Bergman's film notes "Screams and Whispers": April 20, 1971

Alana 2022-01-11 08:02:34


·The first is a question of virtual and real. The fact that Angenis is terminally ill is the real deal. Bergman does not have general problems such as the old cause, symptom, treatment, etc., but only shows pain and death, which is a futility. When Angnis died and resurrected, Bergman made such illusory and miraculous things quite real and believable, without smearing surreal colors, this is turning the fiction into reality. Wandering between the real and the illusion has always been Bergman's masterpiece, and the earliest source should be "Sawdust and Fragment".

·There are two narratives, one is Maria’s entanglement with the doctor and her husband, the other is Karin’s entanglement with her husband, both of which are past events. Bergman inserted the narrative of the former before the death of Angelis, and The latter was inserted after his death.
With homogenous selfishness and indifference, Maria presents a posture of desire and use, while Karin is a posture of rejection and harm.

·Why use Bergman's narration and Maria's monologue at the same time? This is something I have not been able to understand.

·The rustling of clothes, the ticking of clocks and the whispers of people. Especially the first one, filled the movie space like air. It inspired me a lot.

· Karin broke a wine glass during dinner with her husband. Was there something wrong with the editing of the scene where her husband looked up? He felt that the movement of raising his eyes was left too much, almost one-third of a second.

·Ingrid Turin's pubic hair is golden? What kind of race is she? Celtic?

Bergman still uses some of his previous techniques, including what I call "close-up sports long shots," which I really like.

·Angonis maintained the relationship with the other women. This was shown at the beginning of the movie, and when she died, they tried to re-establish another relationship. They failed. They failed miserably. Bergman didn't want to abstract the movie. The four women took their bodies as a reflection of their spirits, and each body clearly pointed in one direction.
This is a good method, not obscure, not to play with the audience.

· Karin is me, Anna is me, Maria is me, and Agnes is me, even the fucking self-harming husband is me.
No one can get out of the movie unscathed.

View more about Cries & Whispers reviews

Extended Reading

Cries & Whispers quotes

  • Anna: [reading Agnes' journal entry] "Wednesday, the third of September. A chill in the air tells of autumn's approach, but the days are still lovely and mild. My sisters, Karin and Maria, have come to see me. It's wonderful to be together again like in the old days. I'm feeling much better. We were even able to take a stroll together. It was a wonderful experience, especially for me, since I haven't been outdoors for so long. We suddenly began to laugh and run toward the old swing that we hadn't used since we were children. We sat in it like three good little sisters and Anna pushed us, slowly and gently. All my aches and pains were gone. The people I'm most fond of in all the world were with me. I could hear them chatting around me. I could feel the presence of their bodies, the warmth of their hands. I wanted to cling to that moment, and I thought, "Come what may, this is happiness. I cannot wish for anything better. Now, for a few minutes, I can experience perfection and I feel profoundly grateful to my life, which gives me so much."

  • David: Come here, Marie. Come. Look in the mirror. You're beautiful. Perhaps even more than when we were together. But you've changed and I want you to see how. Now your eyes cast quick, calculating, side glances. You used to look ahead straightforwardly, openly, without disguise. Your mouth has a slightly hungry, dissatisfied expression. It used to be so soft. Your complexion is pale now. You wear makeup. Your fine, wide brow has four lines above each eye now. You can't see them in this light, but you can in the bright of day. You know what caused those lines?

    Maria: No.

    David: Indifference. And this fine contour from your ear to your chin is no longer so finely drawn - the result of too much comfort and laziness. And there, by the bridge of your nose. Why do you sneer so often? You see that? You sneer too often. You see it? And look under your eyes. The sharp, scarcely noticeable wrinkles from your boredom and impatience.

    Maria: Can you really see all that there?

    David: No, but I feel it when you kiss me.

    Maria: I think you're joking with me. I know where you see it.

    David: Where?

    Maria: In yourself. Because you and I are so alike.

    David: You mean in our selfishness, coldness and indifference?