Twenty-five years later I will be you w

Vinnie 2022-01-15 08:02:24

Can't write a short comment.

The image of the Cloud of Maloja runs through, seemingly true and illusory, and erratic. It is not only the unwillingness of Mary who is no longer young to grasp the tail of youth and indulging in the glory of the years, but also the insecurity of encountering the crisis of middle age.
The form of the play in the play, while giving the story a deep level, allowed the three female characters to have an interesting "dual role substitution" and observe each other, deriving a richer emotional expression.

There are many disputes about the two roles in the play, and most of them are considered from their own standpoint. I personally agree with the director’s view of the play: Helen and Sigrid are the same person (after Shaoguang is no longer the same person), they are not the same person ( Different desires).

Maria was Sigrid 25 years ago, will she still be 25 years later?
Obviously, Maria herself thinks so, so she strongly rejects Helen's role.
Especially in the interaction with Valentin, he was aggressive and oppressive, so Valentin finally left (meaning "suicide").

But in reality, everything around reminds her that she has become Helen, whether it is incomprehensible sci-fi movies, popular pop idols that are incomprehensible, or the current world that Maria has been far away from ( Or reality), which is why Valentine would say "a sense of distance from you".

In the end, it was Sigrid who woke her up—Valentine’s departure and Ellis’ refusal—he was indeed no longer Sigrid, but he did not necessarily become Helen—not toward self-destruction, but to compromise with the new world. (Accept the invitation of science fiction movies), even if they don't agree.

View more about Clouds of Sils Maria reviews

Extended Reading

Clouds of Sils Maria quotes

  • Maria Enders: Jo-Ann?

    Jo-Ann Ellis: What's up?

    Maria Enders: I wanted to ask you. You know the scene at the beginning of Act 3 when you tell me you want to leave and I get on my knees and I beg you to stay? You're on the phone ordering pepperoncini pizza for your coworkers in accounting. You leave without looking at me. As if I didn't exist. If you could pause for a second. Helena's distress would last longer when she's left alone in her office. Well, the way you're playing it, the audience follows you out but instantly forgets about her. So...

    Jo-Ann Ellis: So? So what?

    Maria Enders: When, when I played Sigrid I held it longer. I thought it was more powerful. Erotically. I mean, it really played well.

    Jo-Ann Ellis: No one gives a fuck about Helena at that point, do they? I'm sorry, it's pretty clear to me that this woman is all washed up. I mean, your character, Maria, not you. And when Sigrid leaves Helena's office, Helena's a wreck, and we get it. You know, it's time to move on. I think they want what comes next.

    Maria Enders: If you just held it a few seconds longer.

    Jo-Ann Ellis: It doesn't really feel right for me, Maria.

    Maria Enders: You're right. Yeah. I - I - I think I'm - I'm lost in my memories. You think you've forgotten your old habits, but their all - they all come back. Have to break them.

    Jo-Ann Ellis: I guess you do!

  • Piers Roaldson: [Piers proposes new movie mutant role for Maria] I'm trying to consider genetics from a more human point of view.

    Maria Enders: When I was reading it, I imagined someone much younger. Maybe me younger, actually, but you were seeing me in movies that were made years ago. I - I've changed.

    Piers Roaldson: She has no age. Or else, she's every age at once. Like all of us.

    Maria Enders: Can I be frank? Maybe it's because I'm working with her, but as I was reading it, I - I kept thinking about Jo-Ann.

    Piers Roaldson: Yeah, well personally, I never think about Jo-Ann Ellis.

    Maria Enders: You're wrong. She's smart. And talented. She's modern, just like your character.

    Piers Roaldson: My character isn't modern. Not in that way, anyway. She's, outside of time.

    Maria Enders: Outside of time. I don't understand. It's too abstract for me. It's all right.

    Piers Roaldson: I - I don't like this era.

    Maria Enders: You're wrong. It's yours!

    Piers Roaldson: Amen! I didn't choose it.

    Maria Enders: [laughs]

    Piers Roaldson: And if my era is Jo-Ann Ellis and viral Internet scandals I think I'm entitled to feel unrelated, aren't I. I mean, it's nothing against her, I guess I just assumed you'd understand.