A footnote to individual and liberalism

Clarabelle 2022-02-20 08:01:13

The film is well-formed and the suspense setting is relatively old-fashioned. The contradictions are mainly concentrated on the street homeless people, whether their lives are still worthwhile, and whether they can be deprived of their lives without their consent. Life, for the lives of more people?
I remembered a story I read a long time ago. A group of children were playing on the railroad tracks. Only one child was sober and warned them of danger, but no one else listened. Soon the train came. Should this sober kid pull the gate and change the direction of the tracks, at the expense of himself to save the destiny of most people? There is still no standard answer, but most people think that he does not need to pay for the mistakes of others with his own life, just because others are the majority?
Of course, this film does not have the majority of the people making mistakes, so it does not mean "atonement for the public". It is more like a sacrifice that is not voluntary. The moral judgments given by the film are also clear, even if you think theirs Life is meaningless, and you have no right to force others to rewrite your own life.
In fact, the meaning and value of life are often considered to be added. In China, a country with an atheistic tradition, will I be immortal after my death or be forgotten by the world? What is the difference from myself? I can't experience anything. But in a religious belief, especially a belief that clearly explains the whereabouts of a person after death, this meaning of life may be even more important. In the movie, the "evil professor" thinks that he is taking the life of the tramp to help them go to heaven. This second reason makes sense in the Christian discourse system, but you also did not decide what others want. Going to heaven is the right to go to hell. Human freedom has been elevated to a higher position than religion to some extent. This is the manifestation of human rights transcending divine power.
The United States is such a country that pursues individualism and liberalism. This film makes a classic footnote to the human rights it advocates.

View more about Extreme Measures reviews

Extended Reading
  • Krystel 2022-02-20 08:01:13

    3.5 Very solid, horse face acting is a bit poor

  • Gabe 2022-03-20 09:02:27

    The first part of the story that ROSE arranged for us to watch is too slow and the latter part is okay

Extreme Measures quotes

  • Dr. Lawrence Myrick: I'm 68 years old, I don't have much time. Three years with a rat to get to a dog, and after five years - if I'm lucky - maybe I can work on a chimp? We have to move faster than that. I'm doing medicine here no one's ever DREAMED of! This is baseline neuro-chemistry, Guy!

    Dr. Guy Luthan: You're killing people.

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: [Shrugs] People die every day. For what? For nothing. Plane crash, train wreck? Bosnia - pick your tragedy. Sniper in a restaurant, fifteen dead, story at eleven. What do we do? What do you do? You change the channel, you move on to the next patient. You take care of the ones you think you can save. Good doctors do the correct thing - GREAT doctors have the guts to do the right thing. Your father had those guts. So do you. Two patients on either side of the room - one a gold-plated cop, the other a maniac that pulled a gun on a city bus. Who do you work on first? You knew, Guy. You knew. If you could cure cancer by killing one person, wouldn't you have to do that? Wouldn't that be the brave thing to do? One person and cancer's gone tomorrow. You thought you were paralyzed. What would you have done to be able to walk again? Anything. You said it yourself. Anything. You were like that for... twenty four hours.

    [Puts his hands on Helen's shoulders]

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: Helen hasn't walked for twelve years. I can cure her... and everyone like her. The door's open. You can go out there and... put a stop to everything and it'll all be over. Or we can go upstairs and change medicine forever. It's your call, Guy.

    Helen: [after a nervous pause] ... Guy?

    Dr. Guy Luthan: ...maybe you're right. Those men upstairs, maybe... there isn't much point to their lives. Maybe they are doing a great thing for the world. Maybe they are heroes.

    [Helen and Dr. Myrick look relieved]

    Dr. Guy Luthan: But they didn't choose to be. You chose for them. You didn't choose your wife... or your granddaughter... you didn't ask for volunteers. You chose for them, and you can't do that. Because you're a doctor. Because you took an oath. And you're not God. So I don't care, I don't care if you can do what you say you can. I don't care if you can find a cure for every disease on this planet! You tortured and murdered those men upstairs. And that makes you a disgrace to your profession. And I hope you go to jail for the rest of your life.

    [Helen begins to cry]

    Dr. Guy Luthan: ... I'm sorry.

  • Dr. Lawrence Myrick: I've seen your chart, it's a terrible thing. I'd like to try to help.

    Dr. Guy Luthan: [not looking at him] If you want to help me... let me die.

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: That's a common request.

    Dr. Guy Luthan: Please... 400 of potassium chloride in my IV.

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: ...What if there was hope?

    Dr. Guy Luthan: No. There isn't.

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: [more pointedly] What if there was hope? What would it be worth, to be able to walk again, to be able to feed yourself? To go back to your old life, to be a doctor? What would you endure?

    Dr. Guy Luthan: [finally looks at him] What are you talking about?

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: I'm asking you a question. What do you think that would be worth?

    Dr. Guy Luthan: I can't live like this.

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: With proper care, you can live 20 years like this. What would you do? What would you risk to change that?

    Dr. Guy Luthan: [stubbornly] I have a C6 break in my cord.

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: What if I told you that there was a chance you could be healed? That there was a procedure that offered you... a good chance... that you might walk again? What would you do to make that happen?

    Dr. Guy Luthan: ...Anything.

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: Anything?

    [takes off his glasses]

    Dr. Lawrence Myrick: You'd better think about that.

    [leaves]

    Dr. Guy Luthan: What do you mean? What do you mean? Wait! Dr. Myrick? Dr. Myrick!