Metaphor or projection

Amber 2022-01-20 08:01:28

"Germany Year Zero" is about how a sensible child "degenerates" step by step and then kills his father. On the surface, it looks like a movie discussing the aftereffects of war. After the Second World War, people’s lives and psychological effects are shown by a "child."


But thinking about it further, the pattern of this story is actually:

in the context of the teacher (the powerful), the father (the weak) is finally killed by the child (the tool).
It is the projection of the Nazis on ordinary individuals, and it can also be regarded as a metaphor of micro-knowledge.


The role of the teacher was not clearly defined at the beginning. It may be a "friend" of a vested interest, or it may be just a ruthless businessman. The disc he sold was Hitler’s speech, and the director did not know if he intended to put the image of the teacher on fascism. What he said to his children in a hurry was also extremely cold, "survival of the fittest," and the weak are destined to be eliminated by the strong, more like an instinctive fascist. The director blurs the definition of the character, but adds the title of "teacher" to him, which is an establishment of authority.

The child obeyed the teacher and killed his father. Some people say that the child "thinks that the father is useless to society". I think it is a kind of conjecture. The child is not very conscious in the process of father killing. He is just a tool of the teacher. Rossellini has already told us this before. The child sells discs for the teacher, and the teacher's care for him is only using his means.

The image of the father is mostly established through dialogue. He believes that people should be used to take responsibility. He is deeply guilty of the burden of being a family. He is also an ordinary person who loves life (he describes food in the hospital, saying that it is like heaven), so that a little bit of enrichment, a flesh and blood image . He has no control over reality. One is sick in bed, and the other is "war has taken away my children, and inflation has taken away my property." He is an image of a weak person who is completely powerless to resist.


In fact, whether it is metaphor or not, the director has already achieved his goal of depicting reality.

View more about Germany Year Zero reviews

Extended Reading
  • Camryn 2022-03-20 09:02:41

    Seeing all the distortions caused by the war and the children is always awe-inspiring! 8d111b66-d487-11df-bcc7-0015c55db73d/

  • Kamille 2022-03-21 09:03:04

    Life was taken away like ruins, and desperation drove the child to a dead end. Not atonement but deliverance, the dying child used that nozzle at his forehead and shadow, at the ruins that surrounded him, shot, shot... Here is a tragedy. He hopes to use his explosive body to blow up the ruins here, a sharp passion that has not taken off from the childishness to inflict the bloodiest wounds in the world.

Germany Year Zero quotes

  • Edmund: Is he your brother?

    Christl: Who? Jo? No.

    Edmund: You're always together.

    Christl: So? What about it?

    Edmund: Wherever he goes, you're right behind.

    Christl: And that makes him my brother?

  • Eva: Did you get the Number 2 Card?

    Edmund: No, they kicked me out because I'm not fifteen yet.

    Il padre: I knew that would happen. Still, I'm glad you're not going anywhere. That's too much work for a boy your age.

    Edmund: But it would have meant more to eat. For Karl-Heinz, too.

    Il padre: Did you hear that, Karl-Heinz? You know that poor Edmund, at his age, can't support all of us. He's still a child. But you, what do you do? You keep hiding. You didn't even register for a food card.