But after all, I just entered the house not long ago, and I didn't have the consciousness to play the original game at all. (Am I going to tell you that because I think it takes too much time to advance the plot of the fate of the sky game, so I just pushed the Nao line and Qiongmei line before kneeling, and then I obediently came to the anime and watched it)
So I looked for I came to watch the anime of Air and Kanon, because the dango shocked me too much, so I also had a feeling of yearning for the other two tearjerkers.
After watching all three animes, I did a side-by-side comparison. Overall, I think of these three animes, CLANNAD is the first, AIR is the second, and Kanon is the third.
These three animes are all healing, and the classic elements of healing are friendship, love, family, growing up, losing a loved one, and getting a bento (big fog) all the same. But with the same ingredients, the chef can make the most delicious food in the world, but I can only make murderous dishes (fog). Therefore, although the characters of these three animes have a very high similarity in plots, there are still some gaps. (The metaphor about murderous cooking may not be very appropriate, after all, these three animes are all quasi-scripted by Ma Zhi, and Ishihara Li also supervises.)
In terms of length, CLANNAD is the longest, with nearly 50 episodes in two seasons, so the details are portrayed. is also the most detailed. Of course, there are also the most girls who can be raided (cough, this sentence does not count). Kanon is second, with more than 20 episodes, and he also tells the story very well. Air is the shortest, plus OVA 14 episodes, so in terms of the fineness of the plot, Air is a little lacking, at least about the curse of Guanling, I I didn't understand it too much. After reading Air, I found a lot of information on the Internet to fully understand it.
A little rant here, the characters of these three animes are too similar, such as Tono Mi Nagi and Ichinose Kotomi, such as Kitagawa Jun and Chunyuan Yanghei, such as Ifuko and Tsukimiya Ayu, as for the male protagonists We won't say anything, anyway, the men in the harem are like that, everyone knows it.
As for the plot, I thought the similarity was too high. For example, Fuzi and Ayu were both "beings" (or the hypocritical name "Missing Body"), and the plots of Mai Chengchuan and Kotomi Ichinose were all silent. All the girls with attributes had a bad relationship with the male pig's feet when they were young.
For another example, there are also great similarities between Tomoya's father and daughter and Haruko's mother and daughter. Tomoya became depressed because of Nagisa's death, and he fostered Shio in Sanae's house for five years. Just when Tomoya regained hope in life and began to take on the responsibility of a father, Shio fell ill and eventually it snowed there. The sky fell into the arms of friends.
And Haruko has been reluctant to get too close to Kanrin for many years because she is afraid of the inevitable parting from Kanrin. But she knew that she had always loved that child deeply. Just when she finally decided to face up to her maternal love for Guanling and won the custody of Guanling, Guanling was cursed, and her time was running out.
The deaths of Guanling and Xi have left us with deep grief and regret, and it is precisely because of this that Key's trilogy is called "God's Work" and "tear gas".
There are many reasons why CLANNAD is ranked first (Am I going to tell you that because CLANNAD is the first anime after I moved into the house, it left an indelible impression on me?! Cover your face...) The first is full of details. The length of nearly 50 chapters depicts each heroine very vividly, Fujibayashi Muku's weakness, Xing's love for his sister, Furukawa Nagisa's strength behind weakness, Tomoyo, Fuko, Mei. , with Ji Ning. . . . . .
Air seems to be lacking in this aspect. In addition to Haruko and Kanrin's relatively distinct personalities, Kirishima Kano, Xiaoman and others have a slightly thin image, although we can see at a glance that "Kirishima is a virgin girl. , her sister is a strong-willed royal sister" and other character attributes, but to be honest, these are actually the combination of cute attributes that have been stereotyped, and there is nothing new. Of course, this is also limited by the space. In the space of twelve chapters, the stories of the three heroines are pushed, and the narrative from a thousand years ago is added. Air's narrative always has a very "rush" feeling. We can't ask for anything more about characters.
On the other hand, Air's two rumors are surprisingly well done. Paper fans, hand knives, squatting in corners, pinching faces, selling cute meat, and eroge jokes. These funny elements are not cumbersome at all. Hei Changzhi, natural dumb, arrogant, eldest lady, special first-person pronoun, outsider, these cute attributes are also perfectly integrated in Shennai Beiming, so it is reasonable to say that Shennai can enter the quarterfinals of the 2005 cute battle of.
When I wrote this, I suddenly remembered one thing, about the chaos of Minase Nayuki, Sawatari Makoto, and Tsukigiya Ayu in Air. This episode is really messed up. . . Sincerely! ! Even the voice actors are the same! ! (See the second episode of Air at 13 minutes and 42 seconds, and the seiyuu table for details at 22 minutes and 16 seconds.)
As for Kanon's character, I think it is better than Air, at least there is no special pattern of cute attributes, and most people There is one. . . Attractive and strong quality, which the heroine in Air (excluding Guanling) does not have.
There is another reason why CLannad is ranked first by me, that is, the plot is clear and the plot develops very solidly.
In Air's plot, the protagonist of the first episode is Kunizaki Kaoru. In the second episode, he inexplicably turns into Haruko, while Kaori becomes a crow for no apparent reason. Although the interaction between Haruko and Guanling is the biggest tear in this anime, the change of perspective in the middle is still a bit confusing. Coupled with the limitation of space, Air's plot is always lacking in fire. Many things are not explained clearly.
As for the direction of Kanon's plot, I was a little speechless, and even more seriously, I thought that Kanon's plot was flawed. Originally, as the one with the least supernatural elements in the tearjerker trilogy, and it is not a detective suspense, Kanon's plot direction should be the clearest, but it is the most confusing in the trilogy. At first, it was Sawatari Makoto, then Seikawa Mai and Sayuri's Shuangfei (big fog), then Misaka Shiori, then Tsukimiya Ayu, and finally one who was playing soy sauce from beginning to end. Obviously it can be pushed but not. After repeated deliberation, I finally determined its cute attribute to be Akalin's cousin Minase Nayuki. If you look at the number of harems alone, it seems that it is indeed not as good as Clannad, but this is the most important thing in life. However, Yuichi married Makoto first, Makoto disappeared (probably just a lunch box) and then had some friendship with Mai that was obviously beyond friendship. The interaction of the category, Mai and Zoyuri began to associate with the terminally ill Misaka Shiori after being hospitalized, and after Misaka and his Sayanara, they pulled out the evil relationship between Kazuya and Ayu throughout the whole chapter, and finally reached Iya. The happy ending with the full opening of the main line harem. Counting down Yuichi's daily routine, he went to school with his cousin in the morning (who doesn't look forward to having a capable sister in various senses, you don't cherish it!!), and in the morning, he went to school with Shiori Misaka, During the lunch break, I will eat (play) lunch (3) meals (p) with Mai Chengchuan and Sayuri. After school in the afternoon, I will meet Ayu Tsukimiya who robbed Taiyaki on the road. After feeding my sister, I will discuss ginseng, and then go golden. In the sunset, I bid farewell, and after going to bed at night, I would meet Makoto's night attack, and after midnight, I would go to school with steak rice to feed Chengchuan Mai. (Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhly The existence of the scumbag, let us call him the "God of the Harem". This story tells us that games that take the healing line are adapted from anime, don't try to push the true ending composed of multiple good endings in one season of anime, maybe the audience is sitting in front of the TV gnashing their teeth and cursing the male protagonist to achieve multiple bad endings as soon as possible good boat ending. You must know that although CLANNAD has reached a true ending, it is still there for two seasons! ! How clearly they explain it.
I'm not writing the above because my "Soul of the FFF group" is ignited at this moment, it's just because Yuichi almost achieved all good endings and he was made into a scumbag character, and until In the end, I didn't even see who Yuichi liked.
On the other hand, CLANNAD gives the impression that Tomoya's eyes are always attracted to Nagisa, and his help to the other heroines is all in "humanitarian feelings". And Peng also has very clear feelings for them, it's just an ordinary friendship. At this point, the storyline is very clear. The famous "Good Person Card Incident" in the house circle is from CLANNAD, Chapter 18. In that episode, Tomoya sent Good Person Cards to everyone in the drama department except Nagisa, either intentionally or unintentionally. Then this word became the famous "CL18". Although the card has been issued, the subsequent plots did not eliminate these heroines, but they still gathered together to fight for Nagisa Furukawa's dream. This is much stronger than Air and Kanon, both of which are the latter. . . After the route is completed, the mode of grinding and killing the donkey will be removed.
The last reason CLannad was ranked number one by me. . . Because in CLannad, the three major murderous foods of the Key company have all appeared. Needless to say, Aunt Sanae's bread is of course. In the eighth episode of the second season, Nagisa prepared bread for everyone with a bizarre and dazzling rainbow-colored light, and smeared the same color of jam on it. The original words are as follows: "As soon as I said that Haruhara-san was going to have a very important competition, she asked me to bring it, newly made rainbow bread. Dad also asked me to tell you, 'Give you the glory of the rainbow'. And this, it is said to be the ultimate jam from a friend. The mother's bread is coated with this ultimate jam, and the strongest combination is completed! Do you want to try some?"
This friend. . . Obviously Aunt Qiuzi. It's cold all over. . .
As for Guanling juice, it seems that Tomoya and Haruhara often drink it. Sure enough, those who can live in the small town of Guangzaka are all existences outside the standard.
Well, the above three paragraphs are purely hilarious.
The reason why Air ranks second is also very simple. Although the length is a little thin, the plot is not flawed, and the characters of the main characters are relatively full. The daily life of the trio of Huiren, Guanling and Haruko is also quite interesting. Moreover, this is the first TV animation produced by KyoAni independently, so it should be encouraged.
Kanon came in third. . . Well, I admit that it's my resentment from the dead group (the fog).
View more about Clannad: After Story reviews
