The 2019 version of the Battle of Midway is compared with the 1976 version!

Guido 2022-05-30 19:29:41

I watched it in January, and watched it again today. Especially compared to the Battle of Midway that was screened some time ago, the two movies have their own merits! First of all, the timeline. The 2019 version started with the attack on Pearl Harbor, then the Tokyo air raid on the Coral Sea to Midway Island, and the 1976 version started with the Tokyo air raid as the reason for the Japanese army to accelerate preparations for the battle of Midway Island! Secondly, the plot shaping of the two films are basically true to historical facts and have their own emphasis. The 2019 version is mainly from the perspective of pilots, and 1976 is more comprehensive. However, the bloody transnational love makes people feel superfluous! Thirdly, for the production of the film, the 2019 version chose new actors instead, and the main actors were Alita supporting roles. However, the technological development, the magnificent battle scenes, and the subjective shots of the dive bombing made people breathless; the 1976 version Instead, the star clusters include Henry Fonda and Mifune Toshiro. The main war scenes were absolutely top-notch in the 1970s. Many of them are now studio shots. In addition to editing some historical real pictures, there is no sense of disobedience! There is also a lens for the first angle of view of the dive bombing! Finally, the characters of the 2019 version are fuller, including the mechanic, which is impressive; the 1976 version is a group play, there is no outstanding character image, but the longest fluttering hair Haruko? But for details, 1976 was more detailed than 2019, including the York City aircraft carrier was repaired a few days after the Battle of the Coral Sea and participated in the Battle of Midway Island, while the Japanese followed the American plane and found the York City and suffered another severe damage; and US intelligence. The department determined that AF is a small trick played by Midway Island. The 1976 version has detailed performances, but the 2019 version has it in one sentence; there are also reconnaissance flights by reconnaissance aircraft on both sides before the start of the war. Japanese reconnaissance aircraft took off half an hour late, and there was another reconnaissance. The problem with the machine-transmitting system allowed the United States to take the lead, and the 1976 version performed well! All in all, the two movies have their own advantages. It is recommended to watch them. The visual effects of the 2019 version are excellent, and the historical facts are more complete is the 1976 version!

View more about Midway reviews

Extended Reading

Midway quotes

  • Captain Garth: Admiral, Commander Rochefort has something he would like to tell you.

    Commander Rochefort: It's about objective AF, sir, the meaning of AF. Now, our listening posts have been picking up alot of traffic between Yamamoto's staff commanders.

    Captain Garth: There has been a heavy volume of traffic, sir, with the recurring references to Objective AF and... what was the other one?

    Commander Rochefort: AO. Now, AO is still a mystery, Admiral, maybe a diverson, but I think we've identified Objective AF as Midway. Now, it really had us stymied there, until one of my men remembered an enemy intercept we decoded last March. Now, a Jap reconnaissance pilot radioed his base that he was passing close to AF. Now we plotted every possible course this plane might have taken, and the only appreciable land mass he could have overflown at the time was Midway.

    Captain Garth: Joe...

    Commander Rochefort: Look, I know it's thin...

    Admiral Nimitz: Thin? Damn near invisible.

    Commander Rochefort: But I found a way to confirm it, sir.

    [Takes out a message and passes it to Nimitz]

    Commander Rochefort: If you will have this flown to Midway. It's a fake message, sir, reporting that Midway's fresh water condenser has broken down. Now, it should be transmitted in the clear, so there's no question of Japanese operators getting every word of it.

    Admiral Nimitz: [Smiles and nods, passing it over to Blake] Instruct Midway to include that in their housekeeping traffic tomorrow.

    Lieutenant Commander Ernest L. Blake: Aye, sir.

  • Captain Vinton Maddox: Admiral, these enemy radio intercepts that your intelligence unit has been accumulating...

    Admiral Nimitz: Very detailed, aren't they?

    Captain Vinton Maddox: Too damned detailed, Admiral. Do you remember what happened just before December 7th?

    Admiral Nimitz: The Japanese flooded the airwaves with fake messages.

    Captain Vinton Maddox: Yes. These could be carbon copies. Washington's convinced that Yamamoto's feeding this stuff to you in order to cover his real intentions.

    Admiral Nimitz: Very definite possibility.

    Captain Vinton Maddox: Well then, sir, how can you still insist...

    Admiral Nimitz: Because it is my judgement that this information is factual. I'm convinced Yamamoto's target is Midway.

    Captain Vinton Maddox: If you're wrong, Admiral, if you send our carriers into a Japanese ambush, the entire west coast and Hawaiian islands will be wide open for invasion.

    Admiral Nimitz: I'm fully aware of that, Captain. You're saying the safe play is to defend the home folks first.

    Captain Vinton Maddox: With respects, Admiral, it's the smart play.

    Admiral Nimitz: Captain, if we surprise the enemy, catch him where he doesn't think we'll be, we can drive him back 3000 miles. And keep him pinned 'til we're ready to take him on his own front yard.

    Captain Vinton Maddox: Sir, my instructions were to convey Washington's deep concern for the safety of the west coast and the Hawaiian islands. That is, if...

    Admiral Nimitz: Captain Maddox, is Washington ordering me to defend against an attack here or the west coast?

    Captain Vinton Maddox: No, sir. My orders were simply to consult. No, sir, I have no such orders for you.

    Admiral Nimitz: Commander Blake, declare a state of fleet-opposed invasion. Target... Midway Island. Issue the order immediately.

    Lieutenant Commander Ernest L. Blake: Aye, aye, sir.