Realism is not equal to roughness ("Germany Zero Year" 1948)

Ivy 2022-01-20 08:01:28

"Germania anno zero" (Germania anno zero) is short in the feature film-the version I watched is 74 minutes-the storyline is relatively simple. The Italians went to Germany to make movies. It is doubtful how deep they can be, but it can be seen that although the film is by no means an epic masterpiece, Rossellini is still very delicate in handling.

The first paragraph of the subtitle is annoying moral preaching: "Morality and Christian love should always be the foundation of human life." Leave it alone, and look at it. Rossellini's layout and tailoring can be said to be nuanced. Realism movies are most afraid of being rough. Jia Zhangke’s films are rough in many places. Of course, Master Jia’s "Platform" is a realist boutique, and many Chinese directors known as realists like Ning Ying and Wang Chaolian are realistic. I can't figure out the pulse.

At the beginning, 12-year-old Edmund appeared in the cemetery to dig a grave for 50 grams of margarine, but because he was under 15 years old, he was not even qualified to earn the money. The digging of the grave heralds the end of suicide, and the breath of death quietly spread, pushing the boy to the inevitable tragic ending. Father is sick, brother is weak, sister is gossiped, landlord is ruthless, goes to the black market and is forced to buy things, the girl who first met fools around for food, is used as a tool for money by the old teacher, the boy is struggling until finally because he believes in the teacher Some bastard remarks poisoned his father.

What impressed me the most was the scene in which Edmund's hopes were shattered to death. He told the teacher that he had killed his father according to what he said. He did not expect the teacher to reprimand him. It turned out that the teacher did not really believe in the philosophy of "competition for survival" as he said. Edmund was desperate. When he walked to the street, a few children were playing football. He approached and kicked two feet. The children took the ball and left. As a father killer, he is no longer considered a child. He walked and played a game of grid jumping, as if to keep his innocence. Climbing up the ruined wall, he saw his father's coffin being taken away by truck. Life is about to be ruined. He played a slide on the inclined steel column for the last time, bid farewell to his childhood, and then jumped off. Edmund survived the flames of World War II, but died in the rubble of German rebirth.

"Germany Year Zero" also has its bluntness. One is the recording of Edmund selling Hitler's speech to American soldiers. Hitler said, "The future of Germany is infinitely bright." The director turned the camera to the ruins, and Hitler's passionate voice echoed. The other is when Edmont is heading towards death, Rossellini inserted the church organ music and footage. Too deliberate, weakened the power of the film. However, in general, this is a good movie.

Shadow Kingdom http://buckzhao.blogspot.com/

View more about Germany Year Zero reviews

Extended Reading

Germany Year Zero quotes

  • Karl-Heinz: Who gave you money to buy cigarettes?

    Edmund: It was a gift.

    Karl-Heinz: From who? Those bad boys you go stealing with?

    Edmund: It wasn't boys. It was a girl.

    Karl-Heinz: You should be ashamed of yourself.

    Edmund: Why? Everybody does it.

    Karl-Heinz: That's not a reason.

    Edmund: Her name is Christl. She's all alone, and she sleeps in a basement. She's a nice girl. I like her. She gives cigarettes to all her friends. You should have a woman to take care of you.

    Karl-Heinz: A woman? That's all I need. Like this bitch of a life wasn't enough.

    Edmund: Don't talk like that! Have courage!

    Karl-Heinz: I had courage. A soldier can lose everything but his courage. But now I'm not a soldier anymore. I'm less than useless, another mouth to feed.

  • Il medico: His heart is very weak. His whole condition is bad.

    Eva: What can we do?

    Il medico: He needs nutritrious foods, vitamins.

    Eva: How can we do that, Doctor?

    Edmund: With the cards we have, we can't get more

    Il medico: Yes, I know. It's the same all over. The best thing would be to get him into a hospital. But they are all more than full.

    Karl-Heinz: Couldn't we at least try, Doctor?

    Il medico: Cases worse than his have not been admitted.