to kill Japanese scouts. And Sister Qiong seems to be a very human widowed middle-aged wife? It was almost impossible for a force without the military to be able to sell medical supplies and narcotics in China at that time, and would it be so easy to submit? The overall feeling is that several adults are not in the national disaster, but are playing a family in their own courtyard. Although there are some bloody scenes, it is difficult for me to give me the oppression of war and the crisis of the nation. Instead, it begins to have a petty bourgeoisie sentiment, amazing. 's director.

These bugs don’t need to be mentioned. What’s even more incredible is that the conditions of this elementary school or orphanage are actually quite good. At least in terms of materials, there are several trucks that traveled in the end, and the food along the way is also very sufficient. Huangshi actually encountered Japanese scouts on the way to Lanzhou. Did they fly over?

Finally, do all movies have to be a little bit of color? I don't understand where the problem lies. When a certain woman appeared on the stage, I felt that there must be some kind of erotic factor later. It was lust, not emotion. In the war years, there can be no such factors. I just think that such factors are not universal and generally valued. Of course, this is what the director values, and it is also a taste that many critics and appreciators value.

I miss movies like "Blood Battle in Taierzhuang", at least this is a real war movie

View more about The Children of Huang Shi reviews

Extended Reading
  • Gerda 2022-03-20 09:02:43

    The story is very touching, but the director is a little bit clueless. And I have every reason to believe that what I saw was cut.

  • Gerardo 2022-03-19 09:01:08

    Who said Jonathan_Rhys_Meyers does not accept bad movies...

The Children of Huang Shi quotes

  • Shi-Kai: [to the orphans] Please welcome Mr. Pig.

    George Hogg: Hogg.

    Shi-Kai: [smugly] It says "Pig".

  • George Hogg: It's chaos over here!