The nature of the "rule and widow" in this world

Rosemarie 2022-01-17 08:03:45

Movie opening scene

If the theme of the movie can be refined according to personal taste, I think the theme of this movie is-many tyrannical.

The big scene at the beginning of the movie is magnificent, majestic, and solemn, like a military parade in a prosperous empire, but it is just a dilapidated dream, and all the people in the background are bullying the poor worm named Dreyfus.

After that, a large number of crowd shots appeared in the film, and the crowd always gave people a kind of oppression, so that they could not breathe:

The protagonist Picard complied with his own conscience. It seemed that he decided to stand on the side of justice easily. This is personal courage, and on the one hand, it is also due to the not too tense political environment.

The scene where Picard turned to leave the general was like the scene in Kubrick's "Road to Glory."

"I Accuse" Picard retorted when he left the general

"Road to Glory" Dax turned and left

"Road to Glory" Dax rebuts General

The light and shadow of the film are very similar to solemn oil paintings. This arrangement is like "restore history". In other words, it is a coffin to conclude history with the sense of oil painting, but the interesting thing is that these pictures always smell some funnyness. :

A serious face

This seems to be refuting the "coffining the coffin" itself. The seemingly nailed history is actually nothing more than a projection of the emotions of the masses.

The end of the film is a reversal of the whole film, and it seems to tell the audience-what you see is what I want you to see.

Dreyfus was projected into a villain by the collective emotions, and Picard was projected as a hero by the masses of today. God knows one day Dreyfus will not become a villain again, and Picard will become a stubborn reactionary. Just like Cui Yongyuan's mother taught him: "Don't think that the people like you, you are amazing, this group of people, Liu Shaoqi has been defeated by them."

I don’t want to think of Polanski’s dilemma at this time. I only remember Polanski once commented on "Eavesdropping Storm." He said that in that political environment, no monitor would conscientiously find out. In "The Accusation", the reason Picard can conscientiously find out is only because of the "not bad" political environment. In fact, his "sense of justice" finally became the capital for him to step into the bureaucracy...

Perhaps "justice" itself is as described by Serasumachos-but it is the benefit of the strong.

In most times, the strong are the "people."

View more about An Officer and a Spy reviews

Extended Reading
  • Oma 2022-03-27 09:01:18

    The atmosphere of the opening scene is very intimidating, the somber and solemn tone, the neat and precise composition, the smooth movement of the camera and the scheduling, the whole film maintains sophisticated audio-visual language skills, and still stabilizes the suspense under the premise of knowing the result early. Standard work. This event that shook French society (even Proust used it as a sign of the times in Remembrance) is almost a slice of current events in Europe, reproducing the long history of anti-Semitism in Europe (a few in the opening paragraphs). The officers talked about the eradication of the Jews as the eradication of the plague, and there is a historical fact that the origin of the plague was blamed on the Jews). Although Dreyfus is at the center of the storm, Dreyfus is on the edge of the narrative, so the viewer can look at the big picture from a more objective distance without deliberately substituting a role. "Aurora" shows the courage to face the truth with a series of "I accuse" comparisons. More than a hundred years ago, individuals, news media and literary creators who put their safety at risk have clearly maintained an independent attitude and a clear head, followed the How precious is the conscience of truth and justice, perhaps even more meaningful in comparison with today's reality.

  • Aryanna 2022-04-21 09:03:07

    The classical style comes from pre-modern non-subjectivity. In the first half of "I Complain", in the film about the Dreyfus incident, Dreyfus is just an object that appears in a telescope to be observed. In this way, "I Indict" isolates emotion and avoids the temptation of individual-institutional political narratives. It is difficult to determine whether Polanski was referring to public allegations of his social events, and if there were, it was an elegant and razor-sharp pushback. Therefore, "I Complain" does not lack strength and power, and it is not completely classical. The first half of the film and the second half are in a mirror-image relationship. Picard, who is the "detective" image, exits the stage, and Dreyfus himself appears, and gradually finds his own identity. The subjectivity of the modern subject.

An Officer and a Spy quotes

  • Picquart: I want to see the Dreyfuss file.

  • Picquart: Dreyfuss is innocent.